@the-blessed1546 said in PvE, PvP, PvEvP why does it matter?:
Thank you all so much for your input. I still don't think giving people the option if a private server or something would be a bad idea. If most people like both it won't make that big of an impact. If more people are like me a and want to just enjoy the game in PvE and it would ruin the game then wouldn't that make us right all along for wanting to be able to do that? Maybe if there was a way to just say please don't attack me? I don't know I just don't think I should have to run away all the time. It's gotten to the point I don't even trust anyone in the game. Too many people have pretended to be nice just to kill me. Si even if someone really is nice I can't trust then and I have to run away. And please don't make the excuse that it's a pirate game. That's a very poor excuse to act like a jerk.
but the point is seperating the mode would remove the entire premise of what makes sea of thieves an enjoyable game
in my opinion sea of thieves is a good game not because of its weapons not even sailing a boat or roleplaying as a pirate
what makes sea of thieves a good game is the people
the people you don't know if you can trust
if you made the modes seperate this quote from the official steam page "Whether you’re voyaging as a group or sailing solo, you’re bound to encounter other crews in this shared world adventure – but will they be friends or foes, and how will you respond?"
this would no longer exist the biggest part of what makes sea of thieves well sea of thieves
for me it was never about the skeletons or the loot or the pirates or the ships and guns
it was about the journey the unexpected people you meet out on the seas
but you make those modes seperate it will be "hi diddily ho neighborino!" or "avast ye scurvy dog!" depending on the mode you pick
the mystery made the game what it is and will always be the strongest point the game has got but this is my opinion
the thing you got going about you not being able to trust anyone thats how it should be!
THAT is what sea of thieves is you are sailing in a shared world with people you do not know their intentions are they good or bad?
do they want to steal your loot or say hi?
and the part about it being a "pirate game" you are only seeing the small picture of it
it is true the game is a pirate game and now you are thinking about the definition of a pirate "plunder and kill" no thats not the meaning of it
a pirate is a untrustworthy scurvy rat who plunders AND digs treasures but once again seperate the modes it will be a merchant or killers
being a pirate is not only about the plunder (even if movies and books and games likes to glorify the pirates as being nothing but foul plunderers)