@sdmittensyt
I'm gonna say pretty much the same thing I said in another thread about this...
I think the intention of the paywall is to limit the amount of times a player rerolls and probably think very hard about whether they want to do it or not. When it costs real money, you're much less inclined to want to do it often, or even do it at all.
Throughout the game's lifespan, Rare have seemed very reluctant about the whole idea of letting players re-roll their character. Even though they ultimately ended up saying yes and doing it, I think their intention was always that we would pick a character and that character we picked would be who you are in the world of Sea of Thieves.
Pirate re-roll should not be taken lightly, and it should absolutely cost you. Blowing through the character selection screen is no excuse. Not taking the character selection seriously and just picking a meme pirate is not an excuse. Nobody should be entitled to a freebie for these things...
Extra skin slots are a no from me for the same reason... Your character model should not be readily interchangeable at the drop of a hat.
So what's my personal verdict?
Character rerolls should be treated like an absolute last resort for a player who just absolutely hates the character they picked. It should not be another regularly customizable feature.
Locking it behind a pay wall is the perfect implementation of this feature, as it deters the player from treating this like just another customization option....