After playing A Pirates Life Tall Tales, there were quite a lot of moments that were too easy, and that is why I think the Tall Tales should have some difficulties, so here is how I think it should work.
After completing each of the five Tall Tales for the first time, you'll unlock two new difficulties. The difference between them is that the enemies would take a lot more hits. You'll get a higher reward for completing depending on if you're doing which are Original, Medium, or Hard. (The name of the difficulties are just examples)
Original
Original is just the same difficulty as your first time doing the Tall Tale and the same amount of rewards.
Medium
Medium adds more enemies, they'll take more damage from all weapons including the bosses. You'll earn double the amount of coins than the original one.
Hard
Hard will add a be for those that want a challenge. It's highly recommended to have a few friends help you out if you prefer going solo, Enemies will have double the normal amount of health and this time they'll be able to take more health from your health bar per hit. As to make this even more interesting, only in certain areas enemies will be spawned out in the open for example in The Sunken Pearl there will be mermaids swimming around the black pearl, this will only trigger when the Crew that is doing the hard difficulty arrive at that area and once you're at a far distance from the Black Pearl they'll despawn so that other player won't have to deal with the harder enemies unless they wish to help.
While the bosses will have a massive amount of health and can cause more damage depending on which type of boss, the final Boss in Lords Of The Sea will be included which is everyone's favorite ship The Flying Dutchman, As I'm sure many of you would agree that The Flying Dutchman could have taken more hits since this is The Flying Dutchman we're talking about.
If you beat this difficulty, you'll earn triple and will receive a pirate title for that Tall Tale Episode
If on that certain Tall Tale episode where you've started and finished all of the difficulties, you'll be given a commendation that basically says you've done this Tall Tale episode on all difficulties. You'll also receive exclusive items, for example, The Captains Of The Damned, you'll receive the rest of the ghostly items whereas you got the instruments and a few other items such as the tankard for completing.
Now as for the final big one. If you complete all difficulties of A Pirates Life Tall Tales from 1 to 5, you'll get a big reward that is worth getting like for example maybe a Pirate curse that makes you a ghost which is the same effect that Jack Sparrow had on him.
Please share your thoughts and ideas, if you want this to become a reality. I recommend sharing this thread with others!
