After some time away, I decided to return to Sea of Thieves. This time, I chose not to use Game Pass since I rarely used it outside of this game, and instead purchased a redeem code.
After redeeming the code and installing the game on PC, I was met with a message saying I was banned. However, my account status shows that I am not banned.
When I contacted support, they confirmed that my account is not banned, but stated that the game license on my account is being shared with another account that has been permanently banned. Because of this, the license itself has been blocked from accessing the game on PC.
From my understanding, a purchased license should only be tied to my account, so it’s unclear how it could be affected by another player’s ban, especially as I have not intentionally shared access with anyone else.
Following their advice, I purchased a second license and worked with Xbox support to remove the original one. Despite this, the same issue persisted on PC.
I was then advised to use Game Pass instead, as this should provide a separate license and allow me to access the game. Game Pass does allow me to play on Xbox, however on PC the same Redbeard error still occurs, suggesting the issue is tied specifically to PC access rather than the account itself.
After waiting several days for further investigation, I was informed that no additional details would be provided and that no further responses would be given.
As a result, I am now unable to access the game on PC despite not being banned, and I cannot get refunds for either license since they have both been used. This has left me stuck with a Redbeard error that, based on the information provided, should not apply to my account.
This experience highlights a few areas that could be improved:
- Clearer handling of license sharing and how it impacts platform-specific access
- Better separation of entitlements between Xbox and PC to prevent conflicts like this
- More transparent communication when issues like this occur
- A proper resolution path for players who are confirmed not to be at fault but are still locked out
At the moment, it feels like there is no clear way forward despite following all the recommended steps, which makes it difficult for returning players to get back into the game.

