Galleons Are Under Powered Compared to smaller Ships

  • Galleons are often seen as powerful ships because of their size and firepower, but in reality, they are underpowered when compared to the more nimble sloops. This argument highlights the limitations of galleons in terms of speed, damage control, and crew efficiency, showing that sloops have a clear advantage in naval battles.

    One of the main drawbacks of galleons is their size and weight. Being much larger and heavier than sloops slows them down and makes them less maneuverable, which in turn makes them easier targets for enemy attacks. In contrast, sloops are smaller and lighter, allowing them to change direction quickly and navigate tight spaces. This agility gives sloops the upper hand in combat, enabling them to outmaneuver galleons and strike when the opportunity arises.

    When it comes to damage control, sloops have a significant advantage as well. They only need one crew member to effectively bail out water, allowing for a quick response to flooding. Galleons, on the other hand, require at least two crew members to manage the same situation, and if water reaches the second deck, all four crew members must pitch in. This makes galleons less efficient in emergencies. Additionally, with more crew members on a galleon, coordination can become a challenge. In high-pressure situations, having a larger crew can slow down response times, while sloops, with their smaller crews, can communicate and act more quickly, making them more effective in critical moments.

    Furthermore, galleons are easier targets due to their large masts and hulls. While they may have more cannons, their size makes it harder to avoid damage. Sloops can use their speed to evade attacks and hit galleons from advantageous positions. In naval battles, being able to reposition quickly and respond to threats is crucial. Sloops can take advantage of their agility to launch surprise attacks and retreat before galleons can effectively counter.

    In summary, while galleons may seem impressive with their size and firepower, they are actually underpowered compared to sloops. Their lack of speed, inefficient damage control, and vulnerability as targets put them at a disadvantage in naval warfare. Sloops, with their agility and quick response capabilities, are often the more effective choice in combat situations. Relying on galleons can lead to strategic disadvantages when maneuverability and fast reactions are key to success.

  • 6
    Posts
    2.5k
    Views
  • Reference Video

    Gentleman Willy make a video with the title "Galleons are Weak now - SoT"

    Mentioning the same arguments I have made.

    Im not the only one in the community that thinks this. Reference link down below.

    https://youtu.be/nzjUJ7y89iI?si=cJqvMraGNfcwvgzh

  • You've made 2 posts on this subject and I'm going to repeat the same thing: it's a question of balance and communication.
    If the sloop has less firepower than the gallion, it needs more maneuverability to compensate.
    If you're looking for something in-between, the brigantine is for you: it has both firepower and maneuverability.

  • Spamming the same ChatGPT generated vomit in a second thread does not make you any more correct.
    In fact, I'd wager it makes you twice as incorrect.

  • In fact, as you just posted the same exact thing as before; I can post the same exact reply:

    @captknuckles686

    Galleons are often seen as powerful ships because of their size and firepower, but in reality, they are underpowered when compared to the more nimble sloops.

    No they're not. ChatGPT is just feeding you what you want to hear, based on what you put into it.

    This argument highlights the limitations of galleons in terms of speed, damage control, and crew efficiency, showing that sloops have a clear advantage in naval battles.

    No it does not. The previous line was in no way an 'argument'. It was a statement you want to pretend is fact.

    One of the main drawbacks of galleons is their size and weight. Being much larger and heavier than sloops slows them down and makes them less maneuverable, which in turn makes them easier targets for enemy attacks.

    Ignoring literally every aspect of the game; sure.

    In contrast, sloops are smaller and lighter, allowing them to change direction quickly and navigate tight spaces. This agility gives sloops the upper hand in combat, enabling them to outmaneuver galleons and strike when the opportunity arises.

    That's not how the game works at all.
    Again; You are asking for ChatGPT to give you statements you want, rather than anything valid.

    When it comes to damage control, sloops have a significant advantage as well. They only need one crew member to effectively bail out water, allowing for a quick response to flooding.

    And they also sink quicker. But you are ignoring that, huh? You need your 'Galleons are weak!' copium.

    Galleons, on the other hand, require at least two crew members to manage the same situation, and if water reaches the second deck, all four crew members must pitch in.

    Not really. Not at all, actually.
    Once again; You are asking ChatGPT to make statements instead of making valid arguments.

    Additionally, with more crew members on a galleon, coordination can become a challenge. In high-pressure situations, having a larger crew can slow down response times, while sloops, with their smaller crews, can communicate and act more quickly, making them more effective in critical moments.

    This is the opposite of how communication works
    But you really need to pretend Galleons have no advantages to demand your OP ship addition.

    Furthermore, galleons are easier targets due to their large masts and hulls.

    And they have more players to:

    • Fight back
    • Bail
      *Repair
    • Adjust sails/Steer

    Sloops can use their speed to evade attacks and hit galleons from advantageous positions.

    Not in the slightest. I've never seen, or been in, a battle where a sloop used 'agility' to run around a Galleon.

    In naval battles, being able to reposition quickly and respond to threats is crucial. Sloops can take advantage of their agility to launch surprise attacks and retreat before galleons can effectively counter.

    Flat-out lie.

    In summary, while galleons may seem impressive with their size and firepower, they are actually underpowered compared to sloops

    A lie

    Their lack of speed

    A lie, as 'speed' is not a zero-sum stat in this game.

    inefficient damage control

    Another lie.

    and vulnerability as targets put them at a disadvantage in naval warfare

    Oh look; More lying.

    Sloops, with their agility and quick response capabilities, are often the more effective choice in combat situations. Relying on galleons can lead to strategic disadvantages when maneuverability and fast reactions are key to success.

    Yep! More lying!


    I would bet money OP is asking ChatGPT 'Make me a post that highlights the Sloop's strengths & the Galleon's weaknesses in Sea of Thieves' or some equivalent.

    You will notice OP neither denies this, nor addresses any counter-aguments.
    They just post, ad-nauseam, that the Galleon is weak because of made up numbers and authoritative statements that they can't back up.

    They basically say 'The Galleon is weak because of these numbers & statements I made up! Here's how to fix that!'

  • This thread has been locked as it is essentially a duplicate of https://www.seaofthieves.com/community/forums/topic/179102/adding-cannons-to-galleons-second-deck/

    Creating Duplicate Threads
    Multiple threads on the same topic posted in quick succession is not allowed. The most relevant thread will be kept open and all other threads locked.

6
Posts
2.5k
Views
1 out of 6