My idea is a tall tale where you not only learn about the Leader of the Reaper’s bone Flameheart Junior aka Servant of the Flame’s pass before the chalice (and maybe his name before he changed it) but also learn about the sirens in sea of thieves. The way I had set this up was by making it so that you go to either the order of souls or the Reaper’s emissary and it switches each time you play the tall tale so you get a different dialogue from one or the other and it starts off different.
Basically you meet a siren that learned Order of Souls magic from artifacts and books she collected from shipwrecks making her like a rogue siren figure. She met Flameheart Junior before he was called that because she was the one that led him and his crew to the island he was shipped wrecked on. But that’s not the island you meet her on you meet her on a different island that when you get closer to you hear singing. And you basically help her figure out what happened and find her long lost loved (Flameheart Junior) and reunite him. Keep in mind you don’t know it’s Flameheart Junior because she uses his old name.
Please just give me feed back and if the developers want I can make another post with the whole tale tall concept, photos of the siren and curse for it, and audio recording of the song
