How the reputation tab should be organised

  • In my opinion, the actual order of the tabs doesn't make too much sense, and I think it's not organised. I've made some fan made shots ordering the reputations in the way I think is most optimal.


    First option: Re-order the reputations

    1st page:

    GH, OOS, MA

    In the first page, we could have the 3 original trading companies: Gold Hoarders, Order of Souls and Merchant Alliance.


    2nd page:

    HC, SD, AF

    In this second page, we would have the two trading companies added in the Anniversary Update: Hunter's Call and Sea Dogs, and we would also have Athena's Fortune in this page.

    You are going to ask Why did you organise it these two pages in this order? These two pages are organised to have the trading companies that are used to level up to Pirate Legend, and after them, we have the Pirate Legend reputation.


    3rd page:

    TT, BR
    In the last page, we would have the "special" companies or reputations: Tall Tales and The Bilge Rats. Also, there would be a blank space for any new special trading company.


    Second option: Create a 3x3 grid to display the reputations (New)


    A lot of you suggested that making a 3x3 grid would be better. I liked the idea so I've made a fan-made image with this layout.

    3x3 grid layout


    What do you think guys? Suggestions are welcome. But please, be polite.

    Captain EG.

  • 22
    Posts
    20.7k
    Views
  • Aye, I agree, but I do understand why the Tall Tales and Bilge Rat Adventures are in the first tab, to begin with.

  • @lt-swag-johnson Yes, I do too. That's why it's not organised. But if they add a new "special" reputation it could go where Hunter's Call is, and then, organise the other reputations accordingly.

  • @mr-dragon-raaar

    Same, I'd prefer to have everything on one page!

    And hopefully fixing the updating issue for the commendations where you have to open, close and open again the reputations to have them updated.

  • I'd rather be able to click and drag the separate faction panels on the reputation page.
    Then I could rearrange the factions to my liking.

  • @eggamer13 I'm with you about bringing in some order, but your page 3 should be page 1. Bilge Rat Adventures has had more additions to the commendations over the year than any other section and it looks like it will still be the case in near future. Over all people will be more likely to check for that section, putting it on the last page is suboptimal in my opinion.

  • @eggamer13 said in How the reputation tab should be organised:

    In my opinion, the actual order of the tabs doesn't make too much sense, and I think it's not organised. I've made some fan made shots ordering the reputations in the way I think is most optimal.


    1st page:

    GH, OOS, MA

    In the first page, we could have the 3 original trading companies: Gold Hoarders, Order of Souls and Merchant Alliance.


    2nd page:

    HC, SD, AF

    In this second page, we would have the two trading companies added in the Anniversary Update: Hunter's Call and Sea Dogs, and we would also have Athena's Fortune in this page.

    You are going to ask Why did you organise it these two pages in this order? These two pages are organised to have the trading companies that are used to level up to Pirate Legend, and after them, we have the Pirate Legend reputation.


    3rd page:

    TT, BR
    In the last page, we would have the "special" companies or reputations: Tall Tales and The Bilge Rats. Also, there would be a blank space for any new special trading company.


    What do you think guys? Suggestions are welcome. But please, be polite.

    Captain EG.

  • @eggamer13 said in How the reputation tab should be organised:

    In my opinion, the actual order of the tabs doesn't make too much sense, and I think it's not organised. I've made some fan made shots ordering the reputations in the way I think is most optimal.


    1st page:

    GH, OOS, MA

    In the first page, we could have the 3 original trading companies: Gold Hoarders, Order of Souls and Merchant Alliance.


    2nd page:

    HC, SD, AF

    In this second page, we would have the two trading companies added in the Anniversary Update: Hunter's Call and Sea Dogs, and we would also have Athena's Fortune in this page.

    You are going to ask Why did you organise it these two pages in this order? These two pages are organised to have the trading companies that are used to level up to Pirate Legend, and after them, we have the Pirate Legend reputation.


    3rd page:

    TT, BR
    In the last page, we would have the "special" companies or reputations: Tall Tales and The Bilge Rats. Also, there would be a blank space for any new special trading company.


    What do you think guys? Suggestions are welcome. But please, be polite.

    Captain EG.

    i would say i like it the way it is i don't really use it that much so that's why i like to keep it the same

  • what if they did a 3x3 set of panes like the bilge rat page?

  • I like the order the OP suggests, as well as the 1-page grid option.

  • @mr-dragon-raaar @Skulliah @Captain-Coel @Galactic-Geek I've updated the OP. I added the 3x3 layout that you suggested.

    Thanks for the suggestion mateys!

  • @eggamer13 That would be perfect like that, awesome work matey!

  • I prefer the 3x3 grid.

    As the Tall tales and Bilge Rats have useful & new content I like them to be on the first page for practical reasons.

  • @eggamer13 While I like your new 3x3 grid example, I've noticed that the stat blocks from the original are now missing (likely to save space). Where would we be able to see that particular information if your new layout was to take effect, do you think? Personally, I do like having that info at a glance.

  • @galactic-geek said in How the reputation tab should be organised:

    @eggamer13 While I like your new 3x3 grid example, I've noticed that the stat blocks from the original are now missing (likely to save space). Where would we be able to see that particular information if your new layout was to take effect, do you think? Personally, I do like having that info at a glance.

    You could get these informations by replacing what's inside a reputation tile with a hover effect?

  • @galactic-geek @Skulliah Yes, I thought about that. The stats would be inside the reputation. So you enter the reputation and you see the stats.

  • Agree entirely.

  • I like the grid option.

  • @eggamer13 Upvote for the second option (3x3 grid)

  • 3x3 grid for me. Today OP was a good guy.

  • I like the 3x3 grid, but I could work with either if you could click and drag the factions to rearrange them.

  • @eggamer13 I think you have a wonderful representation of organization within these tabs and i hope Rare listens to you about it. Not that any of it the way it is right now bothers me, but the way you have it organized like these two examples makes much more sense to me.

22
Posts
20.7k
Views
10 out of 22