Compiled into one easy to read location by Sea of News or read on!
Top Ten Bad Ideas that never made it
From Mike -
No 10.
No 9.
No 8.
No 7.
No 6.
No 5.
No 4.
No 3.
No 2.
No 1.
@katttruewalker I have been following this for a while and was actually coming here to do exactly this! haha I love these, their are a few I actually like. Poking stick and Repair hammer would be fun, and the Shop opening and closing times would bring a cool realism to the world
That ship in a bottle concept! Has me excited for the future possibilities... especially in the Pirate Legend Hideout!
Thank you for sharing these here!!
Oh, I'd still like to have a personal place into the game to show our crewmates or anyone else what we have accomplished. While yeah, I think a bedroom is a bit too much, but cave would probable fit :D
So they did have the 80% more content they just somehow justified throwing it all away because of the many arbitrary and fixable with a “git gud” excuses they made for us clearly incapable players... lol.
Some of this stuff sounds a lot more fun and intelligent to add than the game we have with cosmetics all the same price and gold having no purpose and no real captains or progression, currently provides.
Its like they had a plan for this game at one point. What in gods name happened..
Thanks for compiling these in one spot... I loved following him on Twitter, and it really does illustrate how game design works... There is so much iteration, the game you end up making comes from that more than anything. From a player perspective, it feels like "how can you not know the game you're going to make when you start?" And this shows why!
Super educational an inspirational, at least for me!
@xxxpirate01 said in Top Ten ideas that never made it into the Game by Gregg Mayles - Creative Director at Rare Ltd:
@katttruewalker them graphics don’t look right it looks plain.
These are taken from the prototype build waaaaaay back around 2015
@musicmee That is another one that excited me, could be a cool way to have ship ownership and customisation in PL Hideout. Maybe take your bottle ship (Heh... you sunk my bottleship) to the shipwright and have it customised, and then pour it in the water for your ship to arise!
