Tall Tale Trinkets

We could get trinkets for doing the tall tales, like little souvenirs of our journey.
Examples would include an empty shroud breaker, a painting of the Gold Hoarder, the pried-off face of a chest of rage, the star map from "The Cursed Rouge", and Jack's compass.
If we want to tie this to one of the captaincy alignments, I would suggest the Voyager.