Instruments

  • Maybe this has been asked multiple times, but can we PLEASE have a violin and a banjo as an instrument? Especially since we already have a banjo player in Athena's Fortune, it wouldn't be difficult to get this in a game. It feels a little lame when you're in a 4-man crew and there are only 3 different types of instruments.

  • 14
    Publications
    13.0k
    Vues
  • @xgodz-sonicz We already have a Banjo though...

    He makes for a mighty fine ship set if you ask me. After all, he is the instrument of many a pirate's destruction. ✌😅

  • @xgodz-sonicz

  • I'm all for more instruments! How about some winds (ex. Flute, Piccolo, Oboe) or some brass (ex. Trumpet, Trombone, Tuba) or more percussion (ex. Tamborine, Claves, Udu)...

    All seriousness aside, I want a Keytar!

  • A recorder, lute, trumpet, and viol would make excellent additions to the hurdy gurdy, concertino, banjo, and drum.
    In a bit of complete silliness, I want my pirate to be able to whip out a harpsichord and start playing.

  • @butterybarnacls said in Instruments:

    A recorder, lute, trumpet, and viol would make excellent additions to the hurdy gurdy, concertino, banjo, and drum.
    In a bit of complete silliness, I want my pirate to be able to whip out a harpsichord and start playing.

    Don't stop with the harpsichord. Give me a giant pipe organ to stick in the Captain's Cabin.

  • @xgodz-sonicz

    it wouldn't be difficult to get this in a game.

    Apart from memory constraints which is the main limiting factor with adding more instruments and shanties.

    Rumors have it that they have managed to have some progress in this allowing for at least one more instrument but that doesnt make the issue trivial.

    The thing is that each instrument is more then just a model and animation but also each single instrument has 4 pieces of music for each shanty that has to be loaded into memory to be able to instantly start playing it at any point in time.

    There is currently 6 shanties and 3 instruments, that is already 18 musical pieces and for each music and instrument
    Combination there is.

    then there is the fact that each instrument can have a leading role in the shanty and a backup role so that doubles the amount up to 36.

    Next we cant forget that both the leading and backup also have a drunk version doubling it once again to a total of 72 songs that have to be loaded into memory ready to play at any time with the current instruments.

    Now for each instrument you want to add you have to add 24 more pieces of music ( 6 shanties * 4 versions ) with current shantie counts.

    And each new shantie has to have 12 different versions loaded ( 4 versions per instrument * 3 instruments ) again with current instrument count.

    More flexible math is:
    4 * {shantiecount} * {instrumentcount}

    EDIT: thanks to @Galactic-Geek for informing me of 2 shanties i missed

    Current shanties in game (at time of writing)

    • Becalmed (sad sounding one)
    • The summoning ( Merricks tune )
    • We shall sail together ( Legendary shantie )
    • Bosun Bill ( Happy sounding one )
    • Ride of the valkeries
    • Grogg Mayles ( adventure shantie )
  • @callmebackdraft Only 4? I'm fairly certain there's more than that...

    1. Happy-sounding shanty
    2. Sad-sounding shanty
    3. Adventure! Shanty
    4. Ride of the Valkyries
    5. Merril's tune
    6. We Sail Together
  • @blam320 said in Instruments:

    @butterybarnacls said in Instruments:

    A recorder, lute, trumpet, and viol would make excellent additions to the hurdy gurdy, concertino, banjo, and drum.
    In a bit of complete silliness, I want my pirate to be able to whip out a harpsichord and start playing.

    Don't stop with the harpsichord. Give me a giant pipe organ to stick in the Captain's Cabin.

    YES!!!!!!!alt text

  • @galactic-geek , @Sweltering-Nick @CallMeBackdrafT They need to add "Booty Bound" a Sea of Thieves Rap as an instrumental version. It would be a very happy tune.

  • @galactic-geek when all instruments are taken, against the crews better judgement, I tend to take over lead vocals! 😂😂😂

  • @xgodz-sonicz said in Instruments:

    Maybe this has been asked multiple times, but can we PLEASE have a violin and a banjo as an instrument? Especially since we already have a banjo player in Athena's Fortune, it wouldn't be difficult to get this in a game. It feels a little lame when you're in a 4-man crew and there are only 3 different types of instruments.

    That's why I play the bell :D

  • @butterybarnacls said in Instruments:

    @blam320 said in Instruments:

    @butterybarnacls said in Instruments:

    A recorder, lute, trumpet, and viol would make excellent additions to the hurdy gurdy, concertino, banjo, and drum.
    In a bit of complete silliness, I want my pirate to be able to whip out a harpsichord and start playing.

    Don't stop with the harpsichord. Give me a giant pipe organ to stick in the Captain's Cabin.

    YES!!!!!!!alt text

    alt text

    Similar line of thinking.

  • @blam320 I think I just betrayed my age!

14
Publications
13.0k
Vues
1 sur 14