I don't know.
I've heard from many people that the Roar was a joke now, but when I finally made it over there to check out the new balance, I didn't find it to be nerfed. I'd say I noticed less hits and maybe smaller/less holes on my sloop than what I expected (and I noticed a blast of magma that hit near our helm did NOT bring down the mast).
The individual's subjective experience, of the randomness and chaos in this game, can skew people's perceptions into thinking their findings are universal absolutes. So, I'm not going to fall prey to that, but I'm wary of others who may be.
I'm very experienced in the game and within the Roar (but hadn't been there much in the past month or so). I never felt like it NEEDED a reduction in danger - not even from the initial balance on the Roar's launch. I loved it's danger.
That being said, I haven't found the reductions to make it a joke or to be overly nerfed. Just because something is adjusted towards the easier side, doesn't mean they completely nerfed it. I've been impressed with the dev team, because I tend to cringe whenever I read patch notes about reducing difficulty on something - but I've found they often are only making a mild adjustment (skeleton accuracy comes to mind). Even the new sloop steering in a storm doesn't seem to be much different (I've only tested it a tiny bit - I need to check more into it, but I went through the outskirts of a storm and the steering was still a significant factor). I bring that one up, because I've always LOVED how crazy a storm can get, trying to solo sail through, and I don't want to see that lost.
Anyway, I heard second hand reports that the Roar was a joke, but I've visited a couple of times since and I can't say my findings match those secondhand accounts. I rarely ever let my sloop sink, and I did lose it to the new Roar once (I blame my partner more on that one, LOL, but it still sank QUICKLY to Ashen Reaches erupting).
shrugs
Maybe it's too easy. maybe it isn't. I haven't seen definitive proof and I know people sometimes make a bigger deal about things than the reality of things.
De omnibus dubitandum