We get called to Reaper's Hideout where Servant of Flame tasks you with finding out the location of the burning blade. After getting the ship route (like a sunken voyage) we get to find out that two of the three ships that were taking the sword to a secure location sunk, with the 3rd ship never arriving to the destination. We track down the last ship and fight its crew, only to find out that a crew member managed to snatch the sword and take it away on a rowboat.
In the next tall tale we find out the name of the pirate and track down his vessel, sinking him. After taking the pirate to the Servant the latter conducts a ritual, forcing the pirate's memories out of him. It turns out that he left the sword with a note to a stranger, whose face the Servant cannot see.
In the final tall tale we abduct an OOS member, who creates a compass that points us towards the sword. After getting to the location we are faced with a group of ancient phantoms and a high priest, with Belle escaping to warn pirate lord. However, by the time he arrives the Servant open a portal for us to the Reaper Hideout, where we receive a praise from the Reapers and Flameheart gets his blade
