Why I’m quitting Sea of Thieves – broken gameplay, ignored community, and an unfair environment

  • After spending a long time playing Sea of Thieves, I’ve finally decided to leave the game – and honestly, it hurts. I’ve poured hundreds of hours into it, met amazing people, and had some unforgettable moments. But the current state of the game and Rare’s attitude have completely killed my motivation to keep playing.

    Let’s start with the most important part – the toxic state of the game. Every update brings more bugs that never get fixed. The game is getting more broken with time. Hit registration is a disaster, you clearly land shots and nothing registers. Server lag is a daily issue, and for a multiplayer game from a multi-million dollar company, that’s unacceptable.

    The anti-cheat system is basically non-existent. Cheaters are everywhere, ruining PvP, and Rare just lets it happen. The community has been begging for changes for years, but nothing happens. All we get is more cosmetics while core issues are completely ignored.

    The game mechanics are also unbalanced – gun swapping is restricted, but you can quickswap sword into sniper freely and abuse the system with no punishment. It’s broken and discouraging.

    Let’s not forget the FOV issue. The game claims it’s 90 FOV, but in reality, it looks way smaller. Even worse – you can easily change the FOV by editing game files, and many players do it. That gives them a clear PvP advantage over legit players who follow the rules. It’s totally unfair, and Rare turns a blind eye.

    Another thing that really bothers me is the lack of a “no zoom” option on sniper. Many people would love to toggle sniper zoom off in settings if they prefer a cleaner view. It should be about player choice – but again, there’s no option.

    And on top of that, we still don’t have private servers for training, even though the community has been asking for them for years. It would help both beginners and experienced players practice, train PvP, test strategies… but Rare continues to ignore this request.

    I love Sea of Thieves for its concept and atmosphere. But the reality is – it’s turning into a frustrating and toxic experience. Unless Rare starts listening to its players and actually fixes the core problems, the game is going to slowly die out. For me, it’s already lost its fun – and that’s why I’m done.

  • 13
    Beiträge
    8.0k
    Aufrufe
  • @mslechtic15

    Okay, so they do listen to players, but that doesn’t mean every idea the players have are good ideas.

    Also, what makes you think Rare isn’t doing their best to fix the cheater problem? Many employees work tirelessly to rid your servers of cheaters, but I hardly see anybody thanking them. It’s sad really.

    Maybe instead of focusing on these things and quitting just because you didn’t get a few things you wanted, you can focus on the things that actually make the game enjoyable.

  • @mslechtic15

    While I can get behind the complaint of connectivity/hitreg being an issue since forever:

    The anti-cheat system is basically non-existent.

    Existent, working, and getting updated. Arms race battle, and you will never entirely get rid of cheaters in ANY online game. Time for you to make peace with that.

    gun swapping is restricted, but you can quickswap sword into sniper freely and abuse the system with no punishment. It’s broken and discouraging.

    To swap from gun to sword and actually use both, this just means you need to be in someone's melee range to be effective. And that means you're in danger of someone else's sword as well. Quick swapping two guns is different story. This is just a bad comparation.

    Let’s not forget the FOV issue.

    What issue? There is no issue.

    You can easily change the FOV by editing game files, and many players do it. That gives them a clear PvP advantage over legit players who follow the rules. It’s totally unfair, and Rare turns a blind eye.

    Easy anticheat is working. And that's why they're getting banned when detected. Again, no issue.

    Another thing that really bothers me is the lack of a “no zoom” option on sniper.

    It's meant to be long range and not medium. Be happy they allow you to fire from it while it's getting zoomed in.

    And on top of that, we still don’t have private servers for training

    You have adventure, hourglass, etc. All the training opportunities you might need, if you don't play in SS.

    and that’s why I’m done.

    Goodluck and have fun.

  • The thing about endings is that we all tend to lean into what we wanna lean into and it can paint a picture that doesn't best represent what the experience was.

    all the good things you mentioned were also possible because of the effort that went into the game

    Things are typically more complex than we acknowledge. They try, you tried, you got some cool moments out of it and hopefully some lasting memories.

    Lots of times there aren't really villains, just a chapter that reached its end

  • @xdragonman15558 I honestly don’t believe Rare is working as hard as they claim, because after all these years, they still haven’t fixed anything. They have so much money coming in, yet they can’t seem to handle even the most basic issues. It’s absolutely ridiculous at this point.

    The bugs and constant lag are another huge problem. It feels like every update just makes the game more broken, not less.

    And as for the settings, it’s clear they’re not focused on player preferences at all. Instead, they’re forcing playstyles, limiting options, and banning features, which is the exact opposite of what a game should do. It’s not about giving players choice – it’s about controlling them.

  • the toxic state of the game. Every update brings more bugs that never get fixed.

    "never gets fixed" but they do get patched.

    The game is getting more broken with time.

    mmmmh?

    Server lag is a daily issue

    So from what I understand, it just the Pc side that suffers. Console (least the console only lobby) everyone Ive asked said they never ever had server issues they see on reddit or forums complain

    The anti-cheat system is basically non-existent. Cheaters are everywhere, ruining PvP, and Rare just lets it happen.

    What game is there anti-cheat and still has cheaters? "Ruining Pvp" Okie but what about the 99% of the rest of the game?? Seems cheater complaints is always from Hourglass and never about the over all.

    The game mechanics are also unbalanced – gun swapping is restricted

    Uh? because it horrible...

    Let’s not forget the FOV issue. The game claims it’s 90 FOV, but in reality, it looks way smaller.

    Compared to COD which allows you to 110, 90 fov is spot on, at least on my 72 inch :/

    you can easily change the FOV by editing game files

    Dont do it....

    That gives them a clear PvP advantage over legit players who follow the rules. It’s totally unfair, and Rare turns a blind eye.

    How do you know they do this? If you know..and prove it. Report it.

    And on top of that, we still don’t have private servers for training

    Safer Seas. if you can sink a Skeleton Galleon, on a sloop with default supplies and patch only 5 times, Board them twice, kill 4 skeletons, reboard your ship without dying. That good training.

    train PvP, test strategies…

    Best way to swim, is dive into the deep end and start swimming.

    it’s turning into a frustrating and toxic experience

    Where is the toxic part?

    Unless Rare starts listening to its players and actually fixes the core problems, the game is going to slowly die out.

    7 years....7 long years. Still waiting for it die...

  • @mslechtic15

    they’re forcing playstyles

    They're actually not.

    limiting options

    Limiting options to be according to their vision of the game, and mode (HS vs SS), yes. Nothing else.

    and banning features, which is the exact opposite of what a game should do.

    "banning" exploits*. Which is exactly what they should do.

    It’s not about giving players choice – it’s about controlling them.

    You have plenty of choices, of what it is currently in the game. Not having the specific ones YOU desire is something else. Use what's in the game, or don't.

  • @mslechtic15 said in Why I’m quitting Sea of Thieves – broken gameplay, ignored community, and an unfair environment:

    The anti-cheat system is basically non-existent. Cheaters are everywhere, ruining PvP, and Rare just lets it happen. The community has been begging for changes for years, but nothing happens. All we get is more cosmetics while core issues are completely ignored.

    Every game that has PVP or multiple players playing against each other has this issue. It's never going away.

    I will say the thing that the game needs most is a downloadable kill cam, a short clip that can be downloaded after your game session that shows the player killing you from their view.

    Having this killcam footage will help catch cheaters better and make reporting of them easier. The current way of providing your own "first person view" footage is just not good enough, you don't see a lot from your own view most the time due to combat and things going on in game.

    When submitting video to support, they normally ask for more evidence, how else can you get more evidence other than your own first person view video???

    This killcam footage will also cutdown false submissions which Rare/game staff will have to look through... Saving a lot of time.

  • Looked up your gamertag out of curiosity. You're on sot right now, haven't you quit yet? 🤣

  • @hiradc said in Why I’m quitting Sea of Thieves – broken gameplay, ignored community, and an unfair environment:

    Looked up your gamertag out of curiosity. You're on sot right now, haven't you quit yet? 🤣

    Ah don't be like that. It must be a farewell session, right.... right??? xD

  • It's alright to feel burnt out, we all did at some point. SOT is a fun game but as everything that you get to much of, it can get to your nerves.

    Take a break, play something else for a while. SOT will always be there if and when you decide to get back.

  • @r3vanns Private servers for TDM or naval fights with friends should already be in the game. There’s no excuse. As for the FOV – it’s honestly a joke. You can’t see anything, and it ruins the experience. If everyone got to try a higher FOV, they’d realize how much better and fairer the game would feel. It’s not hard to add – Rare is just ignoring it.

  • While we understand your intention is to leave feedback and explain your reasons for leaving, this type of post draws negative reaction, and does not foster discussion in the community. We value your feedback, and if you want to make suggestions or offer your ideas to improve the game, please feel free to create a topic in Feedback & Suggestions.

    This topic will now be locked.

13
Beiträge
8.0k
Aufrufe
12 von 13