Lots of spoilers.
I was mostly following Rarethief.com's guide. The Monkey Island tales are awesome but would make me so mad trying to do them legit. Not bashing lol.
I found Herman's Supplies (3 hollow coconuts in a box) amd tried to carry them to the Stockade. Fell in where you find the suntan oil. Dropped Herman's Supplies.
Some items respawned. Spyglass, Goldtooth (a lot that one) another one I think...maybe.
Anyway, don't drop Herman's Supplies in water. Ticket Submitted.
Also got stuck in foliage, had to alt-f4 to get respawned myself.
