Concept Idea for bringing back Skins you missed - Revamping and bringing back the Black Market

  • Hey everyone,

    I wanted to share a concept idea that could bring back the Black Market and missed time-limited cosmetics — something many pirates (including myself) have been hoping for.

    The Core Idea:
    If you played during or near the time an event took place, but for whatever reason missed out on earning certain skins or cosmetics, you’d now have a second chance to obtain them. Not for free, of course — this would involve a reworked Black Market system where these items return under very specific conditions.

    How It Works:
    Access to the item would be limited to players who were active during the original event window (or a surrounding grace period).

    To unlock the item, you’d either:

    Spend a large number of Doubloons, OR

    Complete a challenging task or voyage tied to the cosmetic’s theme.

    This would keep the prestige of the cosmetics (still time-sensitive, still exclusive to a player era).

    Offers a grind-worthy goal for returning or long-time players.

    Provides a reason to bring back and expand the Black Market, which I for my part miss

    This could tie in with the upcoming Smuggler’s faction. I mean what else is there to smuggle really?

    In summary:

    Reintroduce missed cosmetics through a revamped Black Market, accessible only to players active during the original events. Unlock via high Doubloon costs or difficult themed tasks. This system could integrate into the Smuggler’s faction for lore and gameplay cohesion.

    Footnote: Personally, I missed out on Merrick’s Drum, the Forsaken Ashes Sword, and the Bonecrusher Sails — I’d love to earn them now, espicially because I was actively playing when these cosmetics were available.

  • 3
    Posts
    7.0k
    Views
  • One or the other.

    Either everyone can now unlock them or everyone who didn't unlock them has missed out.

    I'm noticing players want certain things unlocked but not other things. Which makes me think they want the things they missed out on to be unlocked and the things they got to be locked.

    I started playing right near the end of Jack Sparrow update. I'm okay knowing I missed things before I played, but I appreciate being rewarded for being a loyal player since that time.

  • I think the idea behind the time limited cosmetics was a bad choice by Rare.
    feedback regarding time limited cosmetics (forum link):

    Instead of limiting the seasonal events to just a few days with a login bonus,
    Rare could hand out special seasonal voyages to everyone and let the player
    decide when they want to use it. (maybe within 30 days?)

    And then unlock the time limited stuff after completing the event.

    This would allow people with families to get access to seasonal items,
    even when they are busy with RL-stuff during the main event. ;)


    So yeah, my personal opinion is:
    Let everyone unlock everything they want by playing that (old) content now.
    I think this would allow everyone to show off what they like and what they care about.
    Limiting cosmetics behind a short timeframe, just creates FOMO or frustration.

3
Posts
7.0k
Views
1 out of 3