You're right there was a bug in my data... but it was due to an error in rival ships sunk displayed in game vs on this website. I provided a link with my in game stats and the websites stats side by side; and the website shows EXACTLY x2 the actual in-game amount. I'll report that, but my main issue is still unresolved. Also I've realized the rival faction ships sunk data is a terrible way to gauge this. Actual pirate milestone data is better, as it gives you battles completed and battles won. I overlooked the fact that you're never guaranteed to play versus a Guardian when you queue as a Servant and vice versa. My pirate milestone for guardians says I've won 448 and played 618 matches. 448/618 = 72.49%. Servants says I've won 276 and played 453 matches. 276/453=60.93%. So now my Servants levels to win ratio is 1.19 wins per 1 lvl. The guardians are 1.50 wins per 1 lvl. I only played servants when duo'ing with buddies, and most of my guardian levels are solo; but the win rate discrepancy only furthers my questions!!! I have a better win rate for guardians, and consistently go for high streaks compared servants. My buddy and I wanted the verdant bones so we we're lowering every 4 streak, which is LESS efficient than how I play HG solo as a guardian... I attached a reddit thread going over xp per streak/win at the bottom of my post if you're interested; but basically your fifth win is worth 6600 xp compared to the first win which is only 4200 xp. That's a 157% more xp per win at 5+ wins. So with an increased win rate in guardians compared to servants, and combine that with the fact I go for bigger streaks it still doesn't make sense. This is way too long and nerdy I'll write a tldr lol
tldr; I noticed my PvP factions were only 67 lvls apart despite winning 172 more matches on Guardians with a better win rate than my servants. Servants only take 1.19 sinks per level, and the Guardians take 1.5 sinks per level.
Reddit Thread about HG streak XP
![Guardian Data]()
![Servants Data]()