So when I see a big brute pirate, I picture him slightly slower, but able to take a little more damage than the skinny guy with the weaselly eyes.
I'd love the ability for all pirates to adjust their skills on a slider. Ideally this would tie into what your pirate looks like, but I don't see how we could retro that and keep it all even.
SPEED (----------()---------) TOUGHNESS
POWER (----------()---------) AIM
SPEED: Your base land and water speed when NOT carrying loot.
TOUGHNESS: How much damage you can take before you die.
POWER: How much damage you do with the cutlass (melee weapons).
AIM: How much damage you do with guns.
There might be other Yin/Yang combos, but these are the ones that strike me offhand.
It would be awesome tactics to see a brute and KNOW he was gonna dish out the hurt in hand-to-hand, so you better get Gunny to take him at range. Or to see the enemy making a run for their ship and know you had to send little N*d Swift after them before they got away with your loot.
Thoughts?
