Community Poll #1 - Which one is your favourite? [CLOSED]

  • poll time

    Ahoy maties!

    Alright, it's time for a poll and see what prefer the community in Sea of Thieves. As it's a first one, it will be quite long but I can't wait to know your answers, especially for the best cave and waterfall!

    If there is enough traction, I will do some pretty graphs to illustrate your preferences!

    Below the survey you'll find the way how to format your answer :)

    snake

    Here we go:

    1. Best Area
      A. The Shores of Plenty
      B. The Ancient Isles
      C. The Wilds
      D. The Devil's Roar

    2. Best Ship/Boat
      A. Galleon
      B. Brigantine
      C. Sloop
      D. Rowboat

    3. Best Trading Company
      A. Gold Hoarder
      B. Order of Souls
      C. Merchant Alliance

    4. Best Emergent Encounter
      A. Megan
      B. Karen
      C. Skeleton Ship (not the cloud event)

    5. Best Cloud event
      A. Skeleton Fort
      B. Skeleton Ships Battle

    6. Best Campaign NPC
      A. Merrick
      B. Wanda/Captain Warsmith
      C. Salty
      D. Grace/Captain Morrow
      E. Stitcher Jim

    7. Best Shop
      A. Clothing Shop
      B. Equipment Shop
      C. Shipwright Shop
      D. Weaponsmith Shop
      E. Bilge Rat Shop

    8. Best Cursed Chest
      A. Chest of a Thousand Grogs
      B. Chest of Sorrow

    9. Best Instrument
      A. Hurdy-Gurdy
      B. Concertina
      C. Drum

    10. Best Gold Hoarder Quest
      A. X-Marks
      B. Riddles

    11. Best Merchant Alliance Quest
      A. Animals
      B. Cargo runs

    12. Best Animal
      A. Chicken
      B. Pig
      C. Snake

    13. Best Cargo
      A. Plants
      B. Rum Bottles
      C. Clothes

    14. Best Skeleton
      A. Default Skeleton
      B. Plant Skeleton
      C. Shadow Skeleton
      D. Gold Skeleton

    15. Best content update
      A. The Hungering Deep
      B. Cursed Sails
      C. Forsaken Shores
      D. Shrouded Spoils

    16. Best campaign
      A. The Hungering Deep
      B. Cursed Sails
      C. Forsaken Shores

    17. Best Bilge Rat Adventure
      A. Skeleton Thrones
      B. Gunpowder Skeletons
      C. The Sunken Curse
      D. Cursed Crews
      E. Festival of the Damned

    18. Best Outpost
      A. Sanctuary Oupost
      B. Golden Sands Outpost
      C. Plunder Outpost
      D. Ancient Spires Outpost
      E. Dagger Tooth Outpost
      F. Galleon's Grave Outpost
      G. Morrow's Peak Outpost

    19. Worst Outpost
      A. Sanctuary Oupost
      B. Golden Sands Outpost
      C. Plunder Outpost
      D. Ancient Spires Outpost
      E. Dagger Tooth Outpost
      F. Galleon's Grave Outpost
      G. Morrow's Peak Outpost

    20. Best Stronghold Item
      A. Stronghold Skull
      B. Stronghold Chest
      C. Stronghold Powderkeg
      D. Crate of Ancient Bone Dust

    21. Best Cursed Cannonball
      A. Riggingball
      B. Peaceball
      C. Ballastball
      D. Barrelball
      E. Helmball
      F. Anchorball
      G. Jigball
      H. Venomball
      I. Grogball
      J. Limpball
      K. Wearyball

    22. Best Weapon
      A. Cutlass
      B. Blunderbuss
      C. Pistol
      D. Eye of Reach

    23. Best event in the sky
      A. Sunset
      B. Sunrise
      C. Eclipse
      D. Lunar Sky

    24. First thing you do at the beginning of a session
      A. Set sail
      B. Stocking supplies
      C. Choosing a ship livery
      D. Choosing a voyage

    25. Best Cave
      A. Sailor's Bounty
      B. Smuggler's Bay
      C. Lone Cove
      D. Crescent Isle
      E. Cannon Cove
      F. Mermaid's Hideaway
      G. Wanderer's Refuge (Wanda's Hideout)
      H. Plunder Valley
      I. Shark Bait Cove
      J. Snake Island
      K. Thieves Haven
      L. Crook's Hollow
      M. Devil's Ridge
      N. Ancient Spires Outpost
      O. Sunken Grove
      P. Fetcher's Rest
      Q. Flintlock Peninsula
      R. Ruby's Fall
      S. Morrow's Peak Outpost
      T. Ashen Reaches
      U. K9 Uncharted Island (Skeleton Throne Cave)
      V. N13 Uncharted Island (Merrick's Journal Cave)
      W. Discovery Ridge

    26. Best Fortress
      A. Keel Haul
      B. Hidden Spring Keep
      C. Sailor's Knot Stronghold
      D. Lost Gold Fort
      E. Old Boot Fort
      F. The Crow's Nest Fortress
      G. Skull Keep
      H. Kraken Watchtower
      I. Shark Fin Camp

    27. Best Pond
      A. Crescent Isle
      B. Hidden Spring Keep
      C. Wanderer's Refuge
      D. Mermaid's Hideaway
      E. Discovery Ridge
      F. Shark Bait Cove
      G. Thieves Haven
      H. The Crow's Nest Fortress
      I. Devil's Ridge
      J. Ancient Spires Outpost
      K. Paradise Spring
      L. Kraken's Fall
      M. Sunken Grove
      N. Blind Man's Lagoon
      O. Cursewater Shores
      P. Fetcher's Rest
      Q. Flintlock Peninsula
      R. Devil's Thirst

    28. Best Environmental FX
      A. Storm
      B. Volcano Eruption
      C. Fog

    29. Best Alliance name
      A. The Terrifying Powder Monkeys
      B. The Resolute Scallywags
      C. The Unstoppable Skinflints
      D. The Spirited Landlubbers
      E. The Fearless Soap-dodgers
      F. The Renowned Scoundrels
      G. The Undefeated Grog-swiggers

    30. Best Waterfall
      A. Sailor's Bounty
      B. Crescent Isle
      C. Discovery Ridge
      D. Plunder Valley
      E. Shark Bait Cove
      F. Thieves Haven
      G. Crook's Hollow
      H. Devil's Ridge
      I. Sunken Grove
      J. Fetcher's Rest

    31. Best Shipwreck
      A. The Killer Whale
      B. The Shroudbreaker
      C. The Blackwyche

    snake

    How to answer?

    Write the number of the question with its statement and add below the letter of your answer with its statement. Feel free to add an explanation of your choice if you want, it can be very interesting!

    Here's an example:

    1. Best Area
      D. The Devil's Roar

    2. Best Ship/Boat
      A. Galleon

    You can just copy and paste the whole survey and remove the answers you don't want :)

    One answer per question, if there are several, only the first will be counted.

    SoT

    It's up to you now!

  • 88
    Posts
    24.2k
    Views
    1. B
    2. A
    3. C
    4. C
    5. A
    6. C
    7. C
    8. A
    9. B
    10. B
    11. A
    12. A
    13. C
    14. B
    15. D
    16. A
    17. B
    18. D
    19. E
    20. C
    21. F
    22. A
    23. A
    24. C
    25. K
    26. E
    27. G
    28. C
    29. G
    30. F
    31. C

    P.S. I read the format afterwards I hope this doesn't hamper the survey but I'm lazy so no reformatting :-P

  • @hynieth

    Well, it's fine for me if I have to do some graphs later, but it would be more readable if everyone add the labels. The purpose of this survey is also to see what others think :)

    Thanks for the answers!


    I know it's not the most practical way for doing it but if everyone can try to integrate the labels, it would be perfect! :D

  • @skulliah

    1. Best Area
      A - The Shores of Plenty
    2. Best Ship/Boat
      B - The brig
    3. Best Trading Company
      hmmmmmmmmm. After doing so many of each, I am rather bored with them all. But if forced to pick just one, I guess OoS (B), but that depends on which island I have to fight them on.
    4. Best Emergent Encounter
      C, Skelly ships not even close on this one.
    5. Best Cloud Event
      B Skelly ships, though they both are pretty awesome, with A you usually get some really good PvP, but with B you are guaranteed you get to shoot your cannons.
    6. Best Campaign NPS
      They were/are all very good. I can't choose just one here.
    7. Best Shop
      E Bilge Rat
    8. Best Cursed Chest
      A Chest of Sorrow
    9. Best Instrument
      A Hurdy Gurdy, I can't play instruments in real life, the simplicity of the Hurdy Gurdy makes me think I could actually play that. LOL
    10. Best Gold Hoarder Quest
      B Riddles, more immersive to have to find clues.
    11. Best Merchant Alliance Quest
      A Animals
    12. Best Animal
      A Chicken
    13. Best Cargo
      none of them. LOL. Cargo runs were a mistake and should be removed from the game.
      14.Best Skeleton
      hmmmmm. Each one is better than the other depending on where you are facing them. So I can't chose one over the other.
    14. Best content update
      B, Cursed sails, though C Forsaken shores was a close second.
    15. Best campaign
      CForsaken shores (I would go with B cursed sails again, but the campaign itself felt more like going to work in Cursed Sails than a fun game, they corrected this by the time the event was over, but it took too long for the correction)
    16. Best Bilge Rat Adventure
      B Keg Skellies Hands down offered the most gut busting laughs of them all.
    17. Best outpost
      B Golden Sands
    18. Worst outpost
      E Dagger Tooth
    19. Best Stronghold item
      C Stronghold PowderKeg
    20. Best Cursed Cannonball
      Depends on situation it is used in. G Jigball is my favorite.
    21. Best Weapon
      A Cutlass
    22. Best Event in the Sky
      A Sunset
    23. First thing you do at the beginning of a session
      B Stock the boat, again. Worst part of the game.
    24. Best Cave
      Tie between A Sailor's bounty, H Plunder valley and L Crook's Hollow.
    25. Best Fortress
      A Keel Haul
    26. Best Pond
      D Mermaids, for many reason, including the fact that it becomes much more than just a simple pond. LOL
    27. Best environmental FX
      All of them are awesome in their own way, but I would give a very slight edge to C Fog.
    28. Best Alliance Name
      E The Fealess Soap-dodgers (anything that is named after me must be a winner)
    29. Best Waterfall
      D Plunder Valley
    30. Best Shipwreck
      Are these the names of the ships on the islands? If so, which one is which. I personally like the shipwreck at Old Salts Atoll, whichever one that is.
    1. Best Area
      B. The Ancient Isles
    2. Best Ship/Boat
      B. Brigantine
    3. Best Trading Company
      C. Merchant Alliance
    4. Best Emergent Encounter
      C. Skeleton Ship (not the cloud event)
    5. Best Cloud event
      A. Skeleton Fort
    6. Best Campaign NPC
      C. Salty
    7. Best Shop
      A. Clothing Shop
    8. Best Cursed Chest
      A. Chest of a Thousand Grogs
    9. Best Instrument
      B. Concertina
    10. Best Gold Hoarder Quest
      A. X-Marks
    11. Best Merchant Alliance Quest
      A. Animals
    12. Best Animal
      C. Snake
    13. Best Cargo
      A. Plants
    14. Best Skeleton
      B. Plant Skeleton
    15. Best content update
      A. The Hungering Deep
    16. Best campaign
      A. The Hungering Deep
    17. Best Bilge Rat Adventure
      D. Cursed Crews
    18. Best Outpost
      D. Ancient Spires Outpost
    19. Worst Outpost
      F. Galleon's Grave Outpost
    20. Best Stronghold Item
      D. Crate of Ancient Bone Dust
    21. Best Cursed Cannonball
      I. Grogball
    22. Best Weapon
      C. Pistol
    23. Best event in the sky
      A. Sunset
    24. First thing you do at the beginning of a session
      C. Choosing a ship livery
    25. Best Cave
      J. Snake Island
    26. Best Fortress
      D. Lost Gold Fort
    27. Best Pond
      D. Mermaid's Hideaway
    28. Best Environmental FX
      A. Storm
    29. Best Alliance name
      E. The Fearless Soap-Dodgers
    30. Best Waterfall
      G. Crook's Hollow
    31. Best Shipwreck
      A. The Killer Whale
    1. Best Area
      D. The Devil's Roar
    2. Best Ship/Boat
      A. Galleon
    3. Best Trading Company
      A. Gold Hoarder
    4. Best Emergent Encounter
      A. Megan
    5. Best Cloud event
      A. Skeleton Fort
    6. Best Campaign NPC
      A. Merrick
    7. Best Shop
      C. Shipwright Shop
    8. Best Cursed Chest
      B. Chest of Sorrow
    9. Best Instrument
      C. Drum
    10. Best Gold Hoarder Quest
      A. X-Marks
    11. Best Merchant Alliance Quest
      A. Animals
    12. Best Animal
      A. Chicken
    13. Best Cargo
      A. Plants
    14. Best Skeleton
      B. Plant Skeleton
    15. Best content update
      C. Forsaken Shores
    16. Best campaign
      A. The Hungering Deep
    17. Best Bilge Rat Adventure
      E. Festival of the Damned
    18. Best Outpost
      D. Ancient Spires Outpost
    19. Worst Outpost
      E. Dagger Tooth Outpost
    20. Best Stronghold Item
      C. Stronghold Powderkeg
    21. Best Cursed Cannonball
      K. Wearyball
    22. Best Weapon
      A. Cutlass
    23. Best event in the sky
      A. Sunset
    24. First thing you do at the beginning of a session
      B. Stocking supplies
    25. Best Cave
      V. N13 Uncharted Island (Merrick's Journal Cave)
    26. Best Fortress
      F. The Crow's Nest Fortress
    27. Best Pond
      D. Mermaid's Hideaway
    28. Best Environmental FX
      C. Fog
    29. Best Alliance name
      G. The Undefeated Grog-swiggers
    30. Best Waterfall
      H. Devil's Ridge
    31. Best Shipwreck
      C. The Blackwyche

    Some really hard ones, some really easy ones.. The best / worst outpost was a no-brainer for me :p
    The best skelleton depends on which side you are xD

    Anyway, nice poll! Looking forward for the results :)

  • Best Area
    A. The Shores of Plenty

    Best Ship/Boat
    B. Brigantine

    Best Trading Company
    C. Merchant Alliance

    Best Emergent Encounter
    C. Skeleton Ship (not the cloud event)

    Best Cloud event
    B. Skeleton Ships Battle

    Best Campaign NPC
    A. Merrick

    Best Shop
    C. Shipwright Shop

    Best Cursed Chest
    B. Chest of Sorrow

    Best Instrument
    B. Concertina

    Best Gold Hoarder Quest
    A. X-Marks

    Best Merchant Alliance Quest
    B. Cargo runs

    Best Animal
    A. Chicken

    Best Cargo
    A. Plants

    Best Skeleton
    C. Shadow Skeleton

    Best content update
    D. Shrouded Spoils

    Best campaign
    B. Cursed Sails

    Best Bilge Rat Adventure
    B. Gunpowder Skeletons

    Best Outpost
    C. Plunder Outpost

    Worst Outpost
    E. Dagger Tooth Outpost

    Best Stronghold Item
    C. Stronghold Powderkeg

    Best Cursed Cannonball
    C. Ballastball

    Best Weapon
    D. Eye of Reach

    Best event in the sky
    B. Sunrise

    First thing you do at the beginning of a session
    B. Stocking supplies

    Best Cave
    A. Sailor's Bounty

    Best Fortress
    F. The Crow's Nest Fortress

    Best Pond
    G. Thieves Haven

    Best Environmental FX
    A. Storm

    Best Alliance name
    F. The Renowned Scoundrels

    Best Waterfall
    G. Crook's Hollow

    Best Shipwreck
    C. The Blackwyche

  • Thanks for the poll!

    SoT

    snake

    1. Best Area
      B. The Ancient Isles

    2. Best Ship/Boat
      C. Sloop

    3. Best Trading Company
      B. Order of Souls

    4. Best Emergent Encounter
      C. Skeleton Ship (not the cloud event)

    5. Best Cloud event
      A. Skeleton Fort

    6. Best Campaign NPC
      C. Salty

    7. Best Shop
      C. Shipwright

    8. Best Cursed Chest
      A. Chest of a Thousand Grogs

    9. Best Instrument
      B. Concertina

    10. Best Gold Hoarder Quest
      B. Riddles

    11. Best Merchant Alliance Quest
      A. Animals

    12. Best Animal
      A. Chicken

    13. Best Cargo
      B. Rum Bottles - Come on we are pirates. We are not florists or fashion designers. Only one true answer here.

    14. Best Skeleton
      C. Shadow Skeleton

    15. Best content update
      D. Shrouded Spoils

    16. Best campaign
      A. The Hungering Deep

    17. Best Bilge Rat Adventure
      E. Festival of the Damned

    18. Best Outpost
      D. Ancient Spires Outpost

    19. Worst Outpost
      E. Dagger Tooth Outpost

    20. Best Stronghold Item
      C. Stronghold Powderkeg

    21. Best Cursed Cannonball
      F. Anchorball

    22. Best Weapon
      A. Cutlass

    23. Best event in the sky
      A. Sunset

    24. First thing you do at the beginning of a session
      C. Choosing a ship livery - No respectable pirate would want to be seen with a plain looking ship, even if he or she has not left port yet.

    25. Best Cave
      K. Thieves Haven

    26. Best Fortress
      G. Skull Keep - Just because of its name : )

    27. Best Pond
      G. Thieves Haven

    28. Best Environmental FX
      C. Fog

    29. Best Alliance name
      G. The Undefeated Grog-swiggers

    30. Best Waterfall
      F. Thieves Haven - Ok Rare just needs to make Thieves Haven our instanced pirate hangout. It has the best of everything!

    31. Best Shipwreck
      B. The Shroudbreaker

    Best Honorary Write In Category
    32. Best Lantern Flame
    Green - Tops off the eerie legend ghost ship look.

    snake

  • @skulliah :

    Best Area
    D. The Devil's Roar

    Best Ship/Boat
    A. Galleon

    Best Trading Company
    A. Gold Hoarder

    Best Emergent Encounter
    A. Megan

    Best Cloud event
    A. Skeleton Fort

    Best Campaign NPC
    A. Merrick

    Best Shop
    C. Shipwright Shop

    Best Cursed Chest
    A. Chest of a Thousand Grogs

    Best Instrument
    A. Hurdy-Gurdy

    Best Gold Hoarder Quest
    A. X-Marks

    Best Merchant Alliance Quest
    B. Cargo runs

    Best Animal
    A. Chicken

    Best Cargo
    C. Clothes

    Best Skeleton
    B. Plant Skeleton

    Best content update
    C. Forsaken Shores

    Best campaign
    A. The Hungering Deep

    Best Bilge Rat Adventure
    E. Festival of the Damned

    Best Outpost
    D. Ancient Spires Outpost

    Worst Outpost
    E. Dagger Tooth Outpost

    Best Stronghold Item
    C. Stronghold Powderkeg

    Best Cursed Cannonball
    A
    D
    G. Jigball (dance pretty dance!)

    Best Weapon
    A. Cutlass

    Best event in the sky
    A. Sunset

    First thing you do at the beginning of a session
    B. Stocking supplies

    Best Cave
    A. Sailor's Bounty

    Best Fortress
    F. The Crow's Nest Fortress

    Best Pond
    F. Shark Bait Cove

    Best Environmental FX
    A. Storm

    Best Alliance name
    E. The Fearless Soap-dodgers

    Best Waterfall
    G. Crook's Hollow

    Best Shipwreck
    C. The Blackwyche

  • Best Area
    A. The Shores of Plenty

    Best Ship/Boat
    C. Sloop

    Best Trading Company
    B. Order of Souls

    Best Emergent Encounter
    C. Skeleton Ship (not the cloud event)

    Best Cloud event
    A. Skeleton Fort

    Best Campaign NPC
    A. Merrick

    Best Shop
    C. Shipwright Shop

    Best Cursed Chest
    B. Chest of Sorrow

    Best Instrument
    A. Hurdy-Gurdy

    Best Gold Hoarder Quest
    A. X-Marks

    Best Merchant Alliance Quest
    B. Cargo runs

    Best Animal
    A. Chicken

    Best Cargo
    A. Plants

    Best Skeleton
    C. Shadow Skeleton

    Best content update
    D. Shrouded Spoils

    Best campaign
    C. Forsaken Shores

    Best Bilge Rat Adventure
    A. Skeleton Thrones

    Best Outpost
    D. Ancient Spires Outpost

    Worst Outpost
    E. Dagger Tooth Outpost

    Best Stronghold Item
    A. Stronghold Skull

    Best Cursed Cannonball
    I. Grogball

    Best Weapon
    A. Cutlass

    Best event in the sky
    D. Lunar Sky

    First thing you do at the beginning of a session
    B. Stocking supplies

    Best Cave
    J. Snake Island

    Best Fortress
    F. The Crow's Nest Fortress

    Best Pond
    D. Mermaid's Hideaway

    Best Environmental FX
    B. Volcano Eruption

    Best Alliance name
    A. The Terrifying Powder Monkeys

    Best Waterfall
    F. Thieves Haven

    Best Shipwreck
    C. The Blackwyche

  • we go:

    Best Area
    A. The Shores of Plenty

    Best Ship/Boat
    B. Brigantine

    Best Trading Company
    C. Merchant Alliance

    Best Emergent Encounter
    A. Megan, you can jump on its back and ride its amazing

    Best Cloud event
    A. Skeleton Fort

    Best Campaign NPC
    Non i think the npc's should be more interactive like in dragon ace now i just press x and dont read and walk on i guess

    Best Shop
    C. Shipwright Shop, i love it to skin the boat

    Best Cursed Chest
    A. Chest of a Thousand Grogs , more easy solo

    Best Instrument
    Non, people are amazing with music they should be able to make their own music so the instruments should be free to play i think. How great a asset to have a crewmember who learned to play thd songs and you could find different songs to learn to play ^^

    Best Gold Hoarder Quest
    A. X-Marks

    Best Merchant Alliance Quest
    A. Animals, the cargo runs irritate me because i need to get empty coups so now i buy them to discard in search of a voyage that gives empty coops -.-

    Best Animal
    A. Chicken, they are funny and bring luck

    Best Cargo
    A. Plants are active camouflage to make boat look like floating island

    Best Skeleton
    C. Shadow Skeleton, its funny to see them run around with different colour lanterns during a fight then i play music its like a party :)

    Best content update
    Non im conservative allergic to change and it takes days of mood changes from confused to demoralized before i fall in love with it and accept it as the new normal.

    Best campaign
    Is there a campaign?

    Best Bilge Rat Adventure
    What is a bilge rat adventure? I really have no idea

    Best Outpost
    D. Ancient Spires Outpost, oh the surprise when you go around the corner and see theres a friggin pirate ship in port and the panic to flee and turn around while you see the hunger in their eyes running to raise anchor and go after you

    Worst Outpost
    F. Galleon's Grave Outpost, i just don't like how it looks

    Best Stronghold Item
    D. Crate of Ancient Bone Dust, i love stuff in merchant crates it fits my roleplay

    Best Cursed Cannonball
    B. Peaceball, stop killing my chickens!

    Best Weapon
    My new pistol i won, i wear it proudly

    Best event in the sky
    The morning when i can finally buy new voyages

    First thing you do at the beginning of a session
    C. Choosing a ship livery

    Best Cave
    A. Sailor's Bounty, lol i discoverd it yesterday i spawned there with a new ship.. its one of my favorite islands because the chickens are on the beach its easy to catch but i never wend inland -.-

    Best Pond
    I cannot answer for as long as we cant fish :(

    Best Environmental FX
    B. Volcano Eruption

    Best Alliance name
    A. The Terrifying Powder Monkeys
    Yeah i dunno really think there should be more freedom for players to choose a combination of words and make a nice ally name and ship names maybe

    Best Waterfall
    They need some work i hardly noticed any? Sound maybe i dunno

    Best Shipwreck
    I love shipwrecks diving its fun but dont know which is best..

  • Best Area
       D. The Devil's Roar

    Best Ship/Boat
       D. Rowboat

    Best Trading Company
       B. Order of Souls

    Best Emergent Encounter
       C. Skeleton Ship (not the cloud event)

    Best Cloud event
       A. Skeleton Fort

    Best Campaign NPC
       B. Wanda/Captain Warsmith

    Best Shop
       E. Bilge Rat Shop

    Best Cursed Chest
       A. Chest of a Thousand Grogs

    Best Instrument
       A. Hurdy-Gurdy

    Best Gold Hoarder Quest
       B. Riddles

    Best Merchant Alliance Quest
       B. Cargo runs

    Best Animal
       A. Chicken

    Best Cargo
       A. Plants

    Best Skeleton
       D. Gold Skeleton

    Best content update
       D. Shrouded Spoils

    Best campaign
       C. Forsaken Shores

    Best Bilge Rat Adventure
       D. Cursed Crews

    Best Outpost
       F. Galleon's Grave Outpost

    Worst Outpost
       B. Golden Sands Outpost

    Best Stronghold Item
       C. Stronghold Powderkeg

    Best Cursed Cannonball
       B. Peaceball

    Best Weapon
       A. Cutlass

    Best event in the sky
       A. Sunset

    First thing you do at the beginning of a session
       B. Stocking supplies

    Best Cave
       K. Thieves Haven

    Best Fortress
       A. Keel Haul

    Best Pond
       D. Mermaid's Hideaway

    Best Environmental FX
       A. Storm

    Best Alliance name
       G. The Undefeated Grog-swiggers

    Best Waterfall
       F. Thieves Haven

    Best Shipwreck
       A. The Killer Whale

    1. Best Area
      B. The Ancient Isles

    2. Best Ship/Boat
      C. Sloop

    3. Best Trading Company
      C. Merchant Alliance
      (This one was tough. Gold Hoarders are great but my smuggler nature fits with the Merchant Alliance better.)

    4. Best Emergent Encounter
      C. Skeleton Ship (not the cloud event)

    5. Best Cloud event
      A. Skeleton Fort
      (Honestly I've never done the ship ones but I have had some good times with my friend at old school forts so it wins my vote)

    6. Best Campaign NPC
      A. Merrick
      (I don't know if it is because he was the first or what but he to this day has a place in my heart. To be fair the warsmith storyline was pretty cool with cool characters but good ol' Merrick...)

    7. Best Shop
      A. Clothing Shop

    8. Best Cursed Chest
      A. Chest of a Thousand Grogs
      (I'd rather struggle to get it on board than curse every moment it's there...)

    9. Best Instrument
      A. Hurdy-Gurdy
      (Psh as if there is any competition. This instrument still has me wanting one in real life...)

    10. Best Gold Hoarder Quest
      B. Riddles
      (This was touch as both can rub the wrong way depending on mood but at the end of the day I like a good riddle)

    11. Best Merchant Alliance Quest
      B. Cargo runs
      (I'm not die hard anti-animal runs like a lot of people but collecting animals doesn't feel merchanty. Cargo Runs hits the nail on the head as far as theme goes)

    12. Best Animal
      A. Chicken
      (If anyone picks anything else they took too many cannonballs to the head)

    13. Best Cargo
      B. Rum Bottles

    14. Best Skeleton
      A. Default Skeleton
      E. A broken one(was going to say a dead one but then realized the irony...)

    15. Best content update
      D. Shrouded Spoils

    16. Best campaign
      A. The Hungering Deep
      (While not perfect by any means the experience I had working with another ship fighting something I had never seen before has yet to be created again despite the fun I have had in other content)

    17. Best Bilge Rat Adventure
      B. Gunpowder Skeletons

    18. Best Outpost
      D. Ancient Spires Outpost

    19. Worst Outpost
      E. Dagger Tooth Outpost

    20. Best Stronghold Item
      A. Stronghold Skull

    21. Best Cursed Cannonball
      F. Anchorball

    22. Best Weapon
      A. Cutlass
      (I like a good flintlock but when you get a good ol' fashion sword fight going on it's pretty magical)

    23. Best event in the sky
      D. Lunar Sky

    24. First thing you do at the beginning of a session
      B. Stocking supplies

    25. Best Cave
      A. Sailor's Bounty

    26. Best Fortress
      B. Hidden Spring Keep
      (I just picked one at random...this is the one area of maps where I have neglected names so I couldn't tell one from the other. It's usually just "the closest fort")

    27. Best Pond
      E. Discovery Ridge

    28. Best Environmental FX
      A. Storm
      (I'm a sucker for some rain)

    29. Best Alliance name
      A. The Terrifying Powder Monkeys

    30. Best Waterfall
      C. Discovery Ridge

    31. Best Shipwreck
      C. The Blackwyche

  • @x-crowheart-x said in Poll time - Which one do you prefer?:

    Best Honorary Write In Category
    32. Best Lantern Flame
    Green - Tops off the eerie legend ghost ship look.

    Definitely the pink ones for me. I have the royal hull and sails, and the hunter figurehead. Love my kick-*ss girl boat.

  • @john-hatter said in Poll time - Which one do you prefer?:

    1. Best Fortress
      B. Hidden Spring Keep
      (I just picked one at random...this is the one area of maps where I have neglected names so I couldn't tell one from the other. It's usually just "the closest fort")

    Me and my friend found an open vault at Lost Gold Fort the other day, and it was full of treasure. So yeah... That's why I picked that one :)

    1. Best Area
      A. The Shores of Plenty

    2. Best Ship/Boat
      B. Brigantine

    3. Best Trading Company
      A. Gold Hoarder

    4. Best Emergent Encounter
      C. Skeleton Ship (not the cloud event)

    5. Best Cloud event
      A. Skeleton Fort

    6. Best Campaign NPC
      A. Merrick

    7. Best Shop
      E. Bilge Rat Shop

    8. Best Cursed Chest
      A. Chest of a Thousand Grogs

    9. Best Instrument
      C. Drum

    10. Best Gold Hoarder Quest
      A. X-Marks

    11. Best Merchant Alliance Quest
      B. Cargo runs

    12. Best Animal
      A. Chicken

    13. Best Cargo
      A. Plants

    14. Best Skeleton
      B. Plant Skeleton

    15. Best content update
      D. Shrouded Spoils

    16. Best campaign
      B. Cursed Sails

    17. Best Bilge Rat Adventure
      B. Gunpowder Skeletons

    18. Best Outpost
      A. Sanctuary Oupost

    19. Worst Outpost
      E. Dagger Tooth Outpost

    20. Best Stronghold Item
      C. Stronghold Powderkeg

    21. Best Cursed Cannonball
      I. Grogball

    22. Best Weapon
      C. Pistol

    23. Best event in the sky
      A. Sunset

    24. First thing you do at the beginning of a session
      B. Stocking supplies

    25. Best Cave
      K. Thieves Haven

    26. Best Fortress
      F. The Crow's Nest Fortress

    27. Best Pond
      K. Paradise Spring

    28. Best Environmental FX
      C. Fog

    29. Best Alliance name
      A. The Terrifying Powder Monkeys

    30. Best Waterfall
      H. Devil's Ridge

    31. Best Shipwreck
      C. The Blackwyche

  • @skulliah said in Poll time - Which one do you prefer?:

    poll time

    Ahoy maties!

    Alright, it's time for a poll and see what prefer the community in Sea of Thieves. As it's a first one, it will be quite long but I can't wait to know your answers, especially for the best cave and waterfall!

    If there is enough traction, I will do some pretty graphs to illustrate your preferences!

    snake

    Here we go:

    1. Best Area
      A. The Shores of Plenty
      B. The Ancient Isles
      C. The Wilds
      D. The Devil's Roar

    2. Best Ship/Boat
      A. Galleon
      B. Brigantine
      C. Sloop
      D. Rowboat

    3. Best Trading Company
      A. Gold Hoarder
      B. Order of Souls
      C. Merchant Alliance

    4. Best Emergent Encounter
      A. Megan
      B. Karen
      C. Skeleton Ship (not the cloud event)

    5. Best Cloud event
      A. Skeleton Fort
      B. Skeleton Ships Battle

    6. Best Campaign NPC
      A. Merrick
      B. Wanda/Captain Warsmith
      C. Salty
      D. Grace/Captain Morrow
      E. Stitcher Jim

    7. Best Shop
      A. Clothing Shop
      B. Equipment Shop
      C. Shipwright Shop
      D. Weaponsmith Shop
      E. Bilge Rat Shop

    8. Best Cursed Chest
      A. Chest of a Thousand Grogs
      B. Chest of Sorrow

    9. Best Instrument
      A. Hurdy-Gurdy
      B. Concertina
      C. Drum

    10. Best Gold Hoarder Quest
      A. X-Marks
      B. Riddles

    11. Best Merchant Alliance Quest
      A. Animals
      B. Cargo runs

    12. Best Animal
      A. Chicken
      B. Pig
      C. Snake

    13. Best Cargo
      A. Plants
      B. Rum Bottles
      C. Clothes

    14. Best Skeleton
      A. Default Skeleton
      B. Plant Skeleton
      C. Shadow Skeleton
      D. Gold Skeleton

    15. Best content update
      A. The Hungering Deep
      B. Cursed Sails
      C. Forsaken Shores
      D. Shrouded Spoils

    16. Best campaign
      A. The Hungering Deep
      B. Cursed Sails
      C. Forsaken Shores

    17. Best Bilge Rat Adventure
      A. Skeleton Thrones
      B. Gunpowder Skeletons
      C. The Sunken Curse
      D. Cursed Crews
      E. Festival of the Damned

    18. Best Outpost
      A. Sanctuary Oupost
      B. Golden Sands Outpost
      C. Plunder Outpost
      D. Ancient Spires Outpost
      E. Dagger Tooth Outpost
      F. Galleon's Grave Outpost

    19. Worst Outpost
      A. Sanctuary Oupost
      B. Golden Sands Outpost
      C. Plunder Outpost
      D. Ancient Spires Outpost
      E. Dagger Tooth Outpost
      F. Galleon's Grave Outpost

    20. Best Stronghold Item
      A. Stronghold Skull
      B. Stronghold Chest
      C. Stronghold Powderkeg
      D. Crate of Ancient Bone Dust

    21. Best Cursed Cannonball
      A. Riggingball
      B. Peaceball
      C. Ballastball
      D. Barrelball
      E. Helmball
      F. Anchorball
      G. Jigball
      H. Venomball
      I. Grogball
      J. Limpball
      K. Wearyball

    22. Best Weapon
      A. Cutlass
      B. Blunderbuss
      C. Pistol
      D. Eye of Reach

    23. Best event in the sky
      A. Sunset
      B. Sunrise
      C. Eclipse
      D. Lunar Sky

    24. First thing you do at the beginning of a session
      A. Set sail
      B. Stocking supplies
      C. Choosing a ship livery
      D. Choosing a voyage

    25. Best Cave
      A. Sailor's Bounty
      B. Smuggler's Bay
      C. Lone Cove
      D. Crescent Isle
      E. Cannon Cove
      F. Mermaid's Hideaway
      G. Wanderer's Refuge (Wanda's Hideout)
      H. Plunder Valley
      I. Shark Bait Cove
      J. Snake Island
      K. Thieves Haven
      L. Crook's Hollow
      M. Devil's Ridge
      N. Ancient Spires Outpost
      O. Sunken Grove
      P. Fetcher's Rest
      Q. Flintlock Peninsula
      R. Ruby's Fall
      S. Morrow's Peak Outpost
      T. Ashen Reaches
      U. K9 Uncharted Island (Skeleton Throne Cave)
      V. N13 Uncharted Island (Merrick's Journal Cave)

    26. Best Fortress
      A. Keel Haul
      B. Hidden Spring Keep
      C. Sailor's Knot Stronghold
      D. Lost Gold Fort
      E. Old Boot Fort
      F. The Crow's Nest Fortress
      G. Skull Keep
      H. Kraken Watchtower
      I. Shark Fin Camp

    27. Best Pond
      A. Crescent Isle
      B. Hidden Spring Keep
      C. Wanderer's Refuge
      D. Mermaid's Hideaway
      E. Discovery Ridge
      F. Shark Bait Cove
      G. Thieves Haven
      H. The Crow's Nest Fortress
      I. Devil's Ridge
      J. Ancient Spires Outpost
      K. Paradise Spring
      L. Kraken's Fall
      M. Sunken Grove
      N. Blind Man's Lagoon
      O. Cursewater Shores
      P. Fetcher's Rest
      Q. Flintlock Peninsula
      R. Devil's Thirst

    28. Best Environmental FX
      A. Storm
      B. Volcano Eruption
      C. Fog

    29. Best Alliance name
      A. The Terrifying Powder Monkeys
      B. The Resolute Scallywags
      C. The Unstoppable Skinflints
      D. The Spirited Landlubbers
      E. The Fearless Soap-dodgers
      F. The Renowned Scoundrels
      G. The Undefeated Grog-swiggers

    30. Best Waterfall
      A. Sailor's Bounty
      B. Crescent Isle
      C. Discovery Ridge
      D. Plunder Valley
      E. Shark Bait Cove
      F. Thieves Haven
      G. Crook's Hollow
      H. Devil's Ridge
      I. Sunken Grove
      J. Fetcher's Rest

    31. Best Shipwreck
      A. The Killer Whale
      B. The Shroudbreaker
      C. The Blackwyche

    snake

    How to answer?

    Write the number of the question with its statement and add below the letter of your answer with its statement. Feel free to add an explanation of your choice if you want, it can be very interesting!

    Here's an example:

    1. Best Area
      D. The Devil's Roar

    2. Best Ship/Boat
      A. Galleon

    You can just copy and paste the whole survey and remove the answers you don't want :)

    One answer per question, if there are several, only the first will be counted.

    SoT

    It's up to you now!

    the shoes of plenty and rowboat

  • Woooo loving all these answers! A lot of hate for our dearest Dagger Tooth Outpost apparently but lots of Blackwyche and Chicken lovers! All your answers have been noted, can't wait to see more. That's really interesting to read your choices! :D

    @x-Crowheart-x There are so many questions that I wanted to add, but the list was starting to be quite long for the forum, it will be for a second edition! :D

    1. Best Area
      A. The Shores of Plenty
      It's the best sea, oh and the Wilds is the worst area.

    2. Best Ship/Boat
      D. Rowboat
      I love it's functionality.

    3. Best Trading Company
      C. Merchant Alliance
      I'm a Merchant Sailor at heart, there's no denying it.

    4. Best Emergent Encounter
      C. Skeleton Ship (not the cloud event)
      Nothing cooler than seeing a skellie ship on the horizon.

    5. Best Cloud event
      B. Skeleton Ships Battle
      The Battles are so intense and they give that ship to ship combat that pvp lacks imo.

    6. Best Campaign NPC
      E. Stitcher Jim
      The guy is like the devil himself but he's a really good character.

    7. Best Shop
      E. Bilge Rat Shop
      One word: Time limited stuff.

    8. Best Cursed Chest
      B. Chest of Sorrow
      😢

    9. Best Instrument
      A. Hurdy-Gurdy
      The thing sounds genuinely great.

    10. Best Gold Hoarder Quest
      A. X-Marks
      Nothing more Piratey that searching for the X marks the spot.

    11. Best Merchant Alliance Quest
      B. Cargo runs
      They're newer so I like em better.

    12. Best Animal
      A. Chicken
      I look after Chickens in the real world so this is a no brainer for me.

    13. Best Cargo
      B. Rum Bottles
      I love how immersing they are.

    14. Best Skeleton
      C. Shadow Skeleton
      I mean like those guys are scary.

    15. Best content update
      D. Shrouded Spoils
      It made the world feel more alive.

    16. Best campaign
      B. Cursed Sails
      Wanda turning bad? Like come on! That was a great campaign.

    17. Best Bilge Rat Adventure
      B. Gunpowder Skeletons
      Boom baby!

    18. Best Outpost
      B. Golden Sands Outpost
      It's the center of all trade in the north!

    19. Worst Outpost
      E. Dagger Tooth Outpost
      *Hate that huge dock, and that massive hike to the trading companies. *

    20. Best Stronghold Item
      A. Stronghold Skull
      The thing looks really cool.

    21. Best Cursed Cannonball
      G. Jigball
      I love watching my guy start dancing in a pressure situation. 😆

    22. Best Weapon
      D. Eye of Reach
      Many because of the Launch Crew Eye of Reach.

    23. Best event in the sky
      A. Sunset
      alttext

    24. First thing you do at the beginning of a session
      C. Choosing a ship livery
      I have to look my best out on the sea.

    25. Best Cave
      A. Sailor's Bounty
      Love how deep it is.

    26. Best Fortress
      B. Hidden Spring Keep
      I like the spring.

    27. Best Pond
      A. Crescent Isle
      alttext

    28. Best Environmental FX
      C. Fog
      The fog music is so Neate.

    29. Best Alliance name
      A. The Terrifying Powder Monkeys
      Love that name. 🐒

    30. Best Waterfall
      G. Crook's Hollow
      Love this water fall.

    31. Best Shipwreck
      A. The Killer Whale
      Don't know where that is but I like the name.


    Thanks for making this @Skulliah!

  • @skulliah

    1. Best Area
      B. The Ancient Isles

    2. Best Ship/Boat
      A. Galleon

    3. Best Trading Company
      B. Order of Souls

    4. Best Emergent Encounter
      A. Megan

    5. Best Cloud Event
      A. Skeleton Fort

    6. Best Campaign NPC
      B. Wanda.Captain Warsmith

    7. Best Shop
      A. Clothing Shop

    8. Best Cursed Chest
      B. Chest of Sorrow

    9. Best Instrument
      A. Hurdy Gurdy

    10. Best Gold Hoarder Quest
      A. X-Marks

    11. Best Merchant Alliance Quest
      B. Cargo Runs

    12. Best Animal
      B. Pig

    13. Best Cargo
      B. Rum Bottles

    14. Best Skeleton
      B. Plant Skeleton

    15. Best Content Update
      D. Shrouded Spoils

    16. Best Campaign
      B. Cursed Sails

    17. Best Bilge Rat Adventure
      B. Gunpowder Skeletons

    18. Best Outpost
      C. Plunder Outpost

    19. Worst Outpost
      E. Dagger Tooth Outpost

    20. Best Stronghold Item
      C. Stronghold Powderkeg

    21. Best Cursed Cannonball
      F. Anchorball

    22. Best Weapon
      A. Cutlass

    23. Best Event in the Sky
      B. Sunrise

    24. First thing you do at the beginning of a session
      B. Stocking supplies

    25. Best Cave
      M. Devil's Ridge

    26. Best Fortress
      E. Old Boot Fort

    27. Best Pond
      I. Devil's Ridge

    28. Best Environmental FX
      A. Storm

    29. Best Alliance Name
      A. The Terrifying Power Monkeys

    30. Best Waterfall
      H. Devil's Ridge

    31. Best Shipwreck
      A. The Killer Whale

  • @skulliah

    Best Area
    A. The Shores of Plenty

    Best Ship/Boat
    C. Sloop

    Best Trading Company
    C. Merchant Alliance

    Best Emergent Encounter
    A. Megan

    Best Cloud event
    A. Skeleton Fort

    Best Campaign NPC
    D. Grace/Captain Morrow

    Best Shop
    A. Clothing Shop

    Best Cursed Chest
    A. Chest of a Thousand Grogs

    Best Instrument
    A. Hurdy-Gurdy

    Best Gold Hoarder Quest
    B. Riddles

    Best Merchant Alliance Quest
    A. Animals

    Best Animal
    A. Chicken

    Best Cargo
    C. Clothes

    Best Skeleton
    B. Plant Skeleton

    Best content update
    D. Shrouded Spoils

    Best campaign
    B. Cursed Sails

    Best Bilge Rat Adventure
    E. Festival of the Damned

    Best Outpost
    A. Sanctuary Oupost

    Worst Outpost
    E. Dagger Tooth Outpost

    Best Stronghold Item
    D. Crate of Ancient Bone Dust

    Best Cursed Cannonball
    C. Ballastball

    Best Weapon
    A. Cutlass

    Best event in the sky
    A. Sunset

    First thing you do at the beginning of a session
    B. Stocking supplies

    Best Cave
    C. Lone Cove

    Best Fortress
    A. Keel Haul

    Best Pond
    D. Mermaid's Hideaway

    Best Environmental FX
    C. Fog

    Best Alliance name
    A. The Terrifying Powder Monkeys

    Best Waterfall
    C. Discovery Ridge

    Best Shipwreck
    C. The Blackwyche

  • @skulliah

    1. Best Area
      A. The Shores of Plenty
      Only just beat out the Devil's Roar, but wall to wall sunshine, azure seas and archetypal desert islands is hard to resist.

    2. Best Ship/Boat
      C. Sloop
      Without a doubt.

    3. Best Trading Company
      B. Order of Souls
      I love the mystical quality and the potential directions this Order could go in and who doesn't love a bit of magic, right?

    4. Best Emergent Encounter
      A. Megan
      Whether she's just cruising along beside you or widening that jaw to take a chunk out of your ship, she's beautiful

    5. Best Cloud event
      A. Skeleton Fort
      Love these, solo or with another crew, or fighting off rivals and skellie ships.

    6. Best Campaign NPC
      E. Stitcher Jim
      I'll put this as number one, again I think it has huge potential and his (spoiler) appearance in the novel just adds to the intrigue surrounding him and his master.

    7. Best Shop
      E. Bilge Rat Shop
      Who doesn't like a shop with new stock every few weeks?

    8. Best Cursed Chest
      A. Chest of a Thousand Grogs
      The audio for this chest always makes me giggle, especially when you jump or collide with something.

    9. Best Instrument
      C. Drum
      I know I know, not very tuneful but I love it.

    10. Best Gold Hoarder Quest
      B. Riddles
      Love the effects and the fact you need to really know the islands to solve them.

    11. Best Merchant Alliance Quest
      A. Animals
      Piggies.

    12. Best Animal
      B. Pig
      See above - in fact the snakes almost put me off playing when they first came out, I really don't like snakes.

    13. Best Cargo
      B. Rum Bottles
      I'm going to say these because they require so much attention, plus the detail you see as they slowly disintegrate with every knock or jar, is amazingly done.

    14. Best Skeleton
      B. Plant Skeleton
      Easy to beat unless they've wandered into the water!

    15. Best content update
      C. Forsaken Shores
      Volcanoes, danger, adventure, flying lava bombs and volcanoes.

    16. Best campaign
      B. Cursed Sails
      Despite the fact I love volcanoes, Cursed Sails story and being able to ally together and beat the Warsmith was priceless, loved every bit of this adventure.

    17. Best Bilge Rat Adventure
      B. Gunpowder Skeletons
      Let the shenanigans begin, and they did!

    18. Best Outpost
      A. Sanctuary Oupost
      I really like the lonely, outer shores feel of this outpost and the sunshine.

    19. Worst Outpost
      D. Ancient Spires Outpost
      Not sure why this is my worst, I think it's the fact that there's not much to find on all the windy paths and not a huge amount of reason to explore there, it is beautiful though.

    20. Best Stronghold Item
      D. Crate of Ancient Bone Dust
      It's that mystical quality about it again, I reckon it ought to have a sort of ethereal glow.

    21. Best Cursed Cannonball
      G. Jigball
      Especially when used on skeletons.

    22. Best Weapon
      A. Cutlass
      Stick 'em with the pointy end, also doesn't need reloading.

    23. Best event in the sky
      A. Sunset
      Just astounding and with the green flash, stunning.

    24. First thing you do at the beginning of a session
      B. Stocking supplies
      After checking the horizon for possible hostile ships.....

    25. Best Cave
      None of these, I love the small cave on Discovery Ridge next to the mermaidy pool that glows in the moonlight but also.....
      V. I also really love the massive cave at N13 which is tricky to find the entrance for but is full of ancient carved stonework.

    26. Best Fortress
      D. Lost Gold Fort
      I think - my favourite is definitely one of the new ones with a windy layout, just adds so much interest.

    27. Best Pond
      D. Mermaid's Hideaway
      Love the fact it disappears into a cave system underneath.

    28. Best Environmental FX
      A. Storm
      Hands down an incredible experience.

    29. Best Alliance name
      A. The Terrifying Powder Monkeys
      The danger is always there..... boom

    30. Best Waterfall
      H. Devil's Ridge
      Spent many happy times jumping down into the pool below and you can store chests behind it at one point.

    31. Best Shipwreck
      B. The Shroudbreaker
      Because of the stories.

  • @skulliah

    1. Best Area
      A. The Shores of Plenty

    2. Best Ship/Boat
      B. Brigantine

    3. Best Trading Company
      B. Order of Souls

    4. Best Emergent Encounter
      A. Megan

    5. Best Cloud event
      A. Skeleton Fort

    6. Best Campaign NPC
      A. Merrick

    7. Best Shop
      E. Bilge Rat Shop

    8. Best Cursed Chest
      A. Chest of a Thousand Grogs

    9. Best Instrument
      C. Drum

    10. Best Gold Hoarder Quest
      B. Riddles

    11. Best Merchant Alliance Quest
      A. Animals

    12. Best Animal
      B. Pig

    13. Best Cargo
      B. Rum Bottles

    14. Best Skeleton
      C. Shadow Skeleton

    15.Best content update
    B. Cursed Sails

    1. Best campaign
      B. Cursed Sails

    2. Best Bilge Rat Adventure
      E. Festival of the Damned

    3. Best Outpost
      A. Sanctuary Oupost

    4. Worst Outpost
      E. Dagger Tooth Outpost

    5. Best Stronghold Item
      D. Crate of Ancient Bone Dust

    6. Best Cursed Cannonball
      C. Ballastball

    22 Best Weapon
    D. Eye of Reach

    1. Best event in the sky
      B. Sunrise

    2. First thing you do at the beginning of a session
      B. Stocking supplies

    3. Best Cave
      F. Mermaid's Hideaway

    4. Best Fortress
      F. The Crow's Nest Fortress

    5. Best Pond
      G. Thieves Haven

    6. Best Environmental FX
      C. Fog

    7. Best Alliance name
      E. The Fearless Soap-dodgers

    8. Best Waterfall
      B. Crescent Isle

    9. Best Shipwreck
      A. The Killer Whale

  • @katttruewalker

    Looks like I forgot Discovery Ridge in the Caves list! I added it with the W letter :D

    S16 was the old location before Forsaken Shores, I think you're referring to the N13 Uncharted Island if it's the one with Merrick's journal in the cave :)

  • @skulliah Ohhh, you could be right then, I'm pretty sure that's the one I just remember the amazing cave/hall :)

  • @skulliah Wheeyyy :D this has loads to choose from! :D well done on this, id love to see the results in graph form! I will even help if you need!

    1. A
    2. A
    3. B
    4. A
    5. B
    6. A
    7. B
    8. B
    9. A
    10. B
    11. B
    12. B
    13. B
    14. D
    15. D
    16. A
    17. B
    18. B
    19. C
    20. A
    21. A
    22. A
    23. A
    24. B
    25. G
    26. F ( @Armament-Jay before it got changed! :P)
    27. C ( @Thor-von-Blitz my poor treasure chests...)
    28. A
    29. B
    30. F
    31. C
  • @dumy2008

    Yes, sure :D

    I'm just waiting to see if it gets enough entries to get interesting graphs. I might need to share it on Reddit or Twitter but it's not like my 3 followers will have a big impact :P

  • @skulliah It's done :)

  • @katttruewalker Aww that's awesome, thank you! :D

    1. Best Area
      A. The Shores of Plenty

    2. Best Ship/Boat
      B. Brigantine

    3. Best Trading Company
      A. Gold Hoarder

    4. Best Emergent Encounter
      C. Skeleton Ship (not the cloud event)

    5. Best Cloud event
      A. Skeleton Fort

    6. Best Campaign NPC
      E. Stitcher Jim

    7. Best Shop
      A. Clothing Shop

    8. Best Cursed Chest
      A. Chest of a Thousand Grogs

    9. Best Instrument
      A. Hurdy-Gurdy

    10. Best Gold Hoarder Quest
      A. X-Marks

    11. Best Merchant Alliance Quest
      A. Animals

    12. Best Animal
      A. Chicken

    13. Best Cargo
      C. Clothes

    14. Best Skeleton
      B. Plant Skeleton

    15. Best content update
      D. Shrouded Spoils

    16. Best campaign
      C. Forsaken Shores

    17. Best Bilge Rat Adventure
      E. Festival of the Damned

    18. Best Outpost
      B. Golden Sands Outpost

    19. Worst Outpost
      E. Dagger Tooth Outpost

    20. Best Stronghold Item
      D. Crate of Ancient Bone Dust

    21. Best Cursed Cannonball
      F. Anchorball

    22. Best Weapon
      A. Cutlass

    23. Best event in the sky
      B. Sunrise

    24. First thing you do at the beginning of a session
      B. Stocking supplies

    25. Best Cave
      B. Smuggler's Bay

    26. Best Fortress
      E. Old Boot Fort

    27. Best Pond
      D. Mermaid's Hideaway

    28. Best Environmental FX
      C. Fog

    29. Best Alliance name
      A. The Terrifying Powder Monkeys

    30. Best Waterfall
      H. Devil's Ridge

    31. Best Shipwreck
      A. The Killer Whale

  • @skulliah

    Best Area
    B. The Ancient Isles
    
    Best Ship/Boat
    A. Galleon
    
    Best Trading Company
    A. Gold Hoarder
    
    Best Emergent Encounter
    B. Karen
    
    Best Cloud event
    A. Skeleton Fort
    
    Best Campaign NPC
    C. Salty
    
    Best Shop
    E. Bilge Rat Shop
    
    Best Cursed Chest
    B. Chest of Sorrow
    
    Best Instrument
    A. Hurdy-Gurdy
    
    Best Gold Hoarder Quest
    A. X-Marks
    
    Best Merchant Alliance Quest
    B. Cargo runs
    
    Best Animal
    A. Chicken
    
    Best Cargo
    C. Clothes
    
    Best Skeleton
    Too difficult to answer
    
    Best content update
    D. Shrouded Spoils
    
    Best campaign
    B. Cursed Sails
    
    Best Bilge Rat Adventure
    B. Gunpowder Skeletons
    
    Best Outpost
    D. Ancient Spires Outpost
    
    Worst Outpost
    E. Dagger Tooth Outpost
    
    Best Stronghold Item
    C. Stronghold Powderkeg
    
    Best Cursed Cannonball
    C. Ballastball
    
    Best Weapon
    A. Cutlass
    
    Best event in the sky
    C. Eclipse
    
    First thing you do at the beginning of a session
    B. Stocking supplies
    
    Best Cave
    A. Sailor's Bounty
    
    Best Fortress
    D. Lost Gold Fort
    
    Best Pond
    D. Mermaid's Hideaway
    
    Best Environmental FX
    C. Fog
    
    Best Alliance name
    A. The Terrifying Powder Monkeys
    
    Best Waterfall
    D. Plunder Valley
    
    Best Shipwreck
    I have no clue
    

    What about worst stronghold item? Stronghold chest. MA is way too good now. Chest needs to be buffed a lot and skull needs a minor buff to keep them all in line.

    1. Best Area
      A. Shores of Plenty
    2. Best Ship/Boat
      B. Brigantine
    3. Best Trading Company
      C. Merchant Alliance
    4. Best Emergent Encounter
      C. Skeleton Ships
    5. Best Cloud event
      B. Skeleteon Ships....again
    6. Best Campaign NPC
      It's really Shelly at GSO but
      A. Merrick
    7. Best Shop
      E. Bilge Rate Shop (not really a shop)
    8. Best Cursed Chest
      A. Chest of Grog
    9. Best Instrument
      C. Drum
    10. Best Gold Hoarder Quest
      B. Riddles
    11. Best Merchant Alliance Quest
      A. Animals
    12. Best Animal
      A. Chicken
    13. Best Cargo
      C. Cloth (it's not clothing)
    14. Best Skeleton
      C. Shadow Skeleton
    15. Best Content Update
      D. Shrouded Spoils (it was hunger b4 it)
    16. Best Campaign
      A. The Hungering Deep
    17. Best Bilge Rat Adventure
      B. Gunpoweder Skeletons
    18. Best Outpost
      B. Golden Sands Outpost (most of events took place there)
    19. Worst Outpost
      E. Dagger Tooth Outpost (if they open that bay it'd be hands down the best.)
    20. Best Stronghold Item
      D. Crate of Ancient Bone Dust
    21. Best Cursed Cannonball
      A. Riggingball
    22. Best Weapon
      A. Cutlass (cmon really?)
    23. Best event in the sky
      C. Eclipse (i like rarity in games)
    24. First thing you do at the beginning of a session
      B. Stocking supplies
    25. Best Cave
      A. Sailor's Bounty (i smell a dungeon here)
    26. Best Fortress
      D. Lost Gold Fort
    27. Best Pond (really?)
      O. Cursewater Shores
    28. Best Environmental FX
      C. Fog (it's my home)
    29. Best Alliance Name
      G. The Undefeated Grog-swiggers
    30. Best Waterfall
      H. Devil's Ridge
    31. Best Shipwreck (finally last 1)
      B. The Killer Whale (bc it was a secret they never mentioned and you'd had to find it)
88
Posts
24.2k
Views
20 out of 88