I was playing on a solo sloop yesterday and something came up that made me curious.
I'd dug up a Chest of 1000 Grogs on Crescent Island and decided to leave it next ot a pier and just go get my boat since walking back across the island was annoyingly slow.
I arrived to find a galleon approaching and foolishly tried to get to my ship and make a quick getaway – naturally, they shot me to pieces.
Eventually I just found a mermaid and respawned out of there, dumping the chest into the sea.
What I'm wondering is:
Using the mermaid restarts the voyage (the riddle sends you to a different island) – but if I had left the chest hidden on the island, since I'd already dug it up, could I have sailed back to find it again?
