@racmop where did you swim down to see the ferryman?

So after playing yesterday, I am convinced;

A. Hidden hideout isn't in this version
B. It's hidden in a rock and not an island

Just saw another thread on this same topic with others theorizing hours ago what I said. Haha! Maybe we should combine the two posts? You know, have one place to go with a complete list of our ideas. It’d be a much more thorough process imo.

Pirates and sailors were able to cure scurvy by ingesting fresh lemons/juice. Could “No Lemons”=Scurvy Isles? The Black Sand “Atoll” is slightly NE of it, with Old Faithful lying between. They share the same region, “The Wilds”...just a thought...

@mad-jack-ketch honestly I think someone needs to just call up James Cameron n get his sub to explore the depth of the SoT ocean. Can someone mod him into the game? We may even find cameronium...

Seriously though I like your sleuthing. When the full game hits it'll be easier to figure out. Until then we can only speculate and accumulate.

@brozplaygamez For the hideout, i'm thinking you gotta swim through a cave or something similar as the "Door" to the hideout isn't open yet.

@mad-jack-ketch the Bermuda triangle?

No Lemons Atoll and now this...?

Whom said the waterfall was actually visible? What if the waterfall is in a cave or what if the hideout isn't on an island but huge rocks?

@suave-beard the reef you are on about has the empty cave when you swim under? If so that’s really not helping with the hideout as such :)

@racmop where can you see the ferryman in the water?

@mad-jack-ketch there is an uncharted island with a hidden cave in the center of the map close to where that circle is. If you see the crossword puzzle as a big map. And with 26 letters in the alphabet 13 is dead center for everything!

@suave-beard I feel as though I know the island of which you speak.
I'd describe it as an atoll or reef.
Certainly more interesting UNDER than atop it.

There is an uncharted island not being mentioned in this thread that has some interesting content on it and under it.

Although having spent a few hours on it I can't say I feel it has much to do with the secret tavern, unless it is part of a puzzle, and the rest is elsewhere.

All will be revealed soon :)

@mad-jack-ketch aye.. what be in the distance fellow cap’n?

I got a hunch on where it is now hehe :P

@racmop I had that idea, but the next thing is, how'd ya get your ship in?

Is this the entrance perhaps? Possibly not maybe so... who knows? But where's the waterfall

@racmop Haha, in that contract you must bring me food and drink! :P

Well I don't care about progress in this stress test, I will be sailing the ocean till I find it.

@racmop Enjoy

@racmop Agreed.