Weapon Swap Speed in Sea of Thieves

  • Hi,

    I’d like to share my thoughts on the current weapon swap system in Sea of Thieves. I understand and appreciate the changes that have been made, as I recognize the old system was unfair to newer players who didn’t have the same advantages as veteran players. This was definitely a problem, and I can see why the changes were necessary.

    However, the current weapon swap feels too slow and limiting. While it’s understandable that the developers wanted to create a more balanced experience for all players, the slower swap speed now prevents both experienced and newer players from pulling off technical and stylish trickshots, which could add an extra layer of excitement and creativity to the game. These dynamic moments really bring the gameplay to life, and without them, it feels a bit stagnant.

    One possible solution could be to introduce an alternative method of swapping weapons, which could be faster than the current one, allowing players to execute these creative plays without compromising the balance. This way, both newer players and those with more experience could enjoy the game while keeping it fair and dynamic.

    Additionally, if the developers were to pay more attention to the feedback from experienced players (or, as I would call them, veterans), it could help address some of the issues with cheating. If players were encouraged to improve their skills and not fight against an unbalanced system, it could significantly deter people from cheating, as they wouldn’t want to face systems that push them to use cheats.

    The goal should be to find a balance that allows both new players to enjoy the game and learn, while also letting skilled players showcase their abilities and creativity. I truly believe that increasing the weapon swap speed, or providing an additional quicker method, could enhance the gameplay experience for everyone, without reverting back to the old, unbalanced system.

    Thank you for your attention, and I hope this suggestion will be considered in future updates.

    Best regards, slechtic.

  • 39
    Posts
    16.3k
    Views
    xbox onefeedbackcommunity
  • Probably won't happen, but that doesn't mean it shouldn't.

    They are so overwhelmed with bug fixing, performance issues, and the cheating/toxicity feedback that I just don't see it happening.

    Part of the feedback groups want the combat to be less "sweaty" so that numbers rule instead of individual performance. As well as people that want things they don't like nerfed. That being a big one.

    Some really skilled players still play at a very high and quick level of pvp. So there are still people that think others are exploiting/cheating just because they faced one of the higher skilled players in the game.

    A lot of things working against intentional fluid combat in sea of thieves.

  • Yes, but I don’t think that speeding up weapon swapping is something difficult to add to the game.

  • @mslechtic15 said in Weapon Swap Speed in Sea of Thieves:

    Yes, but I don’t think that speeding up weapon swapping is something difficult to add to the game.

    Any change means testing, and it means more chances of exploits being created/discovered. It opens up more bugs.

    Time, resources, and the reality of SoT is a lot of changes have made game or big picture combat significantly worse. There is risk there as well. Making it worse is kinda the only consistency combat has seen in SoT.

    I don't think it's a bad idea but tinkering with combat has really only worked out for players that want stuff nerfed or want bigger crews buffed up in pvp. These changes have not been kind in organic/defense pvp, underdog pvp, challenging pvp. There is a lot on the line for new changes to combat.

  • People that are going to cheat...are going to cheat, regardless.

    Using exploits/Cheats does not make anyone a "good" player, if anything it highlights how bad they are if they feel the need to resort to exploits/cheats.

    Quick-swapping weapons was removed for a reason.

    Willingly using exploits and/or cheats to accomplish something that has been removed intentionally DESERVES punishment.

    Actual good players adjust and adapt to such changes and don't rely on exploits/cheats.

    Just my 2 Cents.

  • That’s why I’m saying it should be changed… The main reason people cheat is because they feel like they’re fighting against the developers. They’re frustrated that the old, good Sea of Thieves is gone—quick swapping, Arena, and so on. It annoys them that the game hasn’t really progressed, but instead, unnecessary things have been removed, and new mechanics have been added just to cater to new players. In every game, there are always worse and better players.

  • The main reason people cheat is because they are bad at games but their ego won't allow them to admit it.

  • Cheater use cheat for many reason, is put hand in your eyes to believes it's because they just bad.
    Sure majority are bad, but somes other do boosting player or just want to make fun of ruining experiment of legit player.
    [mod removed]
    Dommage is done & player suffer then leave. Why is at t he legit player to report that if he know he will lost more time to do a video+ a ticket versus a cheater a new email.

    For back to main sujet i agree a bit with the OG, is not a problem to put somes delay on the two tap, but why Rare add a totaly cancel if you doing to fast ?
    U cant tell at one guys who played so many hours to adapt, just by memory muscle he will do it by instint. And if he force himself to learn he will lost mind doing it.
    Is a suffering need for enjoy game ? Is more easy to forgot the game & found another.
    Like just keeping the old swap keyboard but put a delay ingame for the swap weapon without handicap the player doing fast. Because that was realy good and rewarded to doing it the more fast u can.

    hf all & soz for my ENGL

    Ps : moderator u put anchor on my other post for 2 name but that was so many other thing i speaked about, like weapon & bug + i dont found normal is at me to make ticket for keep game safe, is the job to somebody when i payed game, but sorry for mentioned name)>.

  • The reasoning for cheating doesn't matter.

    Cheating is Cheating and deserves to be punished.

  • nobody call you to dont, we all agree to that ! personaly i just want Rare do it better, because cheater dont have real punishement instead of remake a account with a new email.
    new quickswap then ?

  • @look-behind-you Cheating is wrong, but we need to ask ourselves why most people do it. When the old Sea of Thieves was around, there weren’t as many cheaters—now it’s getting worse and worse.

  • The reason is because they want to do something they can't/aren't allowed to do.

    'Just' cheating to use quick-swapping is STILL cheating.

    Again, the reason is irrelevant. If you can't/aren't allowed to do something....don't do it. If you choose to then cheat to do it, expect consequences.

    Simply allowing people to cheat/exploit because they would just cheat anyway is not a solution nor will it decrease the number of cheaters....because they would still be cheating.

    Simply learn to adjust/adapt.

  • @look-behind-you is word cheater make you see red or ? OG post is about weapon & maybe get a new/rework quickswap... i give up

  • the slower swap speed now prevents both experienced and newer players from pulling off technical and stylish trickshots, which could add an extra layer of excitement and creativity to the game.

    Well... since you mention creativity, then it's time to be creative with positioning and actually making both shots count, now that quickswap got deservedly fixed.

    Before you had to aim once to hit twice. Too bad (not rly) you have to aim twice now.

    And regarding cheaters and bad exploiters - reason doesn't matter. You do a bannable offense, you get banned, reason got nothing to do with it. Simple as that.

  • pulling off technical and stylish trickshots, which could add an extra layer of excitement and creativity to the game

    This isn’t CoD. No need for tricks or style. Just stab, explode, poison and shoot

  • @mslechtic15 said in Weapon Swap Speed in Sea of Thieves:

    That’s why I’m saying it should be changed… The main reason people cheat is because they feel like they’re fighting against the developers. They’re frustrated that the old, good Sea of Thieves is gone—quick swapping, Arena, and so on. It annoys them that the game hasn’t really progressed, but instead, unnecessary things have been removed, and new mechanics have been added just to cater to new players. In every game, there are always worse and better players.

    This isn't directed towards you, I just wanted to comment on cheaters who claim to be doing it for "reasons". I've run into a couple people like this in HG, cheaters tend to run their mouths and spam offensive nonsense in an attempt to get attention, I guess, but occasionally some of them use their words; I've had some informal "interviews" with some of these donkeys, and I've heard the "Rare did this thing I don't like and now I'm a freedom cheater". I find that to be the most pathetic excuse. This is just a video game, anyone revenge cheating or whatever has got to get a life.

  • @mslechtic15 said in Weapon Swap Speed in Sea of Thieves:

    @look-behind-you Cheating is wrong, but we need to ask ourselves why most people do it. When the old Sea of Thieves was around, there weren’t as many cheaters—now it’s getting worse and worse.

    Cheating in video games is pathetic, simple as that. Cheaters are degenerates and they're likely total trash without their crutch.

  • @mslechtic15 said in Weapon Swap Speed in Sea of Thieves:

    Additionally, if the developers were to pay more attention to the feedback from experienced players (or, as I would call them, veterans), it could help address some of the issues with cheating. If players were encouraged to improve their skills and not fight against an unbalanced system, it could significantly deter people from cheating, as they wouldn’t want to face systems that push them to use cheats.

    If some quick swappers decided to cheat after it's removal or because they were beaten by better players like you claim, that means that they never were players worth keeping anyways.

    Regardless, this isn't a good point. Cheaters were always in the game, and they always will be. I don't doubt that there are people who started cheating after their quick swap was removed, but they are FAR from the majority of cheaters.

    The actual reason cheaters rose in numbers was with the inclusion of hourglass, a dedicated PVP mode which gave a lot of insecure people reason to turn on "godmode" and go mad, basically.

    I won't argue with your other points about why weapon switch should be faster. There are some good points there, I suppose. This reply is just a critique of your "making switching faster would significantly deter people from cheating!" point.

  • @thorumsu Yes, but I mean it more like this—if the devs considered everyone and tried to balance players’ demands properly while actually doing something, there wouldn’t be as many cheaters. The developers aren’t doing anything, nothing has changed in the game, and it’s dying. It’s not the players or cheaters who are to blame, but unfortunately, the creators themselves.

  • @look-behind-you said:

    The main reason people cheat is because they are bad at games but their ego won't allow them to admit it.

    I find this to be a very surface level thought.

    Players cheat because it's fun. Some do it to grief others and are malicious. A lot just use FoV and stop at that. Others use skin changers or PAK for resources and that's that, list goes on.

    I also have to disagree that cheaters are automatically bad players skill wise.
    I've known and seen some really good players that have unfortunately turned to cheats later on before perma quitting the game as a final goodbye.

    There still better then the vast majority of players that plays this game before their cheating escapade.
    Cheating is VERY VERY common in this game due to it's lackluster anti-cheat.

    ESP was massive back in the day before Gummy stopped updates, to give you an example of how big it was, ESP had 20k + downloads in mere days of a new udpate.
    Steam has less then 6k average monthly players to put that into comparison.... OH and that was before RARE hinted at EAC coming in the game...
    Imagine having 20,000 players cheating using ESP, that's a single cheating software by the way out of the many...

    Yet RARE were in hard Cope/Denial gaslighting competitive players that were spotlighting the cheating issue long before Hourglass came out and they could no longer deny it... Hence the EAC announcement...

    Players turned too cheats to when they saw how RARE was acting and lying. Oh and also killing Arena bred people turning to cheats, although most honestly just quit and never looked back...

  • The game is not "dying" because people are unable to exploit quick-swapping.

    Again, those that are actually good at the game adapted and were STILL good.

    Those that relied on exploits to be 'good', were never that good to begin with.

    Those who then resorted to cheating just to maintain their perceived 'goodness' are the same people who complain about getting banned for "no reason".

    If you are unable to play fairly, then there are plenty of other games to play.

    Sinking to the level of cheating/exploiting is just proof that they were never good (in a cartoony Pirate game at that....) and should probably accept that they can't 'win' every time and just enjoy games rather than trying to be the best at them....which will they will never be as they require cheating/exploits to do so, completely negating any kind of skill they claim they had.

    The amount of people that cheat 'just' for quick-swapping is minimal but nonetheless they are still cheating and deserve any consequences they may face.

  • @veronik5682 People who cheat are automatically worse at games than a first-day new pirate...because they cheat.

    If you need to cheat, then you are bad at games.

    If people are unable to play a game fairly, they are not welcome and should move on to other games.

    It is THAT simple.

    Sadly, ego doesn't allow that.

  • @look-behind-you said

    Those who then resorted to cheating just to maintain their perceived 'goodness' are the same people who complain about getting banned for "no reason".

    [mod removed] That wasn't just a petty perma ban from the Sea of Thieves either, that was a Microsoft ban, meaning players family's on Microsoft accounts that had NOTHING to do with the game were banned from Microsoft services...

    That bred a lot of cheaters out of spite from that.

    There's a lot more examples of unjustly false bans.
    If the game doesn't even have a robust anti cheat I can bet the support team also doesn't have a robust detection system
    The two go hand in hand...

  • @mslechtic15 I don't think they will or should ever balance with cheaters in mind. And as mentioned they likely intentionally want to reduce the skill gap. After all, it is new players that keep numbers up and make money compared with small percentage of experienced top tier pvp population.

  • @veronik5682 As your post goes against the Forum Rules, it has been edited.

    Discussing Disciplinary Actions

    Discussion of disciplinary actions taken against individual players is not permitted on the Forums. Topics and posts with this content will be locked, deleted and the users involved warned. Ignoring the warning will result in a temporary ban from the Forums and a final warning. If the action continues, a permanent ban from the Forums will be issued.


    If the person involved wants more information or to appeal then they would need to contact Support as it is not something that can be discussed on the Forums.

  • I can back what @Veronik5682 said before the mod edit.

    Players got unjustly redbearded it's been proven many times over in many cases over the years.

    Former Comp player and have a friend that was caught in the cross fire of what was mentioned in the mod edit.

    Edit: If there was no anti-cheat, then support had to rely on Un-deniable hard proof that someone was cheating to be given a Redbeard. Via footage, so players were and still are the main anti-cheat of the game in all honesty..

    But look at the spectrum here, if a mod is having a bad day and doesn't know the game to it's full extent they could be fooled that someone was cheating when they weren't, hence a false Redbeard is issued.
    Such as clone Gamertag with an 'I' instead of a 'l'.

  • @ix-indi-xi . You can submit a support ticket via Rare Player Support if you believe there has been an error or you have issue with any Moderation actions.

    Implying that I am having a 'bad day' because I am simply following the Forum Rules is certainly a take.

  • @hiradc No, new players don’t keep the numbers up. The game is dying. If experienced and long-time players who left the game because the developers are doing nothing but making the game worse were still playing, the game would be in a completely different place.

  • @veronik5682 I completely agree.

  • I think we all share the same opinion that the game is dying, and if RARE doesn’t do something about it, the game will completely end… We need to get all the OG players back into the game – we need to bring back the glory this game once had

  • @look-behind-you

    Implying that I am having a 'bad day' because I am simply following the Forum Rules is certainly a take.

    When did I ever say you were having a bad day?
    Re-read what I typed out.
    It's like you read out the first 5 words and automatically jumped and assumed I was typing about you when not at all? You're not even in the discussion at all outside of the censoring part.
    Also I was backing what the other person originally said in past tense, so linking a report link in this context is odd...

    @MSlechtic15

    We need to get all the OG players back into the game – we need to bring back the glory this game once had

    I don't see it happening at all, the game would need not only drastic changes but make that work to. There's no reason to think that, they are set on their path with S15/S16 and so on... There's no going back, literally.

  • @ix-indi-xi I think that if the whole Sot community united, it’s possible.

  • @ix-indi-xi

    But look at the spectrum here, if a mod is having a bad day and doesn't know the game to it's full extent they could be fooled that someone was cheating when they weren't, hence a false Redbeard is issued.
    Such as clone Gamertag with an 'I' instead of a 'l'.

    If you are confusing Mods with Customer Support, then Mods don't have the power to enforce anything in game. Again, if anybody has any issue with Moderation actions they can contact Support

  • you mean after send 10 000 footage of cheater we need to contact support because we cant tell we tired on forum ? What a joke.
    like indi tell is playerbase the official anti cheat here. And it's useless when is fresh account cheaters because they just do a new adresse mail and can cheat again on SoT. This should not be the case !!!
    And we all hope Rare work on something for fixing this issue. FAST. Because we all want the game we play stay in love for all.
    Waiting that, enjoy new machine gun from thoses $$$$$ infortunaly.

    I will stop answer here because the way the sujet is going & oriented (by modo????) is like promote cheater instead of speaking of a real new/old change for quickswap.

  • @tyjp-0 if you have sent in 10,000 reports with proof I'd be amazed that none resulted in action. Unless you are just mass reporting in hope...or quite possibly...exaggerating the numbers.

    I report a fair amount of people but do so with proof. I don't just report everyone who sinks me thinking "I was better so they must be cheating!"

    EDIT Just to add, Quick swap was a crutch/exploit that has been removed/balanced, it is not coming back. Cheating to do so....is STILL CHEATING.

39
Posts
16.3k
Views
xbox onefeedbackcommunity
7 out of 39