I waited so long for this game to come out. I love pirates and Sea games. I love the concept and the content that is in the game is amazing and it looks great. the game has so much potential. All I see are reviews and posts about how there is nothing to do in the game and I agree. It brings me to tears to say this but they didnt deliver what was promised. all of the content aka 3 factions are just fetch quests around the same outline. all the cosemtics add nothing but looks and its just reskins that cost way to much. Please I want to love this game as much as i am convincing myself that it is going to get better. bring up points that show how good the game is and share your hopefull stories with me that this game will get better and not b the let down that everyone claims it is.
Please help convince me!
I think what a lot of people are criticizing the game about is the lack of content, which I can see. But Sea of Thieves isn't just about doing quests, it's about going on and playing with your friends and doing whatever you want. So it's really just your play style and if you don't really like the game now, I don't think it's for you. But, I do believe they will be adding more content in the future, considering the games only been out for a couple days.
@matt92099 Many might post "what a let down, or OMgosh not enough content" here i say, the game was released 2 days ago. It has the potential to evolve. Ive been MMO gaming for over 16 yrs and still haven't found a game with out glitches at launch. Just know that MANY more are saying that the game is great. If you want to try it and have an Xbox, use their feature for a month and try it. I do believe you can still do the same if you have a pc. Personally I like the game a lot. I cant wait till i can get my crew to sail with me. If you decide that this is for you, Look me up and we can sail the seas together. :)
@endiozo i pre orderd the game and have played it, I love it im just looking for people to tell me they think there is a future for the game and more content b/c atm every single review/post is about how the game is basically contentless and not going to go anywhere. I want to love them game but I cant help but see how ... they might be right
@gamerknight0316 I think you missed my point weather it was how I wrote it or your interpretation. I love the game. and I really want to keep loving it. my problem is i am reading all these reviews and post about how bad the game is and at first i want to defend the game. but then i realize ... some of what they say is true. thats why i posted this. I want to be reconvinced they are wrong and that its just crazy talk.
@finanzminister i got the preorder, I wouldnt say im diappointed just empty. I love the game and have a blast with my friends. the problem and reason for this post is i cant stop and not realize what all the reviews are saying is true. i want to love this game but the limited barebones structure needs some meat on it. i Hope more content will come and i want to see like minded people and share there hope stories i want to be reassured that this game will defy all the negative reviews and b*****e out of the water like the trailers did.
@matt92099 wont happen, either the game recovers like the division or rainbow six siege did or it will sink.
as positiv as i am be i believe rare will make this game a long run hit but i wont convince anyone.
@matt92099 https://www.seaofthieves.com/forum/topic/41360/tldr-post-with-last-night-and-how-this-game-is-contentless
You tell me if that does not convince you.....
I don't really understand the criticism. The game is exactly what was advertised. Cosmetics only to allow new players to join without disadvantage. That was kind of a key selling point. 3 types of quests offering a different experience each.
I'll give you my experiences. I play with my family. Sometimes it's two of us in a sloop or 3-4 of us in a galleon. We start out with a voyage from one of the quest givers. It always varies what we choose. We mark our point on the map and set sail.
Along the way we may spot a shipwreck and we dive down and collect the loot. We will hit an island that we are destined for and fill our ship with whatever isn't nailed to the floor. Perhaps we hit another shipwreck or often we find messages in bottles.
We've encountered players wanting pvp and we usually oblige them. So by the time we finish our voyage it's been hours and we've sailed most of the map and had a great time! We hand in our cargo and rake in our gold and reputation. If we are close to leaving the game we may hit the pub and enjoy a pint or two.
My entire family loves this game. We have hard core FPS players and casual sandbox players as well. There is something for all of us. If you can't find the pleasure in that, then you don't need convincing, you need a different game.
I have to say that most of the critics say there is no depth, but is more biased to missing content that helps one become more powerful, in a sense.
My understanding of this game is not a PVP, where the most powerful pirate with the most powerful equipment rules the seas. It is more about everyone being on the same playing field.
With that in mind i think the game is well balanced with plenty of opportunity to do what you want in the game. If you feel like adventuring and finding hidden treasure and sunken ships you can. If you feel like a ruthless pirate and searching for other pirates to steal their hard earned treasure you can.
Only your imagination is the the limit.
@zoarialgiant284 i have just read your post. i agree that sounds fun but when you break it down you just wrote an amazing story of how you had some ship battles went to an island fought some ai and players then turned in some chests aka a fetch quest with some player pvp and ai pvp mixed in. thats what im saying even the wildest adventures and still barebones you did a fetch quest but what else is there. I have Ship battle and got chests to bring back and sell now what? rinse and repeat?
@matt92099 Ahoy there, I've been on the forums for a long time, I don't recall whether it was said that progression would be any other than cosmetic?
I've played a lot of hours in the game and I love it. I particularly love the world and the sailing, the fact that every play session is different in some way or another. I love that I don't have to do the quests, I can spend a couple of hours searching for shipwrecks, scouring islands for bottles, books and other items which I can sell to the traders or dig up the lucrative rewards from the bottles.
It's my choice and if I so wish, I can keep my hard earned gold and not spend a penny of it because actually I don't need to level up, get the latest gear or customise my ship into the ss enterprise.
I really enjoy that it's some of the encounters with other players that add richness to the whole experience whether they be friend or foe. I like that there are no pvp leaderboards, that I'm not having to constantly strive to be 'best', that I can't actually 'fail' at this game because it's all down to my choices and not what the game is telling me I 'must do'.
What type of content were you hoping to see?
Fun game. We always want to do loads of quests but end up messing around. Next thing we know 6 hours have gone by.
I'm looking forward to the weekly/monthly quests/events and all the free dlc that might start arriving in a few months.
It is definitely a game you need to try. You will always have haters and lovers. It's what humans do best. The game pass option is so good. Try it for the free two weeks. Then carry on paying £7.99 a month or buy it. 😁
@matt92099 said in Please help convince me!:
@zoarialgiant284 i have just read your post. i agree that sounds fun but when you break it down you just wrote an amazing story of how you had some ship battles went to an island fought some ai and players then turned in some chests aka a fetch quest with some player pvp and ai pvp mixed in. thats what im saying even the wildest adventures and still barebones you did a fetch quest but what else is there. I have Ship battle and got chests to bring back and sell now what? rinse and repeat?
Well you have to ask yourself, what do you want exactly? for me it was an amazing time, it was on the edge of my seat for the entire duration, was that not what you are playing for? the thrill of the game? Are you expecting big game rewards or "EPIQS!!!!" that's not gonna happen, at least not for now. Now for the rince and repeat, no, the next engagement will be different, maybe we will have a powder keg and we get to explode it on their ship, or ram an enemy ship in another enemy ship :D you never know (Regarding the rince and repeat is it not the same in RL? go to work/school, come back, play a game or go out sleep rince repeat?)
@katttruewalker I love your response you go on and on about great things in the game are which is what i wanted to see so i thank you. i just want to see more things to keep me interested. i agree i love the freedom. heres where it gets tricky for me. i love sailing, a month from now im gonna need more then just the sailing to keep me interested. i love exploring. a month from now you would have explored everything. finding bottles is cool but it just brings you back to a fetch quest infact the only thing exploring leads to is turing in items aka fetch quest. i love sea battles but for one they only happen everyso often and you dont really gain anything from them MOST of the time not all but most. you can spend money on the limited cosemtics there are. (needs to be a lot more as that is simply disappointing for how long they had to make them). if your not spending the money why bother getting it. I simply want more to do in the world and with eachother, what that is im not really sure atm i just hope i find it eventually. im worried about the longevity of the current game as the like 4 basic things are going to wear out.
@matt92099 I understand what you're saying and I think part of my enjoyment comes from playing through the alpha's beta's etc and seeing that new content added regularly.
From what we know, Sea of Thieves is a 'game as service', which means there will be regular updates of content and mechanics. There is already a huge heap of feedback, reviews and suggestions all over the media and forums and I am certain that Rare are taking note of these and looking at their current roadmap.
There are also a bunch of articles from a press release in February which outline a little more about what is coming in the future which might assuage your concerns a little -
https://www.seaofthieves.com/forum/topic/30834/list-of-news-articles-february-press-embargo-lifted
I really just grind, doing the Basic loop.
but i can agree in some degree ;) but when I hear comments like that on the forum, I just think "come sail with me" an Ill show you what this game is about.The tools in game is just for you to create some fun Voyage.
Doing the Npc Voyage, just put u out there in the world to be a friend or a danger to us all.they could remove all cosmetic gear, an ill still sail the seas.
dont get me wrong, I love some of the cosmetic gear ;)Hmm, i noticed some similarity between SoT and another game (that has floating islands, dont know if i can mention it on forum) and that game has an island creator for people to submit for review to the devs as to implement them in the game, maybe this feature will be made for the game too, as i understood from diferent posts and such, content is coming under diferent forms, so i would wait for that. I see the game like a type of battle royale game + ships sea and some sidequests, troll people, dont just sink them, board them, lower their anchor, hide and dont shoot, make them question their sanity, board them take the treasure and move it but leave it on the ship, board them while shooting people out of the cannon at them (a lot of people forget that that is in the game) watch them panic and laugh at how they start shouting on the voice chat. I understand that you will say that it will wear out, but why should it? Arent other games like battle royale players getting worn out? no because they find ways to entertain themselves, teabagging mostly or killing and dancing on the corpse, you can do that here even sing them a song!
@s1l3nt and @KattTruewalker This is why i made this post i had the same mindset as you s1l3nt but i want people to try and show otherwise. unlike you i love the game and just need a bit of reassurance its gonna get better someone help s1l3nt change thier minds XD
@matt92099 said in Please help convince me!:
@s1l3nt and @KattTruewalker This is why i made this post i had the same mindset as you s1l3nt but i want people to try and show otherwise. unlike you i love the game and just need a bit of reassurance its gonna get better someone help s1l3nt change thier minds XD
Friendly fire! I am on your side! Re-read my comment!!!
@s1l3nt Hmm well it is a pvp orriented game, the missions i think are only there to get you to the pvp engagement, i am not here to make excuses (i need to get payed for that first :D) but saying that there are only 5 things to do is clumping it up quite a lot. Its like saying that what you do at work is just that you......"work" and that's it nothing in detail and showing the fun or reason you work there
@zoarialgiant284 said in Please help convince me!:
@s1l3nt Hmm well it is a pvp orriented game, the missions i think are only there to get you to the pvp engagement, i am not here to make excuses (i need to get payed for that first :D) but saying that there are only 5 things to do is clumping it up quite a lot.
Please do name the things to do in game which you earn a reward for doing. I'll wait....
and its not a PvP anything. It was advertised as a open world sandbox pirate sailing adventure game. There just is only 5 things to do to get rewards. 3 of which (Collect chests, collect skulls, collect animals) are essentially the same thing. The 4th is a larger scale of the first three. The 5th well it gets boring wrecking kids and finding a seafarer chest over and over. Repetitive game is repetitive.
@zoarialgiant284 said in Please help convince me!:
@s1l3nt Edited the reply, you beat me to the post.
Believe me when I say I only do the job I do because I make the money I do. If you want to translate that into the game then its completely accurate for me there as well. I play whichever gets me the most gains unless I am in a crew then I just play whatever majority wants to do and focus on enjoying the experience of group gaming. There lies a problem when everyone says which missions you want to do and everyone says I don't care. Face it the game is bland. Amazing in most aspects but bland when it comes to content.
@s1l3nt And other "Battle royale" (Something-nite),"Some shooter that had a 1.6 version" and other games are not repetitive? But they are still fun to people that play it, maybe you do not like the game and find it lacking content, but they did not launch anything less then what they advertized, i consider that i will have fun in the following weeks/months with it, (also why you are only finding poor chests is because everyone is only starting out and dont have rep to buy any high lvl quests).
@zoarialgiant284 said in Please help convince me!:
@s1l3nt And other "Battle royale" (Something-nite),"Some shooter that had a 1.6 version" and other games are not repetitive? But they are still fun to people that play it, maybe you do not like the game and find it lacking content, but they did not launch anything less then what they advertized, i consider that i will have fun in the following weeks/months with it, (also why you are only finding poor chests is because everyone is only starting out and dont have rep to buy any high lvl quests).
Did you just try and relate a Battle Royale game genre in comparison to features in a group based sailing sandbox game lol.
@s1l3nt said in Please help convince me!:
@zoarialgiant284 said in Please help convince me!:
@s1l3nt Hmm well it is a pvp orriented game, the missions i think are only there to get you to the pvp engagement, i am not here to make excuses (i need to get payed for that first :D) but saying that there are only 5 things to do is clumping it up quite a lot.
Please do name the things to do in game which you earn a reward for doing. I'll wait....
and its not a PvP anything. It was advertised as a open world sandbox pirate sailing adventure game. There just is only 5 things to do to get rewards. 3 of which (Collect chests, collect skulls, collect animals) are essentially the same thing. The 4th is a larger scale of the first three. The 5th well it gets boring wrecking kids and finding a seafarer chest over and over. Repetitive game is repetitive.
You see this is almost the opposite of the reasons I enjoy the game - different strokes for different folks, the question is how can Rare balance this while maintaining the unique qualities that it has already? I don't want a Black Desert style mmorpg, nor do I want a Dayz-on-the-Sea, so compromise is in order?
@s1l3nt Why is it group based? are you forced to play with others? You can play solo and have a blast at it, i know i have, trolling people a lot while not having a boat on an island while they came to cash in, and regarding the comparrison (something-nite) was advertised as an OpenWorld Sandbox game (with sessions), that had a spin in the gamemodes at the last minute.
@matt92099 said in Please help convince me!:
It brings me to tears to say this but they didnt deliver what was promised.
Not the first thread, but it's Friday so I don't have anything better to do than to ask this again. Could you please link me an official press release, forum post or at least something which is from Rare and describes facts about SoT which were promised but are not implemented in the game?
I am almost sure you can't. People really imagined a lot just because they wanted/heard something/thought it's another MMORPG/etc...
It's an open world sandbox and nothing else. And it was not promised to be something else.
@katttruewalker said in Please help convince me!:
@s1l3nt said in Please help convince me!:
@zoarialgiant284 said in Please help convince me!:
@s1l3nt Hmm well it is a pvp orriented game, the missions i think are only there to get you to the pvp engagement, i am not here to make excuses (i need to get payed for that first :D) but saying that there are only 5 things to do is clumping it up quite a lot.
Please do name the things to do in game which you earn a reward for doing. I'll wait....
and its not a PvP anything. It was advertised as a open world sandbox pirate sailing adventure game. There just is only 5 things to do to get rewards. 3 of which (Collect chests, collect skulls, collect animals) are essentially the same thing. The 4th is a larger scale of the first three. The 5th well it gets boring wrecking kids and finding a seafarer chest over and over. Repetitive game is repetitive.
You see this is almost the opposite of the reasons I enjoy the game - different strokes for different folks, the question is how can Rare balance this while maintaining the unique qualities that it has already? I don't want a Black Desert style mmorpg, nor do I want a Dayz-on-the-Sea, so compromise is in order?
The first thing to be done is to impliment NPC ship(s) that have skeleton crews of say 20-30.
Have them patrol areas at random and to never start from the same location and have their pattern memory reset on each server refresh/reset.
Have the NPC ship(s) possess goods so you are rewarded for sinking them.
Allow the ship to be used by players who are able to board and take the ship.
Second thing to implement is a bounty system exact to The Division's Rogue system.
These two things will put this title in the right direction IMO.
@s1l3nt The ideeas are great from my oppinion, i just hope that they listen to some of these threads (highly doubt it) as from that i have seen a lot of people have great ideeas, we will have to wait and sea :D
