I have been repeating Tall Tale #1, The Shroudbreaker, to try to experience the different paths through the story. However, in the five or six successive attempts, I have always got the Scarab Token (taking me to the same island each time). The only other one I have ever got is the Crab Token. I did get a different token in the Insider game, once, long ago, but never in the main game. I understand there are three other tokens I could get, but have never done so in this tale.
Now, I do understand that if I throw a six sided dice six times in a row, I might get the same number six times; but it is very unlikely (1:7776). Have I just been unlucky, or is this aspect of Tall Tale #1 less random than it should be?