Like anyone else I have been wishing for outfit presets ever since the game came out. That doesn't seem to be happening any time soon though. Something that I would like just as much is the ability to mark certain cosmetics (for ship as well as pirate) as favorites with a little heart or star icon with the ability to filter them out, just like we are able to filter unowned items in the shops.

This could even be done in the shops to have a sort of 'wishlist'.