Community Poll #1 - Which one is your favourite? [CLOSED]

  • Oh wow this is more question than i expected, uhhhh...

    1. Best Area:
      A. The Shores of Plenty. It's just a beautiful and calm region.
    2. Best Ship/Boat:
      D. Rowboat. Who needs a boat when you have a rowboat?
    3. Best Trading Company:
      C. Merchant Alliance. Known to be the most hated, tis me most loved. I like animals what can i say?
    4. Best Emergent Encounter:
      B. Karen. Skeleton ships destroy me so not that, and until i get me shrouded ghost its not gonna be meg.
    5. Best Cloud Event:
      B. Skeleton Ships Battle. Very intense, but i'm not all that good at it.
    6. Best Campaign NPC:
      C. Salty. He's too cute i can't just not love him.
    7. Best Shop:
      E. Bilge Rat Shop. I'm a bilge boi what can i say.
    8. Best Cursed Chest:
      A. Chest of a Thousand Grogs. I needs me grog, I NEED IT!
    9. Best Instrument
      A. Hurdy-Gurdy. It plays a nice bass.
    10. Best Gold Hoarder Quest:
      A. X-Marks. I'd rather not do a riddle one, takes too long for not a good payoff.
    11. Best Merchant Alliance Quest:
      A. Animals. I like chickens, and only chickens.
    12. Best Animal:
      A. Chicken. It doesn't spit venom in my face and it doesn't steal me bananas.
    13. Best Cargo:
      B. Rum Bottles. More rum rum for me tum tum.
    14. Best Skeleton:
      B. Plant Skeleton. They eat their leafy greens
    15. Best Content Update:
      A. Forsaken Shores. It included so many cool things and new characters, had and still have a lot of hype for it.
    16. Best Campaign:
      A. The Hungering Deep. The first campaign be the best campaign. Merrick was there, he one of my favourites. Last time i had a crew too, so good memories.
    17. Best Bilge Rat Adventure:
      E. Festival of the Damned. 'Twas very spoopy.
    18. Best Outpost:
      B: Golden Sands. Very visually appealing and also in my favourite region.
    19. Worst Outpost:
      E. Dagger Tooth Outpost. It's in the wilds, too gloomy. Too wide spread so its hard to get from one place to another.
    20. Best Stronghold Item:
      D. Crate of Ancient Bone Dust. It sells for a lot. Also the keg kills me to many times, so not that.
    21. Best Cursed Cannonball:
      I. Grogball. Makes me drunk, what else can i really want?
    22. Best Weapon:
      A. Cutlass. Good for mobility and also some nice duels.
    23. Best event in the sky:
      A. Sunset. Sunsets are always pretty.
    24. First thing you do at the beginning of a session:
      B. Choose a ship livery. I like my cosmetics.
    25. Best Cave:
      A. Sailor's Bounty. Got a very extensive cave system, its really nice looking too but hard to navigate. Pretty weird question.
    26. Best Fortress:
      A. Keel Haul. I manage to get this fort solo a lot, so yea. But i also hardly know any forts.
    27. Best Pond:
      D. Mermaid's Hideaway. I don't know really any forts, but mermaid's hideaway has some nice underwater caves in it.
    28. Best Environmental FX:
      C. Fog. It's so cool, a great addition with some great immersion and battles.
    29. Best Alliance Name:
      G. The Undefeated Grog-Swiggers. SOMEONE SAY GROG?!
    30. Best Waterfall:
      H. Crooks Hollow. Its the only waterfall i can remember, but a good one at that.
    31. Best Shipwreck:
      A. The Killer Whale. Man i want Merrick back

    Kind of wish i knew that i should do this format before i did it all wrong and had to redo it again. But that's fine.

  • Best Area
    A. The Shores of Plenty
    
    Best Ship/Boat
    B. Brigantine
    
    Best Trading Company
    C. Merchant Alliance
    
    Best Emergent Encounter
    C. Skeleton Ship (not the cloud event)
    
    Best Cloud event
    A. Skeleton Fort
    
    Best Campaign NPC
    A. Merrick
    
    Best Shop
    E. Bilge Rat Shop
    
    Best Cursed Chest
    B. Chest of Sorrow
    
    Best Instrument
    C. Drum
    
    Best Gold Hoarder Quest
    B. Riddles
    
    Best Merchant Alliance Quest
    A. Animals
    
    Best Animal
    A. Chicken
    
    Best Cargo
    A. Plants
    
    Best Skeleton
    B. Plant Skeleton
    
    Best content update
    D. Shrouded Spoils
    
    Best campaign
    A. The Hungering Deep
    
    Best Bilge Rat Adventure
    B. Gunpowder Skeletons
    
    Best Outpost
    F. Galleon's Grave Outpost
    
    Worst Outpost
    C. Plunder Outpost
    
    Best Stronghold Item
    C. Stronghold Powderkeg
    
    Best Cursed Cannonball
    C. Ballastball
    
    Best Weapon
    A. Cutlass
    
    Best event in the sky
    C. Eclipse
    
    First thing you do at the beginning of a session
    B. Stocking supplies
    
    Best Cave
    Q. Flintlock Peninsula
    
    Best Fortress
    F. The Crow's Nest Fortress
    
    Best Pond
    D. Mermaid's Hideaway
    
    Best Environmental FX
    B. Volcano Eruption
    
    Best Alliance name
    A. The Terrifying Powder Monkeys
    
    Best Waterfall
    H. Devil's Ridge
    
    Best Shipwreck
    C. The Blackwyche
    

    (Edit: I have no idea why it is formatted this way, I just copy pasted. Please send help)

    1. Best Area
      C. The Ancient Isles, Perfect mix between smooth sailing and being crushed with rocks
    2. Best Ship/Boat
      B. Brigatine
    3. Best Trading Company
      A. Gold Hoarders
    4. Best Emergent Encounter
      B. Karen
    5. Best Cloud Event
      B. Skeleton Ship Battle, Still scares the hell out of me every
      time
    6. Best Campaign NPC
      A. Merrick, Such a good songwriter
    7. Best Shop
      A. Clothing Store, Snazzy hats at a bargain
    8. Best Cursed Chest
      A. Chest of a Thousand Grogs, For obvious reasons ;)
    9. Best Instrument
      B. Concertina
    10. Best Gold Hoarder Quest
      B. Riddles, I love some food for thought, almost as much as
      regular food
    11. Best Merchant Alliance Quest
      B. Cargo Runs, So what if I steal a few bottles they won't
      notice.
    12. Best Animal
      A. Chicken, so tasty
    13. Best Cargo
      B. Rum Bottles
    14. Best Skeleton
      A. Classic Skeleton
    15. Best Content Update
      C. Forsaken Shores, Love the grog they have out there.
    16. Best Campaign
      A. Hungering Deep, Miss you Merrick
    17. Best Bilge Rat Adventure
      C. The Suken Curse
    18. Best Outpost
      F. Galleon's Grave Outpost, Some of the best grog and the
      best people to share it with
    19. Worst Outpost
      A. Sanctuary Outpost, Tracy keeps inviting me to Old Age Pirate lunch. Not that old!
    20. Best Stronghold Item
      C. Stronghold Powder Keg, Gotta love treasure with a bit
      of utility
    21. Best Cursed Cannonball
      C. Ballastball, nothing brings down a galleon faster
    22. Best Weapon
      C. Pistol, Ol' Blue has never lead me astray
    23. Best Event in the sky
      D. Eclipse
    24. First thing you do at the beginning of a session
      D. Choosing a voyage gotta, have a course before the sails
      drop
    25. Best Cave
      U. K9 Uncharted Island, I happen to have an affinity to ol'
      dog island
    26. Best Fortress
      H. Kraken Watchtower
    27. Best Pond
      I. Devil's Ridge, It's like a day at the bathhouse, only the
      bathhouse can kill you.
    28. Best environmental FX
      A. Storm, It feels like you're battling the sea itself
    29. Best Alliance name
      G. The Undefeated Grog-swiggers, because it's true
    30. Best Waterfall
      J. Fletcher's Rest, it's like a warm shower, a really
      warm shower.
    31. Best Shipwreck
      A. The Killer Whale, Merrick's Swan Song is a beautiful
      sight.
  • @personalc0ffee said in Poll time - Which one do you prefer?:

    (Edit: I have no idea why it is formatted this way, I just copy pasted. Please send help)

    Haha it looks nice and clean ;)

  • @skulliah
    31. The best barrel to scrape the bottom of:
    A. A good stout Barrel on the dock
    B. A broken Barrel
    C. A barell with bananas printed on the side

    1. Best Area
      A. The Shores of Plenty
    1. Best Ship/Boat
      C. Sloop
    1. Best Trading Company
      A. Gold Hoarder
    1. Best Emergent Encounter
      C. Skeleton Ship (not the cloud event)
    1. Best Cloud event
      A. Skeleton Fort
    1. Best Campaign NPC
      B. Wanda/Captain Warsmith
    1. Best Shop
      A. Clothing Shop
    1. Best Cursed Chest
      B. Chest of Sorrow
    1. Best Instrument
      A. Hurdy-Gurdy
    1. Best Gold Hoarder Quest
      A. X-Marks
    1. Best Merchant Alliance Quest
      A. Animals
    1. Best Animal
      A. Chicken
    1. Best Cargo
      A. Plants
    1. Best Skeleton
      B. Plant Skeleton
    1. Best content update
      D. Shrouded Spoils
    1. Best campaign
      B. Cursed Sails
    1. Best Bilge Rat Adventure
      D. Cursed Crews
    1. Best Outpost
      B. Golden Sands Outpost
    1. Worst Outpost
      E. Dagger Tooth Outpost
    1. Best Stronghold Item
      C. Stronghold Powderkeg
    1. Best Cursed Cannonballl
      B. Peaceball
    1. Best Weapon
      C. Pistol
    1. Best event in the sky
      A. Sunset
    1. First thing you do at the beginning of a session
      C. Choosing a ship livery
    1. Best Cave
      U. K9 Uncharted Island (Skeleton Throne Cave)
    1. Best Fortress
      F. The Crow's Nest Fortress
    1. Best Pond
      D. Mermaid's Hideaway
    1. Best Environmental FX
      A. Storm
    1. Best Alliance name
      A. The Terrifying Powder Monkeys
    1. Best Waterfall
      H. Devil's Ridge
    1. Best Shipwreck
      C. The Blackwyche

    Pretty Nice Post @Skulliah Can't wait to see the community's results

    1. Best Area
      A. The Shores of Plenty

    2. Best Ship/Boat
      A. Galleon

    3. Best Trading Company
      C. Merchant Alliance

    4. Best Emergent Encounter
      C. Skeleton Ship (not the cloud event)

    5. Best Cloud event
      A. Skeleton Fort

    6. Best Campaign NPC
      A. Merrick

    7. Best Shop
      E. Bilge Rat Shop

    8. Best Cursed Chest
      B. Chest of Sorrow

    9. Best Instrument
      C. Drum

    10. Best Gold Hoarder Quest
      A. X-Marks

    11. Best Merchant Alliance Quest
      B. Cargo runs

    12. Best Animal
      A. Chicken

    13. Best Cargo
      B. Rum Bottles

    14. Best Skeleton
      B. Plant Skeleton

    15. Best content update
      D. Shrouded Spoils

    16. Best campaign
      A. The Hungering Deep

    17. Best Bilge Rat Adventure
      B. Gunpowder Skeletons

    18. Best Outpost
      B. Golden Sands Outpost

    19. Worst Outpost
      E. Dagger Tooth Outpost

    20. Best Stronghold Item
      B. Stronghold Chest

    21. Best Cursed Cannonball
      C. Ballastball

    22. Best Weapon
      D. Eye of Reach

    23. Best event in the sky
      B. Sunrise

    24. First thing you do at the beginning of a session
      B. Stocking supplies

    25. Best Cave
      G. Wanderer's Refuge (Wanda's Hideout)

    26. Best Fortress
      A. Keel Haul

    27. Best Pond
      D. Mermaid's Hideaway

    28. Best Environmental FX
      C. Fog

    29. Best Alliance name
      A. The Terrifying Powder Monkeys

    30. Best Waterfall
      C. Discovery Ridge

    31. Best Shipwreck
      C. The Blackwyche

  • By the way! I wish there was also a category for crates. Exotic spices, extraordinary minerals and precious gems are soooo cool :)

    1. Best Area
      A. The Shores of Plenty

    2. Best Ship/Boat
      C. Sloop

    3. Best Trading Company
      A. Gold Hoarders

    4. Best Emergent Encounter
      B. Kraken

    5. Best Cloud event
      A. Skeleton Fort

    6. Best Campaign NPC
      A. Merrick

    7. Best Shop
      A. Clothing Shop

    8. Best Cursed Chest
      B. Chest of Sorrow

    9. Best Instrument
      B. Concertina

    10. Best Gold Hoarder Quest
      A. X-Marks

    11. Best Merchant Alliance Quest
      B. Cargo runs

    12. Best Animal
      B. Pig

    13. Best Cargo
      B. Rum Bottles

    14. Best Skeleton
      D. Gold Skeleton

    15. Best content update
      D. Shrouded Spoils

    16. Best campaign
      A. The Hungering Deep

    17. Best Bilge Rat Adventure
      B. Gunpowder Skeletons

    18. Best Outpost
      B. Golden Sands Outpost

    19. Worst Outpost
      D. Ancient Spires Outpost

    20. Best Stronghold Item
      C. Stronghold Powderkeg

    21. Best Cursed Cannonball
      B. Peaceball

    22. Best Weapon
      A. Cutlass

    23. Best event in the sky
      B. Sunrise

    24. First thing you do at the beginning of a session
      C. Customize ship

    25. Best Cave
      A. Sailor's Bounty

    26. Best Fortress
      C. Sailor's Knot Stronghold

    27. Best Pond
      C. Wanderer's Refuge

    28. Best Environmental FX
      C. Fog

    29. Best Alliance name
      A. The Terrifying Powder Monkeys

    30. Best Waterfall
      H. Devil's Ridge

    31. Best Shipwreck
      C. The Blackwyche

  • @princes-lettuce said in Community Poll #1 - Which one is your favourite?:

    By the way! I wish there was also a category for crates. Exotic spices, extraordinary minerals and precious gems are soooo cool :)

    Merchant crates is going to be a long list but it's noted for a next edition! :)

  • @skulliah
    Best Area
    D. The Devil's Roar

    Best Ship/Boat
    A. Galleon

    Best Trading Company
    B. Order of Souls

    Best Emergent Encounter
    C. Skeleton Ship (not the cloud event)

    Best Cloud event
    B. Skeleton Ships Battle

    Best Campaign NPC
    A. Merrick

    Best Shop
    E. Bilge Rat Shop

    Best Cursed Chest
    A. Chest of a Thousand Grogs

    Best Instrument
    A. Hurdy-Gurdy

    Best Gold Hoarder Quest
    A. X-Marks

    Best Merchant Alliance Quest
    B. Cargo runs

    Best Animal
    B. Pig

    Best Cargo
    A. Plants

    Best Skeleton
    D. Gold Skeleton

    Best content update
    B. Cursed Sails

    Best campaign
    A. The Hungering Deep

    Best Bilge Rat Adventure
    C. The Sunken Curse

    Best Outpost
    E. Dagger Tooth Outpost

    Worst Outpost
    F. Galleon's Grave Outpost

    Best Stronghold Item
    D. Crate of Ancient Bone Dust

    Best Cursed Cannonball
    F. Anchorball

    Best Weapon
    D. Eye of Reach

    Best event in the sky
    D. Lunar Sky

    First thing you do at the beginning of a session
    B. Stocking supplies

    Best Cave
    T. Ashen Reaches

    Best Fortress
    A. Keel Haul

    Best Pond
    A. Crescent Isle

    Best Environmental FX
    B. Volcano Eruption

    Best Alliance name
    C. The Unstoppable Skinflints

    Best Waterfall
    E. Shark Bait Cove

    Best Shipwreck
    B. The Shroudbreaker

  • Best Area
    B. The Ancient Isles

    Best Ship/Boat
    C. Sloop

    Best Trading Company
    B. Order of Souls

    Best Emergent Encounter
    B. Karen

    Best Cloud event
    A. Skeleton Fort

    Best Campaign NPC
    A. Merrick

    Best Shop
    E. Bilge Rat Shop

    Best Cursed Chest
    A. Chest of a Thousand Grogs

    Best Instrument
    A. Hurdy-Gurdy

    Best Gold Hoarder Quest
    A. X-Marks

    Best Merchant Alliance Quest
    A. Animals

    Best Animal
    A. Chicken

    Best Cargo
    A. Plants

    Best Skeleton
    B. Plant Skeleton

    Best content update
    D. Shrouded Spoils

    Best campaign
    A. The Hungering Deep

    Best Bilge Rat Adventure
    B. Gunpowder Skeletons

    Best Outpost
    D. Ancient Spires Outpost

    Worst Outpost
    E. Dagger Tooth Outpost

    Best Stronghold Item
    C. Stronghold Powderkeg

    Best Cursed Cannonball
    F. Anchorball

    Best Weapon
    C. Pistol

    Best event in the sky
    B. Sunrise

    First thing you do at the beginning of a session
    B. Stocking supplies

    Best Cave
    A. Sailor's Bounty

    Best Fortress
    H. Kraken Watchtower

    Best Pond
    F. Shark Bait Cove

    Best Environmental FX
    A. Storm

    Best Alliance name
    A. The Terrifying Powder Monkeys

    Best Waterfall
    H. Devil's Ridge

    Best Shipwreck
    A. The Killer Whale

  • Best Area
    A. The Shores of Plenty : my favorite island is Cannon Cove, I feel like I lived all my life there before getting pirate legend..

    Best Ship/Boat
    B. Brigantine : love her mobility and I like to be in a crew of 3.

    Best Trading Company
    A. Gold Hoarder : this guys are so mysterious, I can't wait to discover more lore about this company

    Best Emergent Encounter
    A. Megan : when nostalgia hits you. Megan will always be in my heart

    Best Cloud event
    B. Skeleton Ships Battle : definitely this one as I get used to the forts. Especially with the new additions of skelly sloop which are funny to battle !

    Best Campaign NPC
    A. Merrick : I can't wait to see his come back (I know he will). This is the most charismatic NPC they made since launch.

    Best Shop
    C. Shipwright Shop ; don't really bother about clothes, I just love ship customization and which we could do more..

    Best Cursed Chest
    A. Chest of a Thousand Grogs : I am part of a french pirate team called L'Arche du Grog. All of our identity is about Grog stuff. We love grog.

    Best Instrument
    C. Drum : drunk whistle is one of the best features in this game.

    Best Gold Hoarder Quest
    B. Riddles : it is the only quest types that make us really look around and notice every single detail devs has placed on islands. It is for me a way to really pay attention to their work. And what happen everytime go to the next step (sound + wind blowing around + vegetation moving) will always give me goose bumps.

    Best Merchant Alliance Quest
    A. Animals : golden chicken golden chicken golden chicken

    Best Animal
    A. Chicken : golden chicken golden chicken golden chicken

    Best Cargo
    A. Plants : hate rhum, hate clothe, hate plants, but hate less than others

    Best Skeleton
    B. Plant Skeleton : most satisfying skelly type to kill; also love their animation when they get wet (plants on them becoming green and flowered)

    Best content update
    D. Shrouded Spoils : the updtate that used the best features of the previous and tweaked them in the best and most funny way

    Best campaign
    A. The Hungering Deep : when nostalgia hits you

    Best Bilge Rat Adventure
    B. Gunpowder Skeletons : most of the time, all the server was on the ferry of the damned but everyone was laughing as there were explosions EVERYWHERE, it changed the gameplay drastically

    Best Outpost
    C. Plunder Outpost : this island is so majestic. I don't know why.. I just love it

    Worst Outpost
    E. Dagger Tooth Outpost : we all know why

    Best Stronghold Item
    A. Stronghold Skull : best money, like the design !

    Best Cursed Cannonball
    The ball that makes the ship heavier.
    I'm sorry I really couldn't figure out which one it was in the list :/

    Thanks Skulliah, I'll try to learn their english name :D

    Best Weapon
    C. Pistol

    Best event in the sky
    B. Sunrise : best time for screenshots

    First thing you do at the beginning of a session
    B. Stocking supplies :

    Best Cave
    G. Wanderer's Refuge (Wanda's Hideout) : this was the best discover of the Cursed Sails campaign. I wasn't expecting it at all, I had real goose bumps first time I entered it

    Best Fortress
    A. Keel Haul

    Best Pond
    E. Discovery Ridge

    Best Environmental FX
    C. Fog : this is a real experience

    Best Alliance name
    G. The Undefeated Grog-swiggers : grog grog grog

    Best Waterfall
    H. Devil's Ridge : very cinematographic (is that even a word ?)

    Best Shipwreck
    B. The Shroudbreaker : Just love the name. This is one of the best thing that english has and french hasn't. The ability to give very cool names by crafting them with existing words. I like the story of this ship also !

    EDIT : Added explanations

  • @chronik-gatas said in Community Poll #1 - Which one is your favourite?:

    Best Cursed Cannonball
    The ball that makes the ship heavier.
    I'm sorry I really couldn't figure out which one it was in the list :/

    I got you, it's the Ballastball :)

  • @skulliah said in Community Poll #1 - Which one is your favourite?:

    Woooo loving all these answers! A lot of hate for our dearest Dagger Tooth Outpost apparently but lots of Blackwyche and Chicken lovers! All your answers have been noted, can't wait to see more. That's really interesting to read your choices! :D

    @x-Crowheart-x There are so many questions that I wanted to add, but the list was starting to be quite long for the forum, it will be for a second edition! :D

    All is good. I added the category for fun. Lantern color was a question that popped in my head answering the poll. Had fun deciding my choices. Could have answered more. Also like seeing what others think, especially their comments as to why they selected their answers.

    On some I had more than one favorite. I like the Blackwyche shipwreck. Blackwyche had it's own video game. I had a Commodore 64. Actually had many, if not most of all the earlier home computers and game consoles. However, the Shroudbreaker has its story and it is a story we all are now part of.

    Need to do another poll after we get all the great things coming in the new year.

  • @skulliah not got many followers, but thought id share the love too

    https://twitter.com/DuMy_2008/status/1073628024568983554

  • @x-Crowheart-x

    Indeed, I think the most interesting part is to discover why people chose these. I think that our choices are also related to our experiences and stories we've had in these places, that's why I wanted to put some funny questions as the best pond or the best cave. However I am quite surprised that the votes are a bit unanimous for the best waterfall where I expected more diversity! :P


    @dumy2008 That's awesome, thank you! :D

    I also shared it on Reddit:

    https://www.reddit.com/r/Seaofthieves/comments/a63vy0/ahoy_reddit_were_doing_a_funny_community_poll_on/

    We already have 30 entries, can't wait to read more opinions! :D

  • @skulliah Tag me when the next list comes out matey. This was enjoyable to go through and revisit so many adventures by trying to narrow down the finer aspects of the game. Brought back several good and a couple of bad memories. So many good times in this game. And this type of poll, and the fact that so much more could be added, just show what an amazing game this is and how much is involved.

  • Best Area
    A. The Shores of Plenty

    Best Ship/Boat
    A. Galleon

    Best Trading Company
    B. Order of Souls

    Best Emergent Encounter
    C. Skeleton Ship (not the cloud event)

    Best Cloud event
    A. Skeleton Fort

    Best Campaign NPC
    A. Merrick

    Best Shop
    C. Shipwright Shop

    Best Cursed Chest
    A. Chest of a Thousand Grogs

    Best Instrument
    A. Hurdy-Gurdy

    Best Gold Hoarder Quest
    A. X-Marks

    Best Merchant Alliance Quest
    A. Animals

    Best Animal
    A. Chicken

    Best Cargo
    A. Plants

    Best Skeleton
    C. Shadow Skeleton

    Best content update
    D. Shrouded Spoils

    Best campaign
    A. The Hungering Deep

    Best Bilge Rat Adventure
    B. Gunpowder Skeletons

    Best Outpost
    A. Sanctuary Oupost

    Worst Outpost
    F. Galleon's Grave Outpost

    Best Stronghold Item
    C. Stronghold Powderkeg

    Best Cursed Cannonball
    C. Ballastball

    Best Weapon
    A. Cutlass

    Best event in the sky
    C. Eclipse

    First thing you do at the beginning of a session
    B. Stocking supplies

    Best Cave
    C. Lone Cove

    Best Fortress
    A. Keel Haul

    Best Pond
    H. The Crow's Nest Fortress

    Best Environmental FX
    A. Storm

    Best Alliance name
    F. The Renowned Scoundrels

    Best Waterfall
    H. Devil's Ridge

    Best Shipwreck
    C. The Blackwyche

  • @nofears-fun

    I see this first little poll a bit like a Sea of Thieves awards of in-game features so I can't wait to highlight what the forumites chose. I'm glad to see that people enjoy to answer it and read each answers!

    I love the fact that some questions are tough choices, that's the fun part. While this one is mostly focussing on our favourites, I have some machiavellian ideas for future questions and different type of poll :P

  • @hynieth
    o:

    1. Best Area
      A. The Shores of Plenty

    2. Best Ship/Boat
      B. Brigantine

    3. Best Trading Company
      A. Gold Hoarder

    4. Best Emergent Encounter
      C. Skeleton Ship (not the cloud event)

    5. Best Cloud event
      A. Skeleton Fort
      B. Skeleton Ships Battle

    6. Best Campaign NPC
      A. Merrick

    7. Best Shop
      A. Clothing Shop

    8. Best Cursed Chest
      A. Chest of a Thousand Grogs

    9. Best Instrument
      C. Drum

    10. Best Gold Hoarder Quest
      A. X-Marks

    11. Best Merchant Alliance Quest
      B. Cargo runs

    12. Best Animal
      A. Chicken

    13. Best Cargo
      C. Clothes

    14. Best Skeleton
      C. Shadow Skeleton

    15. Best content update
      B. Cursed Sails

    16. Best campaign
      A. The Hungering Deep

    17. Best Bilge Rat Adventure
      B. Gunpowder Skeletons

    18. Best Outpost
      A. Sanctuary Oupost

    19. Worst Outpost
      D. Ancient Spires Outpost

    20. Best Stronghold Item
      D. Crate of Ancient Bone Dust

    21. Best Cursed Cannonball
      J. Limpball

    22. Best Weapon
      A. Cutlass

    23. Best event in the sky
      A. Sunset

    24. First thing you do at the beginning of a session
      B. Stocking supplies

    25. Best Cave
      B. Smuggler's Bay

    26. Best Fortress
      F. The Crow's Nest Fortress

    27. Best Pond
      A. Crescent Isle

    28. Best Environmental FX
      C. Fog

    29. Best Alliance name
      F. The Renowned Scoundrels

    30. Best Waterfall
      B. Crescent Isle

    31. Best Shipwreck
      C. The Blackwyche

  • Best Area
    A. The Shores of Plenty

    Best Ship/Boat
    B. Brigantine

    Best Trading Company
    A. Gold Hoarder

    Best Emergent Encounter
    C. Skeleton Ship (not the cloud event)

    Best Cloud event
    A. Skeleton Fort

    Best Campaign NPC
    A. Merrick

    Best Shop
    E. Bilge Rat Shop

    Best Cursed Chest
    A. Chest of a Thousand Grogs

    Best Instrument
    A. Hurdy-Gurdy

    Best Gold Hoarder Quest
    A. X-Marks

    Best Merchant Alliance Quest
    A. Animals

    Best Animal
    A. Chicken

    Best Cargo
    C. Clothes

    Best Skeleton
    B. Plant Skeleton

    Best content update
    D. Shrouded Spoils

    Best campaign
    A. The Hungering Deep

    Best Bilge Rat Adventure
    B. Gunpowder Skeletons

    Best Outpost
    C. Plunder Outpost

    Worst Outpost
    E. Dagger Tooth Outpost

    Best Stronghold Item
    C. Stronghold Powderkeg

    Best Cursed Cannonball
    C. Ballastball

    Best Weapon
    A. Cutlass

    Best event in the sky
    D. Lunar Sky

    First thing you do at the beginning of a session
    B. Stocking supplies

    Best Cave
    A. Sailor's Bounty

    Best Fortress
    I. Shark Fin Camp

    Best Pond
    D. Mermaid's Hideaway

    Best Environmental FX
    A. Storm

    Best Alliance name
    G. The Undefeated Grog-swiggers

    Best Waterfall
    H. Devil's Ridge

    Best Shipwreck
    A. The Killer Whale

  • Frist off i want to say this is a fantastic post and i'm happy to contribute.

    1. Best Area

      A. The Shores of Plenty
      
    2. Best Ship/Boat

         D. Rowboat
      
    3. Best Trading Company

      A. Gold Hoarder
      
    4. Best Emergent Encounter

      C. Skeleton Ship (not the cloud event)
      
    5. Best Cloud event

        A. Skeleton Fort
      
    6. Best Campaign NPC

      A. Merrick
      
    7. Best Shop

         E. Bilge Rat Shop
      
    8. Best Cursed Chest

         B. Chest of Sorrow
      
    9. Best Instrument

      A. Hurdy-Gurdy
      
    10. Best Gold Hoarder Quest

    A. X-Marks
    
    1. Best Merchant Alliance Quest
    A. Animals
    
    1. Best Animal

      A. Chicken
      
    2. Best Cargo

    A. Plants
    
    1. Best Skeleton

      D. Gold 
      
    2. Best content update

      D. Shrouded Spoils
      
    3. Best campaign

      A. The Hungering Deep
      
    4. Best Bilge Rat Adventure

    B. Gunpowder Skeletons
    
    1. Best Outpost
    C. Plunder Outpost
    
    1. Worst Outpost
    E. Dagger Tooth Outpost
    
    1. Best Stronghold Item
    C. Stronghold Powderkeg
    
    1. Best Cursed Cannonball
    F. Anchorball
    
    1. Best Weapon
    A. Cutlass
    
    1. Best event in the sky
    C. Eclipse
    
    1. First thing you do at the beginning of a session
    C. Choosing a ship livery
    
    1. Best Cave
    G. Wanderer's Refuge (Wanda's Hideout)
    
    1. Best Fortress
    A. Keel Haul
    
    1. Best Pond
    D. Mermaid's Hideaway
    
    1. Best Environmental FX
    A. Storm
    
    1. Best Alliance name
    A. The Terrifying Powder Monkeys
    
    1. Best Waterfall
    H. Devil's Ridge
    
    1. Best Shipwreck
    B. The Shroudbreaker
    
  • Best Area
    A. The Shores of Plenty

    Best Ship/Boat
    A. Galleon

    Best Trading Company
    C. Merchant Alliance

    Best Emergent Encounter
    B. Karen

    Best Cloud event
    A. Skeleton Fort

    Best Campaign NPC
    A. Merrick

    Best Shop
    A. Clothing Shop

    Best Cursed Chest
    B. Chest of Sorrow

    Best Instrument
    A. Hurdy-Gurdy

    Best Gold Hoarder Quest
    A. X-Marks

    Best Merchant Alliance Quest
    B. Cargo runs

    Best Animal
    C. Snake

    Best Cargo
    B. Rum Bottles

    Best Skeleton
    C. Shadow Skeleton

    Best content update
    D. Shrouded Spoils

    Best campaign
    A. The Hungering Deep

    Best Bilge Rat Adventure
    A. Skeleton Thrones

    Best Outpost
    B. Golden Sands Outpost

    Worst Outpost
    E. Dagger Tooth Outpost

    Best Stronghold Item
    B. Stronghold Chest

    Best Cursed Cannonball
    C. Ballastball

    Best Weapon
    A. Cutlass

    Best event in the sky
    C. Eclipse

    First thing you do at the beginning of a session
    C. Choosing a ship livery

    Best Cave
    K. Thieves Haven

    Best Fortress
    E. Old Boot Fort

    Best Pond
    D. Mermaid's Hideaway

    Best Environmental FX
    C. Fog

    Best Alliance name
    F. The Renowned Scoundrels

    Best Waterfall
    H. Devil's Ridge

    Best Shipwreck
    C. The Blackwyche

  • ⚠ I've been alerted that Morrow's Peak Outpost wasn't in the lists.

    It's fixed now but if you wanted to choose it for the best or worst outpost, please let me know as I've already noted all the answers before this post! :)

    Thanks all!

  • @skulliah Thank you for that update, my answer's remain the same.

    1. Best Area: A, Shores of Plenty

    2. Best Ship: D. Rowboat

    3. Best Trading Company: A, Gold Hoarders

    4. Best Emergent Encounter, B. Karen

    5. Best Cloud Event: A, Skeleton Fort

    6. Best Campaign NPC: C, Salty

    7. Best Shop: B: Equipment Shop

    8. Best Cursed Chest: B, Chest of Sorrow

    9. Best Instrument: B, Concertina

    10. Best Gold Hoarder Quest: B, Riddles

    11. Best Merchant Alliance Quest: A, Animals

    12. Best Animal: A, Chicken

    13. Best Cargo: C, Rum Bottles

    14. Best Skeleton: B, Plant Skeleton

    15. Best Content Update: D. Shrouded Spoils

    16. Best Campaign: A, The Hungering Deep

    17: Best Bilge Rat Adventure: A, Skeleton Thrones

    1. Best Outpost: B, Golden Sands Outpost

    2. Worst Outpost: C, Plunder Outpost

    3. Best Stronghold Item: A, Stronghold Skull

    4. Best Cursed Cannonball: C, Ballastball

    5. Best Weapon: A, Sword

    6. Best Event in the Sky: D, Lunar Sky

    7. First thing you do a the beginning of a session: C, Choosing a ship livery

    25: Best Cave: V, N13 Uncharted Island (Merricks Journal Cave)

    26: Best Fortress: D, Lost Gold Fort

    1. Best Pond: K, Paradise Spring

    28: Best Environmental FX: A, Storm

    29: Best Alliance Name: D, The Spirited Landlubbers

    30: Best Waterfall: F, Thieves Haven

    31: Best Shipwreck: C, The Blackwhyche

  • Best Area
    B. The Ancient Isles

    Best Ship/Boat
    A. Galleon

    Best Trading Company
    A. Gold Hoarder

    Best Emergent Encounter
    B. Karen

    Best Cloud event
    B. Skeleton Ships Battle

    Best Campaign NPC
    A. Merrick

    Best Shop
    A. Clothing Shop

    Best Cursed Chest
    B. Chest of Sorrow

    Best Instrument
    A. Hurdy-Gurdy

    Best Gold Hoarder Quest
    A. X-Marks

    Best Merchant Alliance Quest
    B. Cargo runs

    Best Animal
    A. Chicken

    Best Cargo
    A. Plants

    Best Skeleton
    C. Shadow Skeleton

    Best content update
    A. The Hungering Deep

    • best social interaction of any update so far

    Best campaign
    A. The Hungering Deep

    Best Bilge Rat Adventure
    C. The Sunken Curse

    Best Outpost
    B. Golden Sands Outpost

    Worst Outpost
    E. Dagger Tooth Outpost

    Best Stronghold Item
    C. Stronghold Powder keg

    Best Cursed Cannonball
    C. Ballastball

    Best Weapon
    A. Cutlass

    Best event in the sky
    A. Sunset

    First thing you do at the beginning of a session
    B. Stocking supplies

    Best Cave
    A. Sailor's Bounty

    Best Fortress
    A. Keel Haul

    Best Pond
    D. Mermaid's Hideaway

    Best Environmental FX
    C. Fog

    Best Alliance name
    E. The Fearless Soap-dodgers

    Best Waterfall
    G. Crook's Hollow

    Best Shipwreck
    B. The Shroudbreaker

  • @skulliah Thanks !

    I edited my message to explain my choices !

    1. Best Area
      A. The Shores of Plenty
    1. Best Ship/Boat

    B. Brigantine

    1. Best Trading Company
      C. Merchant Alliance
    1. Best Emergent Encounter
      C. Skeleton Ship (not the cloud event)
    1. Best Cloud event
      B. Skeleton Ships Battle
    1. Best Campaign NPC
      C. Salty
    1. Best Shop
      C. Shipwright Shop
    1. Best Cursed Chest
      A. Chest of a Thousand Grogs
    1. Best Instrument
      C. Drum
    1. Best Gold Hoarder Quest
      A. X-Marks
    1. Best Merchant Alliance Quest
      A. Animals
    1. Best Animal
      A. Chicken
    1. Best Cargo
      A. Plants
    1. Best Skeleton

    C. Shadow Skeleton

    1. Best content update
      D. Shrouded Spoils
    1. Best campaign
      A. The Hungering Deep
    1. Best Bilge Rat Adventure
      A. Skeleton Thrones
    1. Best Outpost

    B. Golden Sands Outpost

    1. Worst Outpost

    D. Ancient Spires Outpost

    1. Best Stronghold Item

    C. Stronghold Powderkeg

    1. Best Cursed Cannonball

    G. Jigball

    1. Best Weapon
      A. Cutlass
    1. Best event in the sky

    D. Lunar Sky

    1. First thing you do at the beginning of a session

    B. Stocking supplies

    1. Best Cave
      A. Sailor's Bounty

    G. Wanderer's Refuge (Wanda's Hideout)

    1. Best Fortress

    E. Old Boot Fort

    1. Best Pond

    D. Mermaid's Hideaway

    1. Best Environmental FX

    B. Volcano Eruption

    1. Best Alliance name
      A. The Terrifying Powder Monkeys
    1. Best Waterfall
      A. Sailor's Bounty
    1. Best Shipwreck
      B. The Shroudbreaker
    1. Best Area
      A. The Shores of Plenty

    2. Best Ship/Boat
      A. Galleon

    3. Best Trading Company
      A. Gold Hoarder

    4. Best Emergent Encounter
      C. Skeleton Ship (not the cloud event)

    5. Best Cloud event
      A. Skeleton Fort

    6. Best Campaign NPC
      A. Merrick

    7. Best Shop
      C. Shipwright Shop

    8. Best Cursed Chest
      A. Chest of a Thousand Grogs

    9. Best Instrument
      A. Hurdy-Gurdy

    10. Best Gold Hoarder Quest
      B. Riddles

    11. Best Merchant Alliance Quest
      A. Animals

    12. Best Animal
      A. Chicken

    13. Best Cargo
      B. Rum Bottles

    14. Best Skeleton
      C. Shadow Skeleton

    15. Best content update
      D. Shrouded Spoils

    16. Best campaign
      A. The Hungering Deep

    17. Best Bilge Rat Adventure
      E. Festival of the Damned

    18. Best Outpost
      C. Plunder Outpost

    19. Worst Outpost
      E. Dagger Tooth Outpost

    20. Best Stronghold Item
      A. Stronghold Skull

    21. Best Cursed Cannonball
      G. Jigball

    22. Best Weapon
      A. Cutlass

    23. Best event in the sky
      B. Sunrise

    24. First thing you do at the beginning of a session
      B. Stocking supplies

    25. Best Cave
      V. N13 Uncharted Island (Merrick's Journal Cave)

    26. Best Fortress
      B. Hidden Spring Keep

    27. Best Pond
      M. Sunken Grove

    28. Best Environmental FX
      A. Storm

    29. Best Alliance name
      A. The Terrifying Powder Monkeys

    30. Best Waterfall
      H. Devil's Ridge

    31. Best Shipwreck
      C. The Blackwyche

  • Best Area
    A. The Shores of Plenty

    Best Ship/Boat
    C. Sloop

    Best Trading Company
    A. Gold Hoarder

    Best Emergent Encounter
    A. Megan

    Best Cloud event
    A. Skeleton Fort

    Best Campaign NPC
    A. Merrick

    Best Shop
    E. Bilge Rat Shop

    Best Cursed Chest
    A. Chest of a Thousand Grogs

    Best Instrument
    C. Drum

    Best Gold Hoarder Quest
    B. Riddles

    Best Merchant Alliance Quest
    B. Cargo runs

    Best Animal
    A. Chicken

    Best Cargo
    C. Clothes

    Best Skeleton
    B. Plant Skeleton

    Best content update
    D. Shrouded Spoils

    Best campaign
    A. The Hungering Deep

    Best Bilge Rat Adventure
    D. Cursed Crews

    Best Outpost
    A. Sanctuary Oupost

    Worst Outpost
    B. Golden Sands Outpost

    Best Stronghold Item
    B. Stronghold Chest

    Best Cursed Cannonball
    C. Ballastball

    Best Weapon
    C. Pistol

    Best event in the sky
    A. Sunset

    First thing you do at the beginning of a session
    B. Stocking supplies

    Best Cave
    A. Sailor's Bounty

    Best Fortress
    A. Keel Haul

    Best Pond
    D. Mermaid's Hideaway

    Best Environmental FX
    B. Volcano Eruption

    Best Alliance name
    A. The Terrifying Powder Monkeys

    Best Waterfall
    H. Devil's Ridge

    Best Shipwreck
    A. The Killer Whale

  • Best Area
    A. The Shores of Plenty

    Best Ship/Boat
    B. Brigantine

    Best Trading Company
    B. Order of Souls

    Best Emergent Encounter
    B. Karen

    Best Cloud event
    B. Skeleton Ships Battle

    Best Campaign NPC
    B. Wanda/Captain Warsmith

    Best Shop
    C. Shipwright Shop

    Best Cursed Chest
    A. Chest of a Thousand Grogs

    Best Instrument
    A. Hurdy-Gurdy

    Best Gold Hoarder Quest
    A. X-Marks

    Best Merchant Alliance Quest
    B. Cargo runs

    Best Animal
    A. Chicken

    Best Cargo
    A. Plants

    Best Skeleton
    D. Gold Skeleton

    Best content update
    D. Shrouded Spoils

    Best campaign
    C. Forsaken Shores

    Best Bilge Rat Adventure
    B. Gunpowder Skeletons

    Best Outpost
    F. Galleon's Grave Outpost

    Worst Outpost
    E. Dagger Tooth Outpost

    Best Stronghold Item
    C. Stronghold Powderkeg

    Best Cursed Cannonball
    C. Ballastball

    Best Weapon
    D. Eye of Reach

    Best event in the sky
    C. Eclipse

    First thing you do at the beginning of a session
    C. Choosing a ship livery

    Best Cave
    E. Cannon Cove

    Best Fortress
    I. Shark Fin Camp

    Best Pond
    I. Devil's Ridge

    Best Environmental FX
    C. Fog

    Best Alliance name
    E. The Fearless Soap-dodgers

    Best Waterfall
    H. Devil's Ridge

    Best Shipwreck
    A. The Killer Whale

  • @skulliah

    Best Area
    A. The Shores of Plenty

    Best Ship/Boat
    B. Brigantine

    Best Trading Company
    A. Gold Hoarder

    Best Emergent Encounter
    C. Skeleton Ship (not the cloud event)

    Best Cloud event
    A. Skeleton Fort

    Best Campaign NPC
    B. Wanda/Captain Warsmith

    Best Shop
    C. Shipwright Shop

    Best Cursed Chest
    A. Chest of a Thousand Grogs

    Best Instrument
    A. Hurdy-Gurdy

    Best Gold Hoarder Quest
    A. X-Marks

    Best Merchant Alliance Quest
    A. Animals

    Best Animal
    A. Chicken

    Best Cargo
    A. Plants

    Best Skeleton
    C. Shadow Skeleton

    Best content update
    D. Shrouded Spoils

    Best campaign
    B. Cursed Sails

    Best Bilge Rat Adventure
    A. Skeleton Thrones

    Best Outpost
    C. Plunder Outpost

    Worst Outpost
    E. Dagger Tooth Outpost

    Best Stronghold Item
    C. Stronghold Powderkeg

    Best Cursed Cannonball
    F. Anchorball

    Best Weapon
    A. Cutlass

    Best event in the sky
    A. Sunset

    First thing you do at the beginning of a session
    C. Choosing a ship livery

    Best Cave
    A. Sailor's Bounty

    Best Fortress

    D. Lost Gold Fort

    Best Pond

    D. Mermaid's Hideaway

    Best Environmental FX
    A. Storm

    Best Alliance name

    E. The Fearless Soap-dodgers

    Best Waterfall

    H. Devil's Ridge

    Best Shipwreck
    A. The Killer Whale

  • Best Area
    A. The Shores of Plenty

    Best Ship/Boat
    C. Sloop

    Best Trading Company
    B. Order of Souls

    Best Emergent Encounter
    A. Megan

    Best Cloud event
    A. Skeleton Fort

    Best Campaign NPC
    B. Wanda/Captain Warsmith

    Best Shop
    E. Bilge Rat Shop

    Best Cursed Chest
    A. Chest of a Thousand Grogs

    Best Instrument
    B. Concertina

    Best Gold Hoarder Quest
    A. X-Marks

    Best Merchant Alliance Quest
    A. Animals

    Best Animal
    A. Chicken

    Best Cargo
    B. Rum Bottles

    Best Skeleton
    B. Plant Skeleton

    Best content update
    B. Cursed Sails

    Best campaign
    A. The Hungering Deep

    Best Bilge Rat Adventure
    E. Festival of the Damned

    Best Outpost
    B. Golden Sands Outpost

    Worst Outpost
    E. Dagger Tooth Outpost

    Best Stronghold Item
    C. Stronghold Powderkeg

    Best Cursed Cannonball
    C. Ballastball

    Best Weapon
    B. Blunderbuss

    Best event in the sky
    A. Sunset

    First thing you do at the beginning of a session
    C. Choosing a ship livery

    Best Cave
    N. Ancient Spires Outpost
    Best Fortress
    D. Lost Gold Fort

    Best Pond
    D. Mermaid's Hideaway

    Best Environmental FX
    B. Volcano Eruption

    Best Alliance name
    G. The Undefeated Grog-swiggers

    Best Waterfall
    G. Crook's Hollow

    Best Shipwreck
    C. The Blackwyche

88
Posts
23.4k
Views
50 out of 88