Yarr Fellow Pirates!
I know not everyone is fond of Season 17, but like and dislike for what Rare puts out is never going to be universal. Most players who enjoy things tend to just play and not post. For me, this is the most fun I have had since Season 13. I am back to checking islands, diving into wrecks, scooping up floating loot, and caring about treasure in ways I have not in a long while.
For a good stretch it felt like nothing was worth it unless you raised an emissary flag and locked into the grind. Worse, some seasonal gimmicks funneled everyone into one narrow place. I've passed on he current at the time because I knew if I waited I could do it later without the server sitting on it.
To be clear, I do not mind PvP. It is the lifeblood of the seas, and I enjoy naval battles and hand to hand. But I also have a full-time job, family, and other responsibilities. I do not get to spend all day on the game, and when I log on I want to feel like more often than not I can finish the activity I set out to do with friends and have something to show for it. Losing sometimes is fine, that is part of the fun. But spending hours on something with a ninety percent chance of having it all taken is not rewarding.
That is why I am enjoying Season 17 so much. The world itself feels valuable again. I can play my way, pick and choose, and know I will make progress even if I lose a fight here or there. The armored keg boats and black powder barrels are fantastic. Sure, they can sink you quick if you are careless, but that is the point. I have had more fun planning naval fights this season than I can remember in years. And when I sink? I laugh it off and keep going. Treasure is everywhere right now.
I think a lot of the criticism is about how the season does not feel brand new. To me that is fine. It feels like a world refresh, and I am loving that. Like when Blizzard did Cataclysm in WoW, it breathed new life into old things. I expect new and bigger content will come, but I do not need a revolution every season. I want variety and tools to play the game in new ways, not one "best way" everyone is forced into and expects.
Season 17 has given me more freedom, more strategy, and more reasons to log back in. For me that is exactly what I was hoping for.
