Hello!
TLDR: I've been thinking about feedback for the game, and I wanted a place to write down my thoughts for future insider testing.
Section 1: Big Picture
-More than 1 playable character "slot"
--Since this is a pretty heavily cosmetic-based game, I think people should be allowed to have more than one character on the same account so that they can swap avatars and switch up the cosmetics every now and again. The addition of the Pirate Appearance Potion is AMAZING, but I think it could be taken a step further. That way, people who use the PAP and take hours to find that perfect character don't have to do it again if they want to rock a slightly different look for a bit.
-Stat-tracking weapons/equipment
--A lot of people say this isn't a numbers game, but I disagree. I've seen lots of posts asking how to check how many hours in game among other things. I think it would be awesome if they had stat trackers for things like number/type of skeletons killed, players killed, etc., with the weapons, and similar trackers for the equipment.
-Overcount for commendations
--When we get the last grade for a commendation, I think it would be awesome for the commendation to continue counting, or at least have an option to display that.
-More replay value for Tall Tales
--I know some people will disagree with my opinion of the Tall Tales. I do like the Tall Tales, but I don't see much value in replaying them after the 2nd or 3rd time once all of the commendations were completed. I did complete them all and unlock the Gold Hoarder curse, but I just wish there was more to them than the monotonous grind to complete them 5 times for nothing but that one commendation (and with no reason to go forward and complete them after). I like the direction that they took with the newest two, but I still wish there was a little more reward for the multiple times requirement for completion. Again, I know some will disagree with my take on the TTs, but I just wanted to put my thoughts down there.
-Clothing dye
--We have underwear dye and hair dye, but I think it would be pretty awesome to be able to make your own color basic clothes from the clothing shop. Instead of buying 5 cosmetics from the store with the same design, but different color, let us buy the clothing dyes and one set of that cosmetic so that we can customize our own colors.
Section 2: Smaller Picture
-Having more event-exclusive commendations/rewards
--I feel like there were a lot of events early in the game's release that lead to a lot of really cool cosmetics. With the addition of the Black Market (which I think is a great idea), those rewards didn't diminish, though. The Black Market has a color variant of event items, so I think the events should be more frequent and offer more exclusive cosmetics for the pirates lucky enough to be able to participate
-More fully colored hulls and ripped sails!
--I know the addition of the deck and underneath each ship coloring is relatively new, but I think those cosmetics are awesome for the ships. Instead of having to look at the plain wood coloring all the time, I love the way that some Livery changes the inside of ships. As far as the ripped sails go, it makes it much easier to see ahead of you while you're sailing. Maybe it's a crutch, but as a pirate, I don't really like the idea of sailing the seas with pristine sails all the time. Maybe some dirt, even :)
