Hey everyone,
I wanted to share some feedback about progression and cosmetic unlocks — especially regarding the Gold Curse and other cosmetic rewards.
Recently, I completed the Shores of Gold Tall Tale five times, excited to finally earn the Gold Curse, before realizing that it actually requires completing all Tall Tales five times with every commendation. While I completely understand the idea of rewarding players who put in a lot of effort, I feel the current system turns what could be a fun challenge into a heavy grind.
Many players, including myself, really enjoy the story and adventure aspects of Sea of Thieves but don’t always have the time to repeat every tale multiple times. It would make the game a lot more enjoyable if Tall Tale completions only needed to be done once (or maybe twice) for cosmetic unlocks — keeping them challenging, but not exhausting.
I’d also like to suggest reconsidering a few other progression requirements:
The Hourglass curses could be made accessible from level 60 in Reapers, and Pirate Legend could be obtainable from level 40 in the Trading Companies.
The Gold Ghost Curse might feel more achievable if the requirement was level 500 instead of 1000.
These adjustments would keep rare cosmetics meaningful but make them more attainable and fun for a wider range of players — especially those who can’t play for long sessions.
Sea of Thieves is one of my favorite games, and I’d love to see it continue to grow. Hopefully, this suggestion resonates with others who feel the same way.
