Commendations not counting when in same-faction battles is unfair.

  • It's all in the title.

    This is infuriating.

    We're not all PvPers-to-the-bone. I'm part of the people who will stop this buggy mess of a mode at once, when I unlocked the cosmetics I want and the commendations. I have nothing against PvP but tis game has much more to offer and I prefer fights that happen organically in the game world anyway.

    That being said, I know I'm not the only one out there thinking like this, and I sure am not the only completionist in this game.

    Now imagine my friend and I, separately, both win 200 games (days of gameplay, I'm not talkiing 10 minutes). The only difference being he faced the opposite faction every time, while I was matched against the same faction. Now he's got his skelly part and I don't, while we did the same. This is quite infuriating if you ask me.

    Furthermore, it's not even gonna be a 50/50 proportion of same-faction battles. Same-factions battles already happen MORE than regular ones, due to the fact the playerbase is not evenly spread between the 2 depending on time of the day.

    The grind was already the worst pain, as stated numerous times by many people here and elsewhere, and now sometimes it doesn't even count, if the game decided to not give you the right conditions.

    Rare. It's an easy fix. Either give us the choice (I personally wouln't mind waiting more) or just fix this so that a win = progress towards the commendation, regardless of the faction (these are the same ships, there's NO difference).

    Here, you're placing Lore above Gameplay and I think this is a very dangerous path to follow. You came up with a lore explanation (let's imagine they are training vs each other)... Well you know what benefit training has in real life ? It gives you experience and skill (commendation).

    I, for once, will start protesting this by not fighting ships my own faction. This is exacerbated by the fact this is really trivial. NO ONE will care that a sunken Servant counted as a Guardian, or vice-versa.

  • 8
    帖子
    7.6k
    查看
    competitionfeedback
  • Agreed, haven't chosen to fight same faction, and certain things like champion battles are quite rare as so many lower their hourglass.

  • @jolly-ol-yep so you know the commendations for sinking then opposite faction are for 500, not 200. And while I agree it's a pain, given the wording of the commendations I wasn't mad about it not counting. I was mad it didn't count for the other side.

    Too Many to Count
    After receiving your Blessing, you sank ships representing The Servants of the Flame.

    It would be nice if that counted when sinking a servant ship, even if it was in a same faction battle.

    But if your going for those commendations, you may as well go for level 1000

  • Hmmm
    Fight more often and reduce wait times (tho you could of just defend to improve)
    or
    Fight everyone when no opposite faction is around to get that quick fight, not get commendations.

    Well, seems the crying salts got what they want at the cost of no commendation progression. Unfair yes.
    But there is a..solution... Defend.

  • @burnbacon a dit dans Commendations not counting when in same-faction battles is unfair. :

    But there is a..solution... Defend.

    Isn't it the same though ? I didn't try but you could still be potentially invaded by someone your own faction, couldn't you ? Did they say otherwise or you assume defenders are put at the bottom of the "priority stack" when matching people and thus somehow more consistently thrown against their rival faction ?
    (real question here, are defenders "the last resort" when the game is trying to match you ? And how does it affect same-faction matchmaking ? Do we know ?)

  • In the Battle for the Sea of Thieves, Athena’s Fortune Emissary Flags won from same Faction battles can now be handed to the Mysterious Stranger in return for gold and reputation. This ensures that players can profit from same Faction battles as well as rival Faction battles.

    Well it's still not the case. Why don't they never go to the end of their logic ?

    We'd like to have the commendations work with same faction battles please. It's just a ship sunk. It's the same. I'm grinding them right now (Thans for the one requiring you to sink 500 ships or the rival faction to unlock the starfish skelly head btw, I still felt too much respected.) and any same faction fight is a waste of time for me. Even worse if I'm in a streak.

  • @jolly-ol-yep said in Commendations not counting when in same-faction battles is unfair.:

    @burnbacon a dit dans Commendations not counting when in same-faction battles is unfair. :

    But there is a..solution... Defend.

    Isn't it the same though ? I didn't try but you could still be potentially invaded by someone your own faction, couldn't you ? Did they say otherwise or you assume defenders are put at the bottom of the "priority stack" when matching people and thus somehow more consistently thrown against their rival faction ?
    (real question here, are defenders "the last resort" when the game is trying to match you ? And how does it affect same-faction matchmaking ? Do we know ?)

    No idea, so this is just guessing but if I was designing this I'd set the order this way:

    • Attacker vs Defender (Opposing Factions)
    • Attacker vs Attacker (Opposing Factions)
    • Attacker vs Attacker (Same Faction)
    • Attacker vs Defender (Same Faction)

    Same Faction vs Defender would be last to ensure there are more defenders available for primary matching for Opposing Factions.

    I'm not sure how you'd be able to test this is the case reliably without knowing who is in the pool and how many are in each faction though. It would be nice if Rare could answer stuff like this when it comes up.

  • This still not working? :(

    Was hoping they would've fixed it in today's patch. I just want my milestones to count.

8
帖子
7.6k
查看
competitionfeedback
页数 4/8