Bink's Sake - Playsong - Request to Honor One Piece

@salfo2505 Rare isn't a Japanese company, licensing problems, how bout no

(edited)

@salfo2505 Why honor something completely unrelated to Rare or Microsoft. Most of the ingame homages paid to existing IPs are to those that are owned by Microsoft.

@salfo2505 said in Bink's Sake - Playsong - Request to Honor One Piece:

@supersnipper60
A better argument do you have ?. Because if so, don't post anything...

To that a little racist your argument.

So because you want to honor anime, you feel that my response is 'racist.' What if they did implement it? The other nationalities and ethnicities would want their own songs implemented into the game. And the song isn't related to Rare or Sea of Thieves or Microsoft.

@salfo2505

The more songs the merrier, I say.
Heck, we've already seen references to Hook and Titanic, so I don't see a reason why we can't honor a pirate anime/manga. Even Pirates in the secluded Sea of Thieves have heard of the legendary treasure One Piece.

And we shall sail together

@supersnipper60

Pirate Code - Article 1
The Sea Calls To Us All
Everyone is welcome on the Sea of Thieves regardless of age, gender, race, sexuality, nationality or creed.

@roller-of-dice @Salfo2505
You both realize that if the devs add one anime pirate song, then other people will want other pirate songs, so the devs probably won't add more as they will probably be faced with backlash of "you added this song, why not this song" or "You added this song so add this song next." It's kinda like a domino effect. The number of shanties is good enough now.

@salfo2505 said in Bink's Sake - Playsong - Request to Honor One Piece:

@supersnipper60 Several songs that are in Sea of ​​Thieves are not created by Rare. They are old songs ...

Old songs that have been around for literally centuries

Just take reference of a good tune and pirate music, with a letter of that same ...

Um, I don't think that that anime has been around since the age of piracy.

I don't see why it would be wrong.

That opens a whole new can of worms. Other people would complain to the devs about how other songs aren't in the game.

I don't see any problem with honoring a Pirate Anime that has a longer history than Sea of ​​Thieves itself.

If the devs added a new shanty, it would be A Pirate's Life for Me.

As for your racist side, that's where you said "we aren't Japanese pirates, how bout no."

How many of us watch anime?

And if you want to know the song is the link on youtube in English.

Yeah...no thanks.

@roller-of-dice said in Bink's Sake - Playsong - Request to Honor One Piece:

@supersnipper60

Pirate Code - Article 1
The Sea Calls To Us All
Everyone is welcome on the Sea of Thieves regardless of age, gender, race, sexuality, nationality or creed.

Thank you for retelling me the Pirate Code. What I meant was that other players would get mad when their songs weren't added. They would backlash at Rare and that's probably why the song won't be added.

@salfo2505 copywrite is why they prolly won't add it edit i just took a listen and I hate it I'm not racist but it's not a piraty song to me and good pirate songs are sea shanties or potc's songs (pirate's of the Caribbean) and the one i that i would love that they would add but can't because of copywrite is this https://youtu.be/3A19q7rysLs take a listen

@roller-of-dice said in Bink's Sake - Playsong - Request to Honor One Piece:

@salfo2505

The more songs the merrier, I say.
Heck, we've already seen references to Hook and Titanic, so I don't see a reason why we can't honor a pirate anime/manga. Even Pirates in the secluded Sea of Thieves have heard of the legendary treasure One Piece.

And we shall sail together

true but one piece isn't in the lore of the game and it's supposed to be historical and made up so the lore is different in both mediums

@galactic-geek

You don’t know music. Bink’s Sake is a pretty accurate reflection of sailor’s tavern songs. There are many examples of “shanties” in Sea of Thieves that are not work songs. It would fit into the game.

@closinghare208
You can’t say Bink’s Sake is not a “Piratey” song and then use Pirates of the Caribbean as an example. Both One Piece and PotC are modern adaptations of pirates and both songs from each are just as accurate to sailors songs and shanties.