[mod edited] To Lower The Unrealistic Commendation Achievement requirements

  • Achievements for doing X amount of times has to be lowered simply cause they are unrealistic to get and most gamers dont have the time or patience for these near impossible achievements. Could take up to 1000+ hours for them to be achieved. It isnt even fun at that point to have to boost and boost and boost to unlock them. Examples
    1000 Gunpowder barrels delivered on time/1000 Banana Crates delivered on time/1000 Shipwrecked chests sold/1000 Villianous skulls sold. Id also like to point out the 500 Voyages in each faction, so 1500 voyages to complete. YIKES considering the higher level you are, the longer the voyages take to complete with more chapters which is very tedious and all the other Commendation achievements or how I like the say the grindy ones need to be lowered and or altered without sparking a boost method within making requirements appear more on the map.

    Edit: Id also like the point out Banana crates I have never seen on merchant voyages itself. Only in messages in the bottles spawned on random islands. Curently sitting on 2/1000 on 200 hours of playing and being level 45 merchant. Also whats the point of the commendations when they give you bare minimun xp? By the time youre Pirate legend what would be the incentive to complete commendations? For the title I guess but who thought these numbers were fair.

    To all them whiners aka Sea of Babies: Achievements are suppose to be fun and challenging, not grindy and tedious. Doesnt matter if you go for achievements or just simply like completing your favorite games while some games you dont go for them in. Id like to point out these commendation achievements are not hard what so ever. They are a waste of time and nearly impossible to calculations. So if you think thats fair and fun than you have to learn the basics of what really is an achievement to you? Wasting your time or to have fun/challenge.

    First thing first, if we dont make this issue known than it will never be fixed. It may not be an issue to many but is an issue to others. Upvote, Share, link or anyway possible for us to let Rare know. Other game developers have lowered or changed achievements for them to obtainable either cause they were broken or simply too unrealistic to achieve.

    Examples, Gears of war 4, Killer instinct which are 1st party games on xbox so Im hoping for a change in the near future :)

    If this issue is affecting you, than share [mod edited]!

  • 281
    Posts
    213.2k
    Views
  • o.O wow ... ... just wow ... Can't say that I agree with you here. Lowering standards to appease those that don't want to put in the effort ... no ... don't think that's the path I'd recommend. For the game or society in general.

  • It may seem a bit grindy yeah, but at the same time dude it's just an achievement. It's a little bit entitled to say "It has to be easier because I can't do it."

    I don't remember complaints about Gears of War's "Seriously" Achievements.

  • I agree with the poster on this one. I like to complete every aspect of the game no matter how difficult the challenge is, but this annoyingly unrealistic. I've played nearly 40 hours with friends doing the quests and have only found 1 cannonball chest 0 banana crates and only a handful of the other items need for these fetch quests. I'm not against lowering them fully, but increasing the spawnrate while decreasing the value of said items I feel would be the best way to make both sides happy. To respond to Ghost 0f Dawn's Seriously argument. No one complained because 10k kills on the first one only took 120 hours, 100k kills on the second game took 30 hours, and you could AFK nearly all of the third games most grindy challenges. Going back to where I said I only found 1 cannonball box in 40 hrs with my luck that could take me 40,000 hours or you know a little more than 5 years of straight playing time.

  • Take a look at Friday The 13th:The Game
    Only need 2 achievements left for 100%.
    500 multiplayer matches as Jason.
    1,000 multiplayer matches played as Jason.
    I have 1,000 hours played.
    I'm at 95% for 500 matches played.

    If the host quits when you are Jason you receive no progress towards the achievements.
    Host quitting and ending the match for everyone happens often.
    No dedicated servers on Xbox.

    Perfect example of a BS achievement that needs to be lowered.
    I understand if some achievements need to be reworked to be obtainable.
    Without sinking 2,000 hours into a game.

  • @ghost-0f-dawn Funny thing is they changed Seriously 4.0. They changed the ribbon part of it.

  • @rickydown Also funny if you look at the timeline of how society shifted into the "participation trophy" generation that thinks they should be allowed to earn everything no matter what, it also matches this.

  • Upvote to Rare to give me a million gold just because I want it. The game needs dedication, Rare consider some achievements to be awarded with years playing the game not a month. That's normal dude

  • Sorry, guys, but this is a game that is meant to be played for hundreds of hours. You're never going to have an easy road here.

  • “This game doesn’t have enough content!” Then requests the game reduces it’s content...

  • Ok, so I consider myself a 'Completionist' when it comes to video games...I like to obtain all of the games achievements. I love aiming for more challenging achievements as I find them much more rewarding HOWEVER, I do kind of agree that these are in actual fact incredibly unrealistic with the games current state. I'm not suggesting they necessarily reduce the requirements significantly, but increase the chances to allow some of these quests to be obtained or even allow us to purchase them would be an even better start. They ARE unrealistic and would require 1000's upon 1000's of hours right now.

  • @ghost-0f-dawn how many locust we had to kill? 1 Million? 2 Million. The moment i saw this i was like „ok no completion for me“.

  • The criteria for the commendation achievements are ridiculous and should be lowered to a 100 chests/crates etc. It still would be grindy, but at least it would be completable. Considering how monotonous it would be to actually do this after several thousand hours, I hope Rare will listen and lower it some.
    I remember when Killer Instinct came out and there were achievements requiring you to play 2000 matches (which is crazy) with every character, but after a while they lowered it to 200.

  • What does earning a commendation achieve?

  • Are you level 50 in those guilds yet? No? Then how do you know that you won't be getting 2-3 sorrow chests for a gold mission?

    Fyi, I'm not level 50 but I've found a bunch of most of these "rare" items by ensuring I explore every island I'm sent to thoroughly. Approx 50% of the islands I visit have some kind of loose chest or crate or skull or quest washing around.

    edit: once I hit 45, I saw noticable uptick in such items and having just bumped into a pirate legend, they're even more common on legend missions. 1000 is probably quite high, but we should keep in mind the future expansions may drop them more frequently, and that this isn't a game to crack out in a weekend - they're playing the long game. So in a year, when you're getting a few a day from future content, it might not seem so bad.

    For the merchants, I just started getting snake quests. I'm guessing cannonball/banana crate aren't too far behind.

  • @ghost-0f-dawn Never said this. Why are you bringing hate negativity in a post meant to help everyone? No one is complaining about the game, and youre missing the fact on how ridiculous the achievements are. Not hard to get. Just a big waste of time considering how long it takes to get a few skulls, chests, etc.

  • @drakebg757 I personally never said that. But also achievements isnt content within the game. Im happy with the game and how it plays. Not happy about the achievements which has nothing to do with game content.

  • @lord-of-goats Cannonballs, banana crates seem to be random. Some are more common than others but still an inhuman amount of requirements for such a small sandbox game. Unless they add updates to increase drops rates or such would be cool.

  • @illdwarf8612070 New Title in game, and progress towards some achievements within the game.

  • My heart goes out to you poor achievement hunters.

  • @solemagician506 Dont even have to be a achievement hunter to spot how ridiculous the requirements are. And its not just Rare or SOT, it seems to becoming a trend in the gaming industry to have very annoying grindy achievements.

  • @rickydown
    I can't agree with you... Why people always want to make the games easier [mod edited]...

  • @butch3r87 I forgot about Killer instinct! Yeah they did change it. I can name other games also but their is no point to. But honestly 100 or 200 maybe even 300 would be a whole lot tolerable.

  • It just needs tiers. 250/500/1000 maybe?

  • @zay7sev Smh I think you dont realize it has nothing to do with making it easier. Its about how grindy and time worthy it is. And you cant sit there and tell me it isnt ridiculous. Cause if you played the game and seen how long it takes to get a few items than no one should disagree. And it doesnt affect gameplay at all to lower them.

  • @rickydown so...don't grind for them?

  • @rickydown
    That's the meaning of Legendary Status mate.. it has to be hard and long term thing... imagine all the players will achieve it just because some lazy dude like you wanted it to be decreased... everyone will run with Legendary ship and etc... sorry but i can't agree with you.

  • @solemagician506 Youre right thats an option. But if I love the game and have dedication to it than I wanna go for it. Lowered or not. Still would be nice to many if they were lowered. Even if u dont care about achievements.

  • @rickydown said in *Upvote* To Lower The Unrealistic Commendation Achievement requirements:

    @zay7sev Smh I think you dont realize it has nothing to do with making it easier. Its about how grindy and time worthy it is. And you cant sit there and tell me it isnt ridiculous. Cause if you played the game and seen how long it takes to get a few items than no one should disagree. And it doesnt affect gameplay at all to lower them.

    Those are called long term goals. Play the game for a year and see how many chests you find?

    That said, I've found a single bananna chest and i didn't know others even existed lol.

  • @klikhizz while I agree that some of the commendations are a bit demanding for a simple title (1000 banana crates really?) but these aren’t things that should be earned in a month, not even in a year of playing.

  • @elite-assasin87 Exactly... This is not a single player game which you can complete in 30-50 hours of game play.. This is a online game where you play with others and it has to be long term thing... otherwise there will be no point to play if you achieve everything in a month...

  • @zay7sev Again doesnt affect gameplay at all. Doesnt make it Legendary status at all. Cause im pretty sure people will reach Legendary before any of the achievements even unlock.

  • @rickydown I’m fine with commendations taking a long time to complete, that’s what makes them commendations, but some of them are a bit...meh, mostly the merchant ones. Could be more exciting.

  • @solemagician506 Yes long term goals, but I like to play other games also. And as much as I love SOT I dont see this game lasting a year unless they keep updating with new content. But I have my hopes up.

  • @elite-assasin87 Yeah I like the grind on games, but the amount for them are crazy. It still doesnt hurt anyone or the game to lower the requirements. Game has fantastic achievements and very original descriptions and such, but than have these commendations ones tied to it.

281
Posts
213.2k
Views
17 out of 281