I have long been a supporter of the pirate emporium because it helps give fair pay to employees and lets the devs continue to make free dlcs and updates which would not be possible without it, but I also believe there should be a limit on what can be put in the pirate emporium. Seeing how Rare has started putting cosmetics that should not be in the emporium into the emporium, I believe there should start being written rules of what they can/cannot put into it. These rules should not be too strict as we do not want them to impede on Rare's ability to sufficiently pay their employees. The following lists include what I believe should/should not be allowed in the pirate emporium and should be earned in game.
Things that should not be in the emporium
-Holiday cosmetics
-Lore-based cosmetics (ones that are purely sea of thieves based)
Things That should be put into the emporium
-Pets
-Non lore-based cosmetics
-emotes
-Small game improvements like the character potion
-Non lore-based curses.
The lists are short at the moment but feel free to comment with any suggestions.