With Lost Sands ending tomorrow, there should be deliberations on potential agreements and concessions between the two sides. Obviously, we won't know who wins until tomorrow, but I think a sit-down meeting between the Reapers and the Hunters/Pirate Legends should be arranged in the immediate future.
Here's what I would propose if the Reaper's win: the Hunters/Pirate Legends shall allow a water bridge between Golden Sands and the Reaper's Hideout. (call it PotBeard's Corridor. @CptnPotBeard) No other pirates other then Reapers should be allowed to use this narrow stretch of water so long as the Hunters/Pirate Legends are allowed access to the West (including Sea Dog's Rest and Crescent Isle) and the South around Wander's Refuge. Twin Groves shall become a satellite island for the Reapers to use at their disposal.
My proposal if the Hunters/Pirate Legends win: The Reapers shall relinquish control over Golden Sands and allow us to rebuild the outpost. The Reapers shall also suspend any and all supernatural activities (including any future actions within the Sea of the Damned). If the Reapers continue their bombardment of Golden Sands or if they resume their supernatural activities, they shall be faced with strict treasure tariffs at any of the outposts within the Sea of Thieves (excluding the Reaper's Hideout).
I believe these terms are fair given what has transpired these last two weeks.
In all seriousness, this was a lot of fun! Happy sailing guys!