@theblackbellamy said in What happened to my gilded voyages?:
@gravesilence272 what if the DM replaced those items with other items, or altered some system so that those items are no longer required?
Maybe players would accept that, depending on the swap, but Rare DIDN'T do that, did they? Previously given rewards were taken away and replaced with nothing.
I mean, I'm understanding what you're saying. Something was there and now it isn't. There was a voyage system, and they removed it.
You clearly don't actually, given the following:
When I said "you see it as destructive," I guess it would have been more accurate to say, "you feel the net outcome is destructive," and that's either because you're not recognizing or not happy with what was constructed in its place. Am I wrong?
Yes, you are absolutely wrong. A "destructive change" is a descriptive that literally means "something was removed", it has nothing to do with how anybody feels, or anyone's opinion, mine or yours. It doesn't matter if something else is put in it's place - the removal of something is a "destructive change" by definition.
It's not an opinion or a feeling, it's a description. Like if I say the sky is blue, it's not my opinion - I am describing the colour of the sky.
Likewise here - I am describing the change made, not voicing my opinion on it. I am NOT saying "it's a change I don't like" - that ISN'T what "destructive change" means, it is simply a description of the changes made.
If you are still confused, please mentally substitute the words "a change where something was removed" instead of "destructive change".
Adding something new is called an "additive/constructive change", but adding a new thing doesn't negate the fact that an old thing was removed. So if you remove one thing, and add another in it's place it's STILL a destructive change, sure there's also an additional change - but that just makes two changes, one destructive and one constructive.
You can add as many constructive changes as you like, but it can't negate the fact that something was removed.